IceTV Forum

IceTV IceBox => General => Topic started by: aeb001 on March 20, 2023, 09:50:16 AM

Title: stand alone
Post by: aeb001 on March 20, 2023, 09:50:16 AM
Can i just ask, is iceBox a stand alone os? i.e guide, player, all-in-one?
Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: IanL-S on March 20, 2023, 10:26:16 AM
The installation file contains LibreELEC (the OS) plus two add-ins, one for IceTV and one for TVHeadend. Once the installation wizard has finished you end up with the OS + the latest build of the two add-ins.
Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: aeb001 on March 20, 2023, 07:22:26 PM
Quote from: IanL-S on March 20, 2023, 10:26:16 AMThe installation file contains LibreELEC (the OS) plus two add-ins, one for IceTV and one for TVHeadend. Once the installation wizard has finished you end up with the OS + the latest build of the two add-ins.

is "TVHeadend" the recorder / player? this is all new to me. I'm a Microsoft person
Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: IanL-S on March 20, 2023, 08:08:59 PM
Timers are download from the IceTV server, and are scheduled by the IceTV add-in by making a "reservation" TVHeadend.

It is possible to configure TVHeadend to use free-to-air EPG data, and series recordings are created using a process to Autotimers in Enigma2 devices such as Beyonwiz PVRs. Timers can also be set manually, either via the LibreELEC EPG, or using the TVHeadend web interface.

This is all rather complex and the everyday user does not need to understand how it works.

Ian
Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: aeb001 on March 21, 2023, 09:06:38 AM
so back to my original question then, does it have a recorder & player software as part of the icebox software?
Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: vader1111 on March 21, 2023, 12:00:09 PM
Short answer... yes.

The IceBox comes with LibreELEC/Kodi installed, along with the TVHeadend and IceTV Kodi addons.  Technically, LibreELEC is the operating system, and Kodi the application which sits on top of it, but they are heavily integrated to the extent that the names are often used interchangeably.

Kodi provides the Player functionality.

The TVHeadend addon provides the PVR functionality, including the EPG and Recorder functionality, and tuner management.

The IceTV addon provides integration with the IceTV service, providing the EPG data (feeding into TVHeadend) and the ability to set timers using the IceTV website or phone apps.

It is possible to install other Kodi addons, but I will leave this to your own discretion/investigation.  I haven't bothered.
Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: vader1111 on March 21, 2023, 05:07:04 PM
When you say "standalone", the meaning is not entirely clear.

The IceBox does come with all of the software included, and pre-installed (LibreELEC/Kodi, TVHeadend addon, IceTV addon).  However, it requires internet access for downloading EPG and timer data from the IceTV servers, and the automatic installation of any addon updates which are subsequently released.
Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: IanL-S on March 22, 2023, 08:19:56 AM
Quote from: vader1111 on March 21, 2023, 05:07:04 PM..... it requires internet access for downloading EPG and timer data from the IceTV servers, and the automatic installation of any addon updates which are subsequently released.

Without active internet access you will be running a significantly out of date IceTV addins. I can't recall if any of the other addins have been updated since the installation file was compiled.
Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: aeb001 on March 22, 2023, 08:33:50 AM
Thanks for that @vader1111. yeah thats exactly what i was getting at. I was just making sure that it was an all in one solution that didnt require additional sofetwware downloads etc. Obviously the net access for guide updates ges withoout saying, just the same as my current Win7 / MCE + IceTV does. I'm investigating the icebox option as wintv / mce is a very aged way of doing things, however in a windows household its very reliable as i can view the recordings across the household network on any windows pc, plus the mce machine in the lounge also acts as a full media pc playing my full music collection too.
Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: IanL-S on March 22, 2023, 08:53:45 AM
Yesterday afternoon I discovered by accident that it is possible, using the TVHeadend web management page to play recordings on the IceBox. It may also be possible to watch live TV. Bit clunky, as it has to download the recording first. Have not closely looked at this, but it is promising. I will be providing more comprehensive guidance on network access to recordings when the IceBox wiki gets going.
Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: vader1111 on March 22, 2023, 10:53:25 AM
Quote from: aeb001 on March 22, 2023, 08:33:50 AMThanks for that @vader1111. yeah thats exactly what i was getting at. I was just making sure that it was an all in one solution that didnt require additional sofetwware downloads etc. Obviously the net access for guide updates ges withoout saying, just the same as my current Win7 / MCE + IceTV does. I'm investigating the icebox option as wintv / mce is a very aged way of doing things, however in a windows household its very reliable as i can view the recordings across the household network on any windows pc, plus the mce machine in the lounge also acts as a full media pc playing my full music collection too.
You can view the contents of the IceBox on any PC, or even a legacy Beyonwiz PVR, attached to your home network.  All you need to do is connect to the IceBox's Recordings SMB share folder.

Kodi is a powerful media player, and is capable of playing pretty much any format.  It's far better than Plex, in that regard.  You can setup Kodi to play your music collection, or any other video files you have on your network. 

