IceTV Forum

IceTV Guide for IceTV enabled PVRs => SKIPPA => Topic started by: TimC on October 29, 2015, 01:44:08 PM

Title: What Happens with Skippa when all the Dust Settles
Post by: TimC on October 29, 2015, 01:44:08 PM
I thought I would put this one up to scope a way forward for all the Skippa users (enthusiasts?)

From what I see, those who own Skippas have, what could have been one of the best PVRs available but with the following drawbacks.
* no warranty
* virtually no Tech support
* no ongoing development
* totally dependant on the IceTV EPG subscription
* a little buggy

From what I understand the 1.1.10604 Firmware is the most recent and the final firmware that will be provided.

While all this looks fairly grim, the reality is the Skippa is still a pretty functional unit.
* Its well integrated with the IceTV EPG. I don't seem to be getting get failed timers now.
* Addskip works fairly reliably. There's a couple of things I'd like improved, but oh well!!!
* it gives us Catchup TV
* three tuners is handy
* I love the way the padding works i.e. a bit before and after is recorded even if there is a timer immediatly following.
I'm sure there are lots of other things we all like.

I intend to keep my Skippa as long as it continues to be reliable.

Be that as it may I have a number of questions:

Will we be able to continue with the Skippa forum here, or will it have to be moved?
  I have heard that It may have to be moved as the Skippa dosen't really have anything to do with the New IceTV company.

What is the best way to structure the forum?
  Its current structure is based on IceTV supporting the Skippa. Now that that will not happen, there may be a better way to organise it. e.g. There's no point having a Wish List section if no one is going to do any development.  The same goes for the Firmware section.
  I also note that no one is reporting bugs any longer. Is that because they aren't being found or have we all just given up?
  What bug workarounds have been found? It would be handy if all the workarounds could be found in one place, instread of hunting through hundreds of bug reports. Similarly a list of known bugs with the current firmware will be handy for the future.
 
What support does the New IceTV intend to provide?
  A couple of IceTV staff do seem to be looking at the Skippa posts at the moment and providing often valuable support. A thousand thanks by the way.
  Will this support continue or is it just that the support is being provided in there own time?
  What will happen in the future if some change in the EPG service causes problems with the Skippas?
  Is the New IceTV committed to ensuring that the EPG service will continue to work with the Skippas?

Are there people (i.e other forum members) capable of providing Technical Support?
I have seen that Warkus has been helping out a few people and has opened up at least one, but he can't be expected to provide technical support to all of us without compensation of some sort.

How many Skippas are out there anyway?
  Are there enough Skippas in use to make providing technical support as a business worthwhile?

Is there a way forward firmware wise?
  Are there Intellectual Property issues?
  Can a person with programming skills do work on it without being sued?
  Is there someone out there with the skills?
  Could someone do some work on it and sell an update without being sued?

Sometimes car enthusiasts can keep an obscure model running for years after you would expect all of them to be on a scrap heap somewhere.
Perhaps we Skippa enthusiasts can keep our units running for a reasonable time as well.

What are your thoughts?
Title: Re: What Happens with Skippa when all the Dust Settles
Post by: MB4913 on October 29, 2015, 02:00:19 PM
I support the OP 100%. Even with the limitations described above, in combination with IceTV, the Skippa is a fantastic PVR. I would love it if a co-operative of some sort could be formed to support the existing users.

Apparently there are a few thousand more Skippas that have been manufactured and are being held in a warehouse somewhere. If they could somehow be released, there would be a reasonably large user base.
Title: Re: What Happens with Skippa when all the Dust Settles
Post by: warkus on October 29, 2015, 02:03:06 PM
They won't be...

Definitely not as skippas anyway...
Title: Re: What Happens with Skippa when all the Dust Settles
Post by: JPP on October 29, 2015, 02:41:50 PM
I don't have answers to most if not all of your questions.

For now though, I'll add that I've just become a proud owner of a Skippa that the previous owner didn't want any more. As promised by him, it appears to be in perfect working order. He was happy with it, but didn't want to pay for an ICETV subscription.

I took note of what Warkus posted re the high temperature the SOC IC runs and confirmed that out in the open, i.e. not in an enclosed cabinet and with nothing on top of it, it runs at around 65-70 deg C (ambient 25 deg C). It runs about 10 deg cooler when the unit is in Standby, i.e. the video output is turned OFF.

