IceTV Forum

IceTV Applications => Smart Recording website and General questions => Topic started by: prl on November 19, 2008, 01:21:44 PM

Title: Recommendations recommending shows that aren't running
Post by: prl on November 19, 2008, 01:21:44 PM
My Recommendations list currently contains ten entries. Of those,

The Hollowmen,
Doctor Who,
Grand Designs, and
Top Gear Australia

appear to be shows that aren't actually running. Certainly the IceTV EPG thinks not. They all return: "Not upcoming in the next 7 days" when I search for them in the Guide. Refreshing the Recommendations page in my browser doesn't change the list.

So... of my ten current recommendations, four aren't showing, and four are shows that I already know I'm interested in, because I've marked them either as Favorites or as Recordings.

And I'm still waiting to see my first Recommendation of a one-off show.
Title: Re: Recommendations recommending shows that aren't running
Post by: Marc on November 19, 2008, 02:41:32 PM
Both of these issues are being addressed in an update to the Recommendations system. Now we have Keyword recording released, it's the next thing in our sights.
Title: Re: Recommendations recommending shows that aren't running
Post by: prl on November 19, 2008, 02:54:38 PM
Thanks.
Title: Re: Recommendations recommending shows that aren't running
Post by: prl on February 09, 2009, 09:45:39 AM
Quote from: Marc-IceTV on November 19, 2008, 02:41:32 PM
Both of these issues are being addressed in an update to the Recommendations system. Now we have Keyword recording released, it's the next thing in our sights.
How's that going? Nothing much seems to have changed in my recommendations.

My current list is recommending 3 shows that aren't currently showing:
Enough Rope
The Hollowmen
Top Gear Australia

It's recommending three shows that are already set as favorites or recordings:
Grand Designs
Spicks and Specks
The Hollowmen

That leaves five out of ten recommendations that are potentially of any use to me. All of those 5 are shows that I've watched in the past, but that I'm no longer interested in.

When I remove the recommendations that I think are irrelevant (all but one), it doesn't fill in another 9 recommendations, it just shows the one. I think it would be more useful if deleting a recommendation was taken to be a "thanks, but no thanks, try something else". "Reset all recommendations" then just brings me back to the same list as before.
Title: Re: Recommendations recommending shows that aren't running
Post by: Russell at IceTV on February 27, 2009, 10:11:36 AM
Hi, sorry for the delay on this, and thanks for the feedback.

We're working on this again now, and have already made a few changes.  First, we've removed the programs that aren't currently being aired from the recommendations data.  We've also changed the "Recommendations" page so that it only lists series that have shows scheduled in the next 7 days, on your channels.  So hopefully it should never show you a series that you don't truly have upcoming shows for.

The piece that's missing at the moment is that when you hide a recommendation, it's not being removed from the data used for calculating new recommendations for you -- it's just being hidden from your list, as you said.  What really needs to happen is that it has an immediate effect, and you get new recommendations that are more accurate, based on your input about what you don't like.  Right now the system is more geared towards what you do like, so the negative input needs to be factored in better.  We're looking into the best way of getting that negative input working better, and I'll get back to you when I have more info.

Thanks,
Russell
Title: Re: Recommendations recommending shows that aren't running
Post by: prl on February 27, 2009, 02:08:25 PM
Thanks, Russell. All the shows in my recommendations are now shows that are currently airing.

One other thing I'd like to see is to have shows that I've already marked as favorites or for series recordings removed from the recommendations. They should still be used as input to the recommendations algorithm. Four of my current 9 (I'm sure it used to be 10!) recommendations are shows that I've marked as either favorites or as recordings. I get 9 shows in the recommendations list even after doing "Reset all recommendations". If this isn't a universal preference, than perhaps make it configurable.

If I exclude a show from my recommendations, all that seems to do is reduce the number of recommendations.

If negative input is hard to implement, would it be easier to simply list the top ten shows that come out of the recommendations algorithm after excluding any I've set as favorites or recordings, and any shows I've marked to remove from recommendations. I think it would be useful to somehow be able to distinguish "reasonable choice, but I'm not interested in that particular show at the moment" from "bad choice". The first probably shouldn't affect the recommendations algorithm, but the latter probably should.

At the moment, all my recommendations are either shows that I've set as favorites or recordings, or shows that I have watched in the past, but that I'm no longer interested in. And there's no way I can change that in a way that's useful to me.

I'm still yet to have a movie recommended to me. Has anyone?
Title: Re: Recommendations recommending shows that aren't running
Post by: Marc on February 27, 2009, 05:56:32 PM
Quote from: prl on February 27, 2009, 02:08:25 PMFour of my current 9 (I'm sure it used to be 10!
A quick note: We're working on showing a lot more recommendations than 9 (or 10).
Title: Re: Recommendations recommending shows that aren't running
Post by: prl on February 27, 2009, 10:51:00 PM
Quote from: Marc at IceTV on February 27, 2009, 05:56:32 PM
Quote from: prl on February 27, 2009, 02:08:25 PMFour of my current 9 (I'm sure it used to be 10!
A quick note: We're working on showing a lot more recommendations than 9 (or 10).
Thanks, Marc. I appreciate the feedback.

This has the potential to be a great feature in Ice, but (as you can probably guess) I think it has some way to go.
Title: Re: Recommendations recommending shows that aren't running
Post by: Marc on February 27, 2009, 11:50:29 PM
Quote from: prl on February 27, 2009, 10:51:00 PMThis has the potential to be a great feature in Ice, but (as you can probably guess) I think it has some way to go.
That's our opinion too. :)
Title: Re: Recommendations recommending shows that aren't running
Post by: prl on May 12, 2009, 09:51:43 AM
Quote from: Marc at IceTV on February 27, 2009, 05:56:32 PM
Quote from: prl on February 27, 2009, 02:08:25 PMFour of my current 9 (I'm sure it used to be 10!
A quick note: We're working on showing a lot more recommendations than 9 (or 10).

Hi Marc. I've noticed that non-running programs now seem to be being excluded from Recommendations. Thanks.

However, this seems to have been done by generating an initial list of 9 or 10 favorites, and then removing any that aren't running. I don't know this for sure, because IceTV doesn't tell us how the recommendations list is constructed. This seems to have the opposite effect to your desire to show "a lot more recommendations than 9 (or 10)."

Of the 7 shows in my Recommended list, 3 are ones that I have marked as either Favourites or for Recordings (or both). I don't need the Recommendations system to tell me that I might like shows that I've told it I like. I can't see why it was ever thought that showing Favourites or Recordings in the Recommended list was ever a good idea. The remaining 4 are programs that I have watched in the past, but that I'm no longer interested in. I can exclude these from my Recommended list, but as before, all that does is reduce the number of recommendations from 7 to 3. The three remaining are the ones I already record or have marked as Favorites.

The Recommendations system is still not telling me anything useful.

I'm also still yet to see a Recommendation for any one-off show. My question to other readers about whether they'd ever seen one was met with silence. Can IceTV look at their system and see whether anyone has a one-off show in their Recommended list?
Title: Re: Recommendations recommending shows that aren't running
Post by: Vortical on May 12, 2009, 10:13:38 AM
Peter

Definately no One Off Shows here in my recommendations list after I reset it.

I've cancelled most of them though as not really interested in what it brought up.