There are many other Kodi addons available, which can be installed by the user - but only the addons required for IceBox PVR functionality is installed by default.  Anything else is up to the user.

The one proviso I would note is that the IceBox does not play 4K (2160p) video terribly well - I believe this is a hardware issue.  You're definitely best sticking with video files at 1080p or lower.
Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: aeb001 on March 22, 2023, 07:13:16 PM
Quote from: IanL-S on March 22, 2023, 08:53:45 AMYesterday afternoon I discovered by accident that it is possible, using the TVHeadend web management page to play recordings on the IceBox. It may also be possible to watch live TV. Bit clunky, as it has to download the recording first. Have not closely looked at this, but it is promising. I will be providing more comprehensive guidance on network access to recordings when the IceBox wiki gets going.

@IanL-S Are you referring to watching live recordings on a secondary device? (Personally i ony watch pre-recorded stuff from the night before in the morning on my office pc while i drink a coffee. With MCE it plays from the lounge pc's HDD on the office PC's windows media player. You can watch a recording as it records over the network too but this loads up the CPU like no tomorrow so i only ever watch recordins once they have completed)

@vader1111 can you run Kodi on a win7 pc. I currently have VLC installed for watching certain other files with matroska encryption.
Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: IanL-S on March 22, 2023, 07:35:20 PM
Quote from: aeb001 on March 22, 2023, 07:13:16 PM@IanL-S Are you referring to watching live recordings on a secondary device? (Personally i ony watch pre-recorded stuff from the night before in the morning on my office pc while i drink a coffee. With MCE it plays from the lounge pc's HDD on the office PC's windows media player. You can watch a recording as it records over the network too but this loads up the CPU like no tomorrow so i only ever watch recordins once they have completed)

Yes, was watching it on my PC. Not something I would normally do, just fooling around and discovered it worked. It was live TV (I think). Will look again tomorrow.
Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: vader1111 on March 23, 2023, 10:50:50 AM
Quote from: aeb001 on March 22, 2023, 07:13:16 PM@vader1111 can you run Kodi on a win7 pc. I currently have VLC installed for watching certain other files with matroska encryption.
Yes, there are Kodi versions available for Windows.
Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: aeb001 on March 23, 2023, 07:23:47 PM
have you guys seen anywhere on the threads of anyone using hauppage pcie tuners? I've been doing a bit of googling & i "think" i can get a driver for a HVR-quadHD PCI-E.
Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: Daniel Hall at IceTV on March 23, 2023, 07:43:07 PM
Quote from: aeb001 on March 23, 2023, 07:23:47 PMhave you guys seen anywhere on the threads of anyone using hauppage pcie tuners? I've been doing a bit of googling & i "think" i can get a driver for a HVR-quadHD PCI-E.

I used one of these before with Libreelec and it worked fine, and when I am able to get my test BYOB system up and running it's what it will be using.
Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: MD on March 23, 2023, 07:56:54 PM
Look at the Kodi links at the very end of our setup and user guide where a search for tuners will bring up much info and the ability to ask questions on the forum.  Our USB tuners are made by Hauppage.
Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: Hati on April 06, 2023, 06:03:57 AM
Quote from: MD on March 23, 2023, 07:56:54 PMOur USB tuners are made by Hauppage.

And are the exact same Beyonwiz used to sell/use, just the "branding" differs. So if you are like me, a Beyonwiz refugee, you can use those tuners with IceBox. 6 tuners (3 sticks) seem to be enough to cover all the FTA recording combinations possible.
Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: prl on April 06, 2023, 06:25:26 PM
Quote from: Hati on April 06, 2023, 06:03:57 AMAnd are the exact same Beyonwiz used to sell/use, just the "branding" differs.

I don't think that that's quite right. The Hauppauge dual tuners that Beyonwiz used to sell are no longer made, and their replacement doesn't work in the Beyonwizes that used to support the Hauppauge dual tuner.
Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: Hati on April 06, 2023, 06:45:19 PM
Quote from: prl on April 06, 2023, 06:25:26 PMI don't think that that's quite right. The Hauppauge dual tuners that Beyonwiz used to sell are no longer made, and their replacement doesn't work in the Beyonwizes that used to support the Hauppauge dual tuner.

These pics prove you wrong Peter.

(https://i.postimg.cc/xjwXLrG3/IMG-2141.jpg) (https://postimg.cc/nM1VtPPX)

(https://i.postimg.cc/MKJGv7xs/IMG-2142.jpg) (https://postimg.cc/K4QbWg1L)
Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: prl on April 07, 2023, 10:05:04 AM
I'm not sure how the pictures prove me wrong. They don't show the tuners working on a Beyonwiz. I didn't say anything about tuners not working any other device.
Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: Hati on April 07, 2023, 10:18:20 AM
Quote from: prl on April 07, 2023, 10:05:04 AMI'm not sure how the pictures prove me wrong.

I said that the dual tuner sold by Beyonwiz is identical to what IceTV sells, so clearly they are still being made. Picture to (kinda) show the sticks next to one another. I bought that Hauppauge stick years ago from BW and now compared to the IceTV offering, find them identical, including what the box reads off them (picture 2).

