I was watching Seven propaganda news this evening and noticed that they're promoting that 72 will go live on Sunday.
I've had a dig in the Ice XML feed and can't see that there is any obvious mention of the programming that is coming up -- not even a placeholder.
I do appreciate that the workflow you go through requires several sources, but when do you plan to start feeding guidedata for this channel?
Thanks,
Matt.
7 has a complete program guide on their website, so data should be available for ICE...
Quote from: mcpaton on October 23, 2009, 11:06:09 PM
7 has a complete program guide on their website, so data should be available for ICE...
That's not how it works as has been posted here so many times already. IceTV have major restrictions on how they compile their guides so they cannot just copy it.
Hi. Thanks for bringing this to light and yes, it's pretty much how Gary has described it. Will keep you posted on on our progress with it. As you can understand, we're a bit loathe to 'get in' immediately for the sake of hours of 'TBA'
Quote from: Mitch IceGuide on October 24, 2009, 04:56:40 PM
Hi. Thanks for bringing this to light and yes, it's pretty much how Gary has described it. Will keep you posted on on our progress with it. As you can understand, we're a bit loathe to 'get in' immediately for the sake of hours of 'TBA'
A few (at least) "TBA" entries would allow us to get our PVRs etc set up so that we'll get the real data when you have it ready.
Ch7 has been extensively advertising the opening show for "7 Two" - the Michael Jackson Concert
Well, I tuned my TV to 72 and they are now broadcasting. Well, broadcasting non stop ads for coming shows. ::) It really would help to be able to set up everything now, before it all starts. I always seem to get into trouble trying to get everything to run smoothly, so would really prefer to do it at my leisure
Personally, so long as it is broken up into 1 hour blocks, I'd be happy to see TBA across the 72 guide until data is available, least it will allow me to set recordings on my own.
Hi
We are currently doing some tests for 7TWO in Sydney before we establish guide data for other capital cities. (Please note that most regional areas will not be getting 7TWO until early December). We will send out an email advising subscribers of what to do to get the new channel in the next day or two.
It is still important for us to follow certain protocols when scheduling a new channel. This means that apart from the odd show that has been promoted on air, the guide for 7TWO will initially consist of short blocks of "Coming Soon".
Thanks
Quote from: Madeleine at IceTV on October 28, 2009, 11:44:41 AM
It is still important for us to follow certain protocols when scheduling a new channel. This means that apart from the odd show that has been promoted on air, the guide for 7TWO will initially consist of short blocks of "Coming Soon".
One day, when common sense has finally prevailed, we'll look back on this era and laugh at how utterly stupid it all was. TV networks making legal threats against a company that promotes when their shows are on? Laughable.
The commercial FTA channels just can't see the forest for the trees.
Quote from: Neon Kitten on October 28, 2009, 11:06:37 PM
Quote from: Madeleine at IceTV on October 28, 2009, 11:44:41 AM
It is still important for us to follow certain protocols when scheduling a new channel. This means that apart from the odd show that has been promoted on air, the guide for 7TWO will initially consist of short blocks of "Coming Soon".
One day, when common sense has finally prevailed, we'll look back on this era and laugh at how utterly stupid it all was. TV networks making legal threats against a company that promotes when their shows are on? Laughable.
The commercial FTA channels just can't see the forest for the trees.
What's needed is legislation/regulation to force the FTA networks to release their basic schedule free of copyright as a condition of their broadcasting license. Just the time/title/subtitle would be enough.
Last working day before "7 Two" - any news yet?
The current known guide information for 7TWO is now in the guide, and the channel is enabled in the regions that will be receiving it on Sunday. An email is now on it's way out to everyone to let them know it is available.
As with any new channel full guide information will take at least two weeks before it is available.
Noticed it was there about 30 mins ago - BTW "Heroes" on Wednesday is a double episode
Quote from: Daniel Hall at IceTV on October 30, 2009, 04:55:24 PM
The current known guide information for 7TWO is now in the guide, and the channel is enabled in the regions that will be receiving it on Sunday. An email is now on it's way out to everyone to let them know it is available.
As with any new channel full guide information will take at least two weeks before it is available.
There is something in the water in Melbourne. :( My main ISP has crashed, can't send or receive posts through them. My main computer has also crashed :( so I can't get to my address book to notify people to send posts to an alternative address. That is a problem, as I expecting some important posts from a committee I'm on. I also have TED etc on that PC as well as MCE, so I can't set up anything now.
I have been studying the guide for 72 and noticed Brothers & Sisters on Thursday at lunchtime. Any way of knowing if this is a new ep, or a repeat?
