Silent Witness
'The World Cruise'
9Gem, 8:40pm, Tue, 8 Dec 2015, 70 minutes
and
Silent Witness
'The World Cruise - Part 2'
9Gem, 9:50pm, Tue, 8 Dec 2015, 70 minutes
I am confused for two reasons. Firstly, this is now on GEM, whereas it used to be on the ABC. So, is it "new" to Gem only?
Secondly, if it is indeed new, then how come that out of the two episodes one is repeat the other is not?
Given the cast and the year it was made, they would both be a repeat (previously shown on ABC). Not sure if it has previously been shown on 9Gem.
Ian
Quote from: IanL-S on December 08, 2015, 06:57:34 AM
Given the cast and the year it was made, they would both be a repeat (previously shown on ABC). Not sure if it has previously been shown on 9Gem.
Ian
Still hasn't been changed by IceTV
The sorts of things are always a dilemma. I think that IceTV have chosen to shows previously shown on other channels but run for the first time on another as first runs.
There are a lot of people that have never bothered to even look at the ABC.
Quote from: TimC on December 08, 2015, 11:01:37 PM
The sorts of things are always a dilemma. I think that IceTV have chosen to shows previously shown on other channels but run for the first time on another as first runs.
Well, firstly, that never used to be the case. They prided themselves on showing everything that has played before as repeat (for instance The Big Bang Theory on 7), whether or not it was on a different network.
Secondly, if that is what they are doing, as this particular show is made up of two episodes, why mark the first as repeat and not the second?
Quote from: TimC on December 08, 2015, 11:01:37 PM
There are a lot of people that have never bothered to even look at the ABC.
Well, I suspect that those people wouldn't have it set in IceTV as a series recording ;D
Quote from: csutak40 on December 09, 2015, 12:49:13 AM
Well, firstly, that never used to be the case. They prided themselves on showing everything that has played before as repeat (for instance The Big Bang Theory on 7), whether or not it was on a different network.
This has not been my experience. e.g. Law and Order was reported as first Runs when Seven ran reruns previously shown on Ten a few years ago.
Quote from: csutak40 on December 09, 2015, 12:49:13 AM
Well, I suspect that those people wouldn't have it set in IceTV as a series recording ;D
This actually reinforces my point. Those people would set a new series recording when it came up on a commercial station expecting the episodes to be first runs.
Setting IceTV to record the first runs only a particular channel can resolve the problem. Just what constitutes a rerun anyway.
If Nine Melbourne runs an episode and Prime doesn't, Is it a Rerun? Can IceTV successfully keep track of all the possible permutations?
As I said it can be a dilemma.
I think I may have found a clue to what's happening. IMDB shows Silent Witness 'Two Below Zero' as being a 120-min telemovie. If it was shown that way when it was on the ABC, the IceGuide would need some re-jigging to handle it being shown as two parts, as it is being done on Gem.
There's a hint of this in the IceGuide titles: the first part is titled (ACT IceGuide) as Silent Witness (2001) 'Two Below Zero', while the second part is titled Silent Witness 'Two Below Zero (Part 2)' [my emphasis].
Perhaps the first part is matching with the earlier ABC showing, but the second part isn't.
Quote from: TimC on December 09, 2015, 08:17:59 AM...
As I said it can be a dilemma.
No doubt. But why is the first part shown as a repeat, but the second part is shown as a first run? Unless the ABC left their audience hanging as to whodunnit. Though it shouldn't have been too much of a problem for the audience; they need only have applied the rule "Sam Ryan Is Always Right" ;)
Quote from: csutak40 on December 09, 2015, 12:49:13 AM...
Well, I suspect that those people wouldn't have it set in IceTV as a series recording ;D
I have Silent Witness set as a series recording (from when it was shown on the ABC), and I'm not getting any recordings of it showing up for the episodes on Gem.
And another oddity. As I noted above, there are two different titles for the Gem instance of the series: "Silent Witness (2001)" and "Silent Witness". My series recording has yet another series title: "Silent Witness (1996)". According to IMDB, 1966 is indeed the year that Silent Witness first ran.
Maybe we need to get Sam Ryan in on the case ;)
Peter I am getting them for 9Gem. Are you sure you did not limit episodes to ABC? I use different PVR for ABC/SBS/Ten and Seven/Nine, so I specify networks to be 'searched'.
Ian
Quote from: IanL-S on December 09, 2015, 12:02:22 PM
Peter I am getting them for 9Gem. Are you sure you did not limit episodes to ABC? I use different PVR for ABC/SBS/Ten and Seven/Nine, so I specify networks to be 'searched'.
Ian
Yeah, I think that must be the reason.
BTW, looks like John doesn't work weekends any longer either. So, if no one is at the wheel on weekends, that could cause lots of mistakes in the schedule.
Quote from: IanL-S on December 09, 2015, 12:02:22 PM
Peter I am getting them for 9Gem. Are you sure you did not limit episodes to ABC?
You're right. I just looked at the series recording and it's ABC only. It was set up a long time ago, so I don't know why I did it that way.
Quote from: IanL-S on December 09, 2015, 12:02:22 PM
I use different PVR for ABC/SBS/Ten and Seven/Nine, so I specify networks to be 'searched'.
...
I use different PVRs for different series, but I've never needed to specify the channel to achieve that.
Hi Guys Just to clarify.
I hope no one missed anything with Silent Witness. Looking at all of the comments I can shed a little light, firstly if we can determine that the show has been on before it will be marked as a repeat irrespective of whether it was on ABC or Gem. In the case of Silent Witness we had that it had been shown previously as a one hour episode and it was scheduled to be shown for 2 hours and twenty minutes. Some times these are telemovies but I could not establish this in this case and thought (maybe unwisely) that I should break it up and create a second episode in case parts of it were new. Not sure if putting it in for two hours and twenty minutes as a repeat would have been better?