As I'm going to be putting it in a cabinet, I've added a small 40mm fan inside the unit directly in front of the SOC IC heat sink. The noise level is almost imperceptible - and less than what the HDU makes.

The heat-sink temperature under the same condition, i.e. the unit out in the open (but lid in place as before) has dropped to 45 deg. Ambient temperature still at 25 deg C.

It does of course run 24/7 as there is no deep standby in the Skippa, unlike the Beyonwiz T2, to which I've also added the same fan. The T2 (with a 3rd tuner USB tuner) case is almost the same size as the Skippa and is supplied fan-less too. The HDD puts out very little heat in comparison to the SOC IC, so even if you were to put in an SDD drive, it would only reduce the overall case temperature slightly and do nothing for the SOC chip temperature.

I'll be running these two PVRs in parallel when I've got them both fully configured. So far impressions are too preliminary to comment really - if there is sufficient interest I could post these later - perhaps Whirlpool might be the best place to do this? Dave/Daniel?
Title: Re: What Happens with Skippa when all the Dust Settles
Post by: JPP on October 29, 2015, 02:43:10 PM
Quote from: warkus on October 29, 2015, 02:03:06 PM
They won't be...

Definitely not as skippas anyway...
Perhaps as Altech 9600-ICETV or 9600+. It would then be no different to any other ICETV enabled PVR, but with the benefit of having the best implementation of ICETV. Not sure if the ad-skipping would still exist or enabled - maybe that would be a risk that UEC would not be willing to be exposed to wrt being taken to court over it.
Title: Re: What Happens with Skippa when all the Dust Settles
Post by: Paul55 on October 29, 2015, 02:51:02 PM
Quote from: JPP on October 29, 2015, 02:43:10 PM

Perhaps as Altech 9600-ICETV or 9600+. It would then be no different to any other ICETV enabled PVR, but with the benefit of having the best implementation of ICETV. Not sure if the ad-skipping would still exist or enabled - maybe that would be a risk that UEC would not be willing to be exposed to wrt being taken to court over it.

I very much doubt there will be any love or cooperation between IceTV and Altech
Title: Re: What Happens with Skippa when all the Dust Settles
Post by: warkus on October 29, 2015, 03:03:58 PM
I agree 100% Paul. If indeed altech are the reason for the icetv demise, I cant see any further cooperation between these parties. Its unlikely at best anyway.

Who knows. Stranger things have happened.

Title: Re: What Happens with Skippa when all the Dust Settles
Post by: IanL-S on October 29, 2015, 03:05:19 PM
Quote from: Paul55 on October 29, 2015, 02:51:02 PM
I very much doubt there will be any love or cooperation between IceTV and Altech

Yes that is a strong possibility. However, they say money talks .... the big question will it outweigh the past "animosity"?

What happens to the warehoused SKIPPAs is a matter for the Administrators and Altech. The question of warranty support aside, it would be in Altech's interest to get them out of the warehouse, and the old IceTV to get a possibly token payment for the licensing of intellectual property. If they are sold as SKIPPAs than there would be some hope of furture firmware updates (excluding ad-skipping).

In situations such as these you do not always see rational behaviour.

Ian
Title: Re: What Happens with Skippa when all the Dust Settles
Post by: Stalky on October 29, 2015, 03:06:40 PM
As far as extra support goes, I think Dave from IceTV mentioned that a lot of the staff (previous staff?) had Skippas so I would assume they would be keen to contribute to keeping the Skippa dream alive.
Title: Re: What Happens with Skippa when all the Dust Settles
Post by: IanL-S on October 29, 2015, 03:10:53 PM
Once the ozSKIPPA wiki is up an running (someone is not pulling his/her weight in the process of getting it sorted) there will be a more structured way of presenting information about the SKIPPA than is possible via a forum. This can be seen by comparing the Topfield Australia Forum to the oztoppy wiki (http://oztoppy.wikidot.com/).

Ian
Title: Re: What Happens with Skippa when all the Dust Settles
Post by: Carljh on October 29, 2015, 03:18:30 PM
Excellent post, TimC
Title: Re: What Happens with Skippa when all the Dust Settles
Post by: Dave at IceTV on October 29, 2015, 04:12:50 PM
Quote from: TimC on October 29, 2015, 01:44:08 PM
What support does the New IceTV intend to provide?
  Is the New IceTV committed to ensuring that the EPG service will continue to work with the Skippas?