Does anyone know what's happening with Seven's regional affiliates? The IceTV web page doesn't have the new service in their ACT guide yet.
Quote from: Daniel Hall at IceTV on October 30, 2009, 04:55:24 PM
An email is now on it's way out to everyone to let them know it is available.
Thanks - all worked fine for me on Win7 Ultimate - channel found and labelled correctly and once added guide listing appeared (still to try the Vista Ultimate Media Center to see how easy that one is)
now just the padding on Win7 Interactive to resolve......
Update - the Vista MCE worked as well - a little more complex (incl doing an IceTV update and then associating the guide with the channel) - but a lot easier than I remember for previous "new" channels like Go and 10HD
Quote from: prl on October 30, 2009, 05:29:07 PM
Does anyone know what's happening with Seven's regional affiliates? The IceTV web page doesn't have the new service in their ACT guide yet.
At this stage Canberra will not get the channel as of Sunday. Newspaper reports indicate that Southern Cross will begin broadcasting on December 1. Prime, including ACT, will not get 7TWO until January.
Quote from: bodogbodog on October 30, 2009, 05:37:34 PM
Quote from: Daniel Hall at IceTV on October 30, 2009, 04:55:24 PM
An email is now on it's way out to everyone to let them know it is available.
Thanks - all worked fine for me on Win7 Ultimate - channel found and labelled correctly and once added guide listing appeared (still to try the Vista Ultimate Media Center to see how easy that one is)
now just the padding on Win7 Interactive to resolve......
Excellent news, the way its been added this time should mean we won't have all the problems in MCE that happened in previous new channels.
We are still testing and working on Beta2, but at this stage I can confirm that padding will be disabled in the app for Beta2 so that it uses the Media Center padding.
Quote from: j s on October 30, 2009, 05:01:06 PM
Noticed it was there about 30 mins ago - BTW "Heroes" on Wednesday is a double episode
We can't amend programs based on info from other guides while we are still establishing our own guide data but we'll keep an eye on the promos for Heroes to see if they indicate a double episode.
Quote from: csutak40 on October 30, 2009, 05:16:07 PM
I have been studying the guide for 72 and noticed Brothers & Sisters on Thursday at lunchtime. Any way of knowing if this is a new ep, or a repeat?
We cannot determine episodes for most shows at this early stage. However, daytime shows are likely to be repeats rather than first runs.
FYI, the last ep of Brothers & Sisters shown on ch7 was the Season 3 finale, 'Mexico', in late July. If you have a title for the ep showing on 7TWO then you can double check it here.
http://epguides.com/BrothersandSisters/
Quote from: Daniel Hall at IceTV on October 30, 2009, 05:42:48 PM
Quote from: prl on October 30, 2009, 05:29:07 PM
Does anyone know what's happening with Seven's regional affiliates? The IceTV web page doesn't have the new service in their ACT guide yet.
At this stage Canberra will not get the channel as of Sunday. Newspaper reports indicate that Southern Cross will begin broadcasting on December 1. Prime, including ACT, will not get 7TWO until January.
Thanks, Daniel.
By the way, step 5 in your emailed update instructions for Beyonwiz:
QuoteFor Beyonwiz users you may need to do the following:
1. Re-scan the channels if necessary to pick-up the new 7TWO channel.
2. Go into the "Setup" of the Beyonwiz.
3. Go across to the fourth tab at the top of the screen, it will be labelled "System".
4. Go down to "Initialize".
5. Select "Clear IceGuide Disk Cache".
6. Click "Yes" to confirm this.
can't be done on a DP-H1, because the Initialize screen doesn't have a Clear IceGuide Disk Cache operation. I've mentioned this twice on the Beyonwiz beta forum since IceTV caching was introduced on the DP-H1 (if it has an external recording HDD).
Quote from: Daniel Hall at IceTV on October 30, 2009, 04:55:24 PM
The current known guide information for 7TWO is now in the guide, and the channel is enabled in the regions that will be receiving it on Sunday.
I just re-fetched the guide data and, sure enough, there it is!
Thanks for the great content.
Quote from: Daniel Hall at IceTV on October 30, 2009, 04:55:24 PM
The current known guide information for 7TWO is now in the guide, and the channel is enabled in the regions that will be receiving it on Sunday. An email is now on it's way out to everyone to let them know it is available.
As with any new channel full guide information will take at least two weeks before it is available.
This really is a bit of a farce.
Yep, the "known" guide info is in the Ice Guide. And the "unknown" info is sitting there as "7TWo - Coming Soon". Neatly divided into the blocks that match the programming that we can't talk about lest we be sued.