Secondly I definitely do work on the weekends and must admit that I had a few issues over the weekend so was a little tardy in keeping the forum up to date, hopefully this will not happen again.
I must say I do appreciate your feed back in advance that I can rectify and am looking forward to the day we only have to answer help questions.
According to IMDB, seasons 1-4 of SW were all 2 part stories, 120 min each.
In season 5, where "Two Below Zero" appears, are all single-part stories, but again all 120 min.
In seasons 6-9, they're back to two parts each 120 min.
In season 10, they become two parts each of about 60min (I've seen 65min and 58min).
In season 19 (coming in 2016, according to IMDB), they're back to two 120-min parts.
I think the total of 2 hours 20 min for "Two Below Zero" is probably the original 2 hours + ad breaks (and perhaps a bit of cutting, though perhaps in that time slot they will really only do 10 min of ads in 70 min).
Just to confuse matters, some programs produced in the UK are available in two forms; all in one or split into two parts. This has happened with Silent Witness, Agatha Christie's Poirot, Dalzile & Pascoe (and there are probably others). On the ABC Agatha Christie's Poirot were, to the best of my knowledge, always shown as a single program; when repeated on GEM the longer ones were invariably broadcast in two parts (the exception may be the Mysterious Affairs at Sytles which was show as one episode). I suspect the two-part episodes were packaged for domestic consumption and the combined episodes were packaged for export sales (particularly for the United States cable networks).
Just to confuse things the same episodes of Silent Witness and Dalzile & Pascoe have been show as a single program and in two parts.
Ian
PS This can be very confusing.
Update: The earlier episodes of Agatha Christie's Poirot broadcast on GEM were the remastered versions, not the original versions broadcast on the ABC (and I think before that on Seven). I suspect they were recorded on film and then transferred to videotape (going by the quality of the end credits which are blurred on the original versions).
I'm not sure this has been resolved.
In the icetv app I have for next Tuesday I have
8.40 Silent Witness (2001) - Two Below Zero marked as a repeat
9.50 Silent Witness - Two Below Zero (Part 2) marked as a first run
One of these must be wrong.
I don't think John said he'd resolved it.
I'm still seeing part 2 as a first run, too (Canberra IceGuide).
Same here in Melbourn; the first part is shown as a repeat and the second is not.
Speculation: The ABC originally showed it in one part rather than in two parts, and the IceTV data base therefore picked up the first as a repeat but not the second. The algorithm needs a bit of tweaking.
Ian
Quote from: IanL-S on December 09, 2015, 06:37:46 PM
Same here in Melbourn; the first part is shown as a repeat and the second is not.
Speculation: The ABC originally showed it in one part rather than in two parts, and the IceTV data base therefore picked up the first as a repeat but not the second. The algorithm needs a bit of tweaking.
Ian
When I originally posted this, I hadn't checked to see when these were made. Now that I see how old these are, there is absolutely no doubt that they are repeats
Quote from: prl on December 09, 2015, 06:19:57 PM
I don't think John said he'd resolved it.
I'm still seeing part 2 as a first run, too (Canberra IceGuide).
No, but I assumed if he'd had time to write a 3 para response then there should have been an opportunity to set the repeat flag for the second episode.
In terms of your comment about only recording on abc, I note that in the similar posts section below there is a 2012 post about gem showing silent witness repeats so you may have done it then.
Quote from: simoncasey on December 09, 2015, 11:59:01 PM
...
In terms of your comment about only recording on abc, I note that in the similar posts section below there is a 2012 post about gem showing silent witness repeats so you may have done it then.
Quite likely.
Hi prl the check we do is to see if it had been aired on any of the channels we supply to the guide so this covers all ABC and commercial channels. I guess it could have slipped through without an episode at some stage but i have no way of working this out.
Hi, John.
I realise that, but no matter whether "Two Below Zero" has been shown before on Australian FTA TV, the current situation where the first half of "Two Below Zero" on Gem is flagged as a repeat, but the second half is flagged as a first run is surely wrong.
Hi prl I agree with you and I had already changed the flag so they are both repeats.
To add to the confusion, I just noticed that 9Gem were adverting the episodes shown this week as being "new".
Ian
Quote from: IanL-S on December 11, 2015, 04:10:13 PM
To add to the confusion, I just noticed that 9Gem were adverting the episodes shown this week as being "new".
Ian
They could argue that everything on 9Gem must be new. The previous shows were shown on GEM. :)
Quote from: IanL-S on December 11, 2015, 04:10:13 PM
To add to the confusion, I just noticed that 9Gem were adverting the episodes shown this week as being "new".
Ian
They have always done this. It is "new" to GEM. ::) That is what's good about IceTV (or was) that they knew if a show has been shown previously, regardless of which channel.
It's back! IceTV (ACT) is showing Silent Witness "The Fall Out (2002)", Parts 1 and 2, GEM Tue 29 Dec, 21:10 and 22:20 as being first run. They're surely not: the episodes really are from 2002, and I recall the plot from seeing them. Yahoo7's guide doesn't have them marked as repeats, either, but I'm pretty sure they're wrong.
Quote from: prl on December 24, 2015, 12:42:35 PM
It's back! IceTV (ACT) is showing Silent Witness "The Fall Out (2002)", Parts 1 and 2, GEM Tue 29 Dec, 21:10 and 22:20 as being first run. They're surely not: the episodes really are from 2002, and I recall the plot from seeing them. Yahoo7's guide doesn't have them marked as repeats, either, but I'm pretty sure they're wrong.
It's been fixed now (at least in the ACT guide).
Thanks!