The Skippa is still an IceTV compatible PVR so will continue to get the same support as other IceTV compatible recorders.
Title: Re: What Happens with Skippa when all the Dust Settles
Post by: TimC on October 29, 2015, 05:35:33 PM
Quote from: JPP on October 29, 2015, 02:41:50 PM
I took note of what Warkus posted re the high temperature the SOC IC runs and confirmed that out in the open, i.e. not in an enclosed cabinet and with nothing on top of it, it runs at around 65-70 deg C (ambient 25 deg C). It runs about 10 deg cooler when the unit is in Standby, i.e. the video output is turned OFF.

I am curious what is the best way to use the Skippa.  I am yet to have a freeze, so I usually don't resteart it often.

I have heard a school of thought that says that integrated circuits that are often turned on and off have a shorter lifespan than those that are running all the time as the heating up and cooling cycle causes mechanical stresses to the chip especially larger ones.

Which do you think would be worse, running the chip continuously at a high temperature of giving it a chance to cool down from time to time by turning it off when you are not using it?
Title: Re: What Happens with Skippa when all the Dust Settles
Post by: Paul55 on October 29, 2015, 06:30:20 PM
High temperature + computers (such as a PVR) = component failures
Title: Re: What Happens with Skippa when all the Dust Settles
Post by: Heideho on October 29, 2015, 06:41:58 PM
I'm definitely nervous about all the talk about overheating of the Skippa. Apart from the clock stopping which hasn't re-manifested itself since the firmware upgrade I'm pretty happy with performance to date. It's a hugely better interface than my old Topfields and I am hoping it continues to run. Appreciate the support that's proposed by the community here even though I hope that I don't need it.

Thanks!
Title: Re: What Happens with Skippa when all the Dust Settles
Post by: IanL-S on October 29, 2015, 06:48:31 PM
Quote from: Paul55 on October 29, 2015, 06:30:20 PM
High temperature + computers (such as a PVR) = component failures

It is so! Older Topfield PVRs (SD and the 7000, 7100 - not the plus) had big problems with heat. In part due to poor quality of the caps on the power supply pcb, and also because the internal HDDs put out a lot of heat. I had power board pcb fail on my 5000 Masterpiece.

As to heat, you could try placing the SKIPPA on a laptop comupter stand -- they have fans that may help although absence of vents on the bottom of the case is not very helpful. Small fans on the top, or inside as done by Phil will reduce the heat build-up appreciably.

Ian
Title: Re: What Happens with Skippa when all the Dust Settles
Post by: Twisterinc on October 30, 2015, 12:04:27 AM
Don't know if this has been answered elsewhere but is the autoskip function still enabled and working on the Skippa? Mine says it is still processing a show that was recorded on the 10th October... All new shows are recorded without autoskip...
Title: Re: What Happens with Skippa when all the Dust Settles
Post by: TimC on October 30, 2015, 12:15:14 AM
Quote from: Twisterinc on October 30, 2015, 12:04:27 AM
Don't know if this has been answered elsewhere but is the autoskip function still enabled and working on the Skippa? Mine says it is still processing a show that was recorded on the 10th October... All new shows are recorded without autoskip...
Autoskip works fine as long as you have downloaded and installed the latest firmware 1.1.10604. 
The auto update wild not load it as it is not really supported by the New IceTV.

Check out the firmware threads.  There is a link to the download page and instructions there. Its quite easy to do. 

All you need is a thumb drive
Title: Re: What Happens with Skippa when all the Dust Settles
Post by: Twisterinc on October 30, 2015, 01:50:25 AM
Quote from: TimC on October 30, 2015, 12:15:14 AM
Quote from: Twisterinc on October 30, 2015, 12:04:27 AM
Don't know if this has been answered elsewhere but is the autoskip function still enabled and working on the Skippa? Mine says it is still processing a show that was recorded on the 10th October... All new shows are recorded without autoskip...
Autoskip works fine as long as you have downloaded and installed the latest firmware 1.1.10604. 
The auto update wild not load it as it is not really supported by the New IceTV.

Check out the firmware threads.  There is a link to the download page and instructions there. Its quite easy to do. 

All you need is a thumb drive

All done. See how it goes now...
Title: Re: What Happens with Skippa when all the Dust Settles
Post by: TimC on October 30, 2015, 10:45:03 AM
One of the things I mentioned in the initial post was the Intellectual property rights of the Firmware.