I understand, obviously, the circumstances etc etc, but if Seven was going to take issue with the use of their "intellectual property", surely the fact that the show time schedule has already been copied from "verboten" information would be ammo enough?
This rubbish situation needs to be challenged and defeated once and for all. I mean, they DO want us to watch their new channel, right?
Quote from: Neon Kitten on October 31, 2009, 08:14:19 AM
...
This rubbish situation needs to be challenged and defeated once and for all. I mean, they DO want us to watch their new channel, right?
Well, start talking to your local Federal MP about making pretty large changes to the Copyright Act. The Act's intention is to give the copyright holder exclusive (with a few limited exceptions) rights to make copies. Just because something has been published, like 7TWO's schedule, doesn't free it from copyright. Quite the contrary.
Quote from: Copyright Act Section 31(1)copyright, in relation to a work, is the exclusive right: ... to reproduce the work ... to publish ... to perform ... to communicate ... to make an adaptation of the work ...
I can understand IceTV's caution about this.
Quote from: Neon Kitten on October 31, 2009, 08:14:19 AM
I understand, obviously, the circumstances etc etc, but if Seven was going to take issue with the use of their "intellectual property", surely the fact that the show time schedule has already been copied from "verboten" information would be ammo enough?
We divided the days into Coming Soon blocks to make it easier to amend once we receive more info but the blocks themselves haven't been copied from anywhere. Some will correspond with actual timeslots (it's no great stretch to assume a program will be on from 8.30-9.30pm) but a lot of them won't.
Quote from: Daniel Hall at IceTV on October 30, 2009, 05:44:55 PM
Excellent news, the way its been added this time should mean we won't have all the problems in MCE that happened in previous new channels.
Daniel -- kudos and thank you to all responsible for looking into this issue. Addition of the new channel could not have been smoother on Vista MCE this time out. I enabled channel 72 about a week ago (when it was still called "7 digital 2" according to MCE), and of course it has just been saying no data available all week. But as soon as the guide data became available I see it has renamed to "7TWO", and the EPG data automatically associated with it! I have done literally
nothing and it is all working perfectly.
Nice job! ;D
Quote from: Madeleine at IceTV on October 31, 2009, 09:58:40 AM
We divided the days into Coming Soon blocks to make it easier to amend once we receive more info but the blocks themselves haven't been copied from anywhere. Some will correspond with actual timeslots (it's no great stretch to assume a program will be on from 8.30-9.30pm) but a lot of them won't.
Ah, ok. It was just the fact that there were blocks of varying lengths in there that made me wonder.
I still think all of this is ridiculous. I understand why you have to do it, but it's ridiculous.
Quote from: Neon Kitten on October 31, 2009, 06:35:35 PM
I still think all of this is ridiculous.
As do I.
How a television station can think that a TV schedule is IP is absolutely beyond me. We're trying to watch your content here!
I wish I was given the opportunity to participate in ratings as you can be sure that certain television stations would be suitably punished for their behavior.
Quote from: Matt- on October 31, 2009, 09:06:06 PM
Quote from: Neon Kitten on October 31, 2009, 06:35:35 PM
I still think all of this is ridiculous.
As do I.
How a television station can think that a TV schedule is IP is absolutely beyond me. We're trying to watch your content here!
...
They think so because the Copyright Act, and presumably a bunch of case law, tells them that it is. IIRC, Telstra won a case that says that a list of names and addresses against numbers (i.e. the telephone book) was copyrightable. I think that that's why Telstra (or Sensis?) joined Nine's case against IceTV, because they feared that a judgement in IceTV's favour might compromise the monopoly rights that copyright gives them on publishing the phone book.
The real argument here is about the nature of copyright. The TV stations are simply using that law to protect what they think is their interest. You may think they're mistaken about what their best interest is, but the Copyright Act gives that decision to them over any material that it covers.
The judgement on Nine vs IceTV might have loosened it up slightly, so that time and title information may not be copyright, but with the appeals and the mess that that caused, I have no idea now just what the case leaves IceTV as being allowed to do with the TV stations' published schedules, nor is it clear just how much advantage of the decision IceTV is taking. It looks very much as though they've gone back to their original method of predicting most of the schedule, and using the published schedules only to make corrections.
Not a lawyer.
Quote from: Matt- on October 31, 2009, 09:06:06 PM
Quote from: Neon Kitten on October 31, 2009, 06:35:35 PM
I still think all of this is ridiculous.
As do I.
How a television station can think that a TV schedule is IP is absolutely beyond me. We're trying to watch your content here!
...