I fail to understand what is "not quote right" with the paragraph above. I was NOT talking about BW working with anything, they are dead, what is the point even bringing them up?
Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: prl on April 07, 2023, 12:07:42 PM
I said that the older and newer versions of the Hauppauge tuners weren't identical. I don't think that your screen photo necessarily shows that they are.

Here's a link to Beyonwiz forum of discussion of the problem of the newer tuners not working properly with Beyonwizes, starting with a post that quotes Hauppauge support as saying that newer drivers are required to have them work on a Beyonwiz V2.

https://www.beyonwiz.com.au/forum/viewtopic.php?f=49&t=15014&hilit=hauppauge#p198593

In particular, note the quote from Hauppauge support saying "There is a newer revision of the DualHD 204209 that requires a different firmware."
Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: raymondjpg on April 07, 2023, 01:57:42 PM
Quote from: prl on April 06, 2023, 06:25:26 PMI don't think that that's quite right. The Hauppauge dual tuners that Beyonwiz used to sell are no longer made, and their replacement doesn't work in the Beyonwizes that used to support the Hauppauge dual tuner.

Is that right? As far as I can see the WinTV-dualHD TV Tuner Model 1590 is still available for 69.90 euros on the UK site (https://www.hauppauge.co.uk/site/webstore/webstore_dualhd.html).

I suspect (though don't know for sure) that BW would have supplied Model 1590. The "updated" model referred to by Hauppauge USA in correspondence in the BW forum thread could have been Model 1595 (see https://www.hauppauge.com/pages/webstore2/webstore_dualhd.html). This reference https://linuxtv.org/wiki/index.php/Hauppauge_WinTV-dualHD#Model_01595_.28USB_device_ID_2040:026d.29 from two or three years ago suggests models 1590 and 1595 can be easily distinguished by connector type.

Edit: Just to add to that the reference https://linuxtv.org/wiki/index.php/Hauppauge_WinTV-dualHD#Model_01595_.28USB_device_ID_2040:026d.29 clearly identifies Model 1590 as having the Si2168-B40 Demodulator whereas Model 1595 has LG LGDT3306a.
Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: prl on April 07, 2023, 04:49:58 PM
I don't think that anyone found that for sale when it was being discussed on the Beyonwiz forum.

The old Hauppauge that I got From Beyonwiz doesn't have either 1590 or 1595 marked anywhere on its body. It's identified as "Hauppauge model 204109, rev C2I6" in /var/log/messages, and that matches what's on the label on the back of the device. But the messages file does identify it as having a Silicon Labs Si2157 tuner and a Silicon Labs Si2168 demodulator.
Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: raymondjpg on April 07, 2023, 05:27:56 PM
Quote from: prl on April 07, 2023, 04:49:58 PMI don't think that anyone found that for sale when it was being discussed on the Beyonwiz forum.

The old Hauppauge that I got From Beyonwiz doesn't have either 1590 or 1595 marked anywhere on its body. It's identified as "Hauppauge model 204109, rev C2I6" in /var/log/messages, and that matches what's on the label on the back of the device. But the messages file does identify it as having a Silicon Labs Si2157 tuner and a Silicon Labs Si2168 demodulator.

From https://linuxtv.org/wiki/index.php/Hauppauge_WinTV-dualHD#Model_01595_.28USB_device_ID_2040:026d.29:

Model 01590 (USB device ID 2040:0265)

USB Treeview will report model ID. For example my two WinTV-dualHD TV Tuners bought 4-5 years ago (not from BW) report:

Vendor ID                : 0x2040 (Hauppauge Computer Works, Inc.)
Product ID               : 0x0265

Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: MD on April 07, 2023, 06:58:58 PM
My only contribution to this post is that I hope it was noted that IceTV sells them approximately $15 less than they are sold in the UK:)
Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: raymondjpg on April 07, 2023, 07:29:25 PM
Quote from: MD on April 07, 2023, 06:58:58 PMMy only contribution to this post is that I hope it was noted that IceTV sells them approximately $15 less than they are sold in the UK:)

I would be interested in what USB Treeview would report for the IceTV supplied WinTV-dualHD TV Tuners.

Currently running only one model 1590 in the BYOB software, I can only get one tuner at a time to work. TVheadend reports both tuners, but if I start a recording on one service I cannot set a concurrent second recording on a second service, or view live TV on a second service, without the first recording (and second if set) stopping after half a minute or so.
Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: MD on April 07, 2023, 07:39:17 PM
I can only assume the "1590" has a driver issue whereas our IceTV branded ones are tested to work correctly as dual tuners. You may get some info from the Kodi forum...
Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: raymondjpg on April 07, 2023, 09:37:57 PM
Quote from: MD on April 07, 2023, 07:39:17 PMI can only assume the "1590" has a driver issue whereas our IceTV branded ones are tested to work correctly as dual tuners. You may get some info from the Kodi forum...
That is precisely why I would be interested to see established exactly what model the IceTV tuners are. If 1590 then it would point to my installation of LibreELEC being problematic. If not I would