Can someone in the know provide some insight?
Title: Re: What Happens with Skippa when all the Dust Settles
Post by: nis200sx on November 04, 2015, 03:48:05 PM
Quote from: TimC on October 30, 2015, 12:15:14 AM
Autoskip works fine as long as you have downloaded and installed the latest firmware 1.1.10604. 

Yes it does. But even if my Skippa stopped working as a PVR I'd probably keep it as a Plex media player and for catchup TV. It is hands down the best catchup TV player I've tried.

Title: Re: What Happens with Skippa when all the Dust Settles
Post by: gibster on November 05, 2015, 12:59:24 AM
Would have been really nice to have gotten one   :(
Title: Re: What Happens with Skippa when all the Dust Settles
Post by: IanL-S on November 05, 2015, 09:37:34 AM
Quote from: TimC on October 30, 2015, 10:45:03 AM
One of the things I mentioned in the initial post was the Intellectual property rights of the Firmware.

Can someone in the know provide some insight?

I can only speculate. As the firmware is substantially based on the Altech 9600, Altech would presumably own the firmware and have licensed its use in a modified form to the old IceTV for use on the SKIPPA. I would expect that the firmware modules ralating to SKIPPA and IceTV features would be owned by the old IceTV.

The big stumbling block to new firmware is that it appears that only Altech has the complier that packages the firmware so it can be loaded onto the Toppy. So, as far as firmware goes, that is probably the end of the story.

Ian
Title: Re: What Happens with Skippa when all the Dust Settles
Post by: payandwait on November 08, 2015, 01:22:43 PM
if anyone wants to buy my Skippa let me know.
NOT paying for a subscription as i was supposed to get lifetime subscription with the unit.
email me on jtr6163@gmail.com
;D

so the unit is as new with box and all.

cheers
Title: Re: What Happens with Skippa when all the Dust Settles
Post by: TimC on November 08, 2015, 07:57:32 PM
Quote from: payandwait on November 08, 2015, 01:22:43 PM
NOT paying for a subscription as i was supposed to get lifetime subscription with the unit.

So you feel that getting all your money from PayPal back means that you can stand on your principles to refuse paying the EPG subscription, but then sell the unit that you told PayPal had no value to someone else.
I suppose you are looking for $417 as well.

Putting your $417 into subscriptions would have given you 4 years of EPG.  Perhaps the Skippa will still be running then. I'm actually beginning to wonder if FTA TV will still be there then.

Seriously though, I hope you get your sale from someone on the forum that understands what they are buying.

I did see a post the other day from someone that seemed to be wishing they had one.
Title: Re: What Happens with Skippa when all the Dust Settles
Post by: TimC on November 14, 2015, 10:29:52 AM
Quote from: IanL-S on November 05, 2015, 09:37:34 AM
The big stumbling block to new firmware is that it appears that only Altech has the complier that packages the firmware so it can be loaded onto the Toppy. So, as far as firmware goes, that is probably the end of the story.

I just had a thought. I doubt if Altech would ever deal with IceTV again, but I wonder if they would deal with a group of Skippa owners.

Title: Re: What Happens with Skippa when all the Dust Settles
Post by: Paul55 on November 14, 2015, 04:38:45 PM
Quote from: TimC on November 14, 2015, 10:29:52 AM
I doubt if Altech would ever deal with IceTV again, but I wonder if they would deal with a group of Skippa owners.

This statement presupposes that Altech was the aggrieved partner in the Skippa debacle. Remember, Altech made what seems a hasty decision to exit the Australian market. It doesn't seem unlikely that they were the ones who wanted out of the agreement.
Title: Re: What Happens with Skippa when all the Dust Settles
Post by: TimC on November 14, 2015, 07:04:23 PM
Quote from: Paul55 on November 14, 2015, 04:38:45 PM
This statement presupposes that Altech was the aggrieved partner in the Skippa debacle.
I'm not suggesting who was aggrieved, just business. Generally you don't do business with a company that a deal went sour on.
I am just suggesting that they may be more willing to deal with someone representing a group of people that own one of their products. 
If we could find someone that new enough to fiddle with the code, Altech may be willing to run their compiler over it.
Title: Re: What Happens with Skippa when all the Dust Settles
Post by: Paul55 on November 14, 2015, 11:23:26 PM
Quote from: TimC on November 14, 2015, 07:04:23 PM
willing to deal with someone representing a group of people that own one of their products. 

Could be worth a try. Then we could get a sense of what sort of character Altech has.