They think so because the Copyright Act, and presumably a bunch of case law, tells them that it is. IIRC, Telstra won a case that says that a list of names and addresses against numbers (i.e. the telephone book) was copyrightable. I think that that's why Telstra (or Sensis?) joined Nine's case against IceTV, because they feared that a judgement in IceTV's favour might compromise the monopoly rights that copyright gives them on publishing the phone book.
The real argument here is about the nature of copyright. The TV stations are simply using that law to protect what they think is their interest. You may think they're mistaken about what their best interest is, but the Copyright Act gives that decision to them over any material that it covers.
The judgement on Nine vs IceTV might have loosened it up slightly, so that time and title information may not be copyright, but with the appeals and the mess that that caused, I have no idea now just what the case leaves IceTV as being allowed to do with the TV stations' published schedules, nor is it clear just how much advantage of the decision IceTV is taking. It looks very much as though they've gone back to their original method of predicting most of the schedule, and using the published schedules only to make corrections.
Not a lawyer.
Just to reiterate. The new channel will not be fully available for some weeks.
7TWO can not see it in Newcastle so fa:-(((
Quote from: Mitch IceGuide on November 01, 2009, 12:38:41 PM
Just to reiterate. The new channel will not be fully available for some weeks.
What, if anything, is being done in the wake of the recent court decision in favour of IceTV to ensure that situations like this don't happen in the future?
And not to anyone from Seven who might be reading: if there was something on I might have wanted to see but I miss the first episodes because your program listing is "copyright", then that's just another show added to the torrent list.
Unfortunately if I attempt to answer this question satisfactorily, I will probably do with legal foot-in-mouth. It's best I don't, only to say that we still adhere to strict independant procedure for identifying what programs will appear on any given channel (except abc/sbs).
Quote from: Neon Kitten on November 02, 2009, 12:31:27 AM
What, if anything, is being done in the wake of the recent court decision in favour of IceTV to ensure that situations like this don't happen in the future?
And not to anyone from Seven who might be reading: if there was something on I might have wanted to see but I miss the first episodes because your program listing is "copyright", then that's just another show added to the torrent list.
There is no reason why anything should or would be done about this. The commercial channels are only trying to protect their business model as best they can. You might want to bear in mind that this is the same business model that provides you and I with free-to-air commercial television in the first place, and you can't expect to have you cake and eat it too.
The High Court has ruled (quite rightly IMHO) that copyright subsists in program schedules. This is perfectly reasonable: the schedules do not just "exist" for anyone to discover, and do with as they wish, they are created by those people at the various networks whose job it is to select programs, and to decide when and where they will be broadcast. They are original works, in the sense required by the Copyright Act. So copying the whole of someone's schedule, or a substantial part of it, is an infringement of copyright.
However, the High Court has also ruled (again quite rightly IMHO, and in favour of IceTV who took the fight all the way to the top) that the "time and title" information of individual programs within a schedule are not a sufficiently substantial part of the whole work to sustain a case for infringement. Thus if, like IceTV, you have independently constructed a complete program guide without copying the schedule, it is OK to correct a few individual entries by reference to the schedule.
The commercial channels are free to license their schedules to any other party they wish (including IceTV) on whatever terms (including for a fee) that they see fit. Or they can refuse to do so, and take legal action against any infringers. As I understand it, the reason they are reluctant to work with third party EPG suppliers such as IceTV is because, in general, PVRs make it too easy for viewers to avoid exposure to commercials, either via "30 second skip" buttons and/or more sophisticated measures. This obviously kills the major source of revenue to commercial free-to-air networks.
As you may know, the Australian TiVo PVR has access to a licensed EPG, but the trade-off is that it had to hop into bed with Seven, and does not include the most convenient commercial-skipping functionality.
You might think that in the age of broadband internet, the commercial free-to-air networks are dinosaurs in danger of extinction if they cannot come up with new revenue models, and you might be right (time will tell). But the problem is that the most vocal objectors seem unwilling to pay in other ways for the content. If you think that your alternative to 7TWO is an (illegal) free download, then I would ask you who is going to pay to create and distribute the content you love so much once there are no networks left that are willing or able to buy it? The best information available on the internet suggests that many one-hour action series cost well in excess of US$1M per episode to make. A whole season is thus on a par with a modest Hollywood movie, and someone has to have a good business case before they will bankroll that.
The situation is not even as bad as you make out. There has been a full schedule on the 7TWO web site for over a week already. The schedule is also in all of this week's papers. And the in-band EPG on 7TWO is complete. So what is stopping you from manually setting your recordings for a couple of weeks while IceTV gets its EPG data up and running?
:o A copyright post I agree with 100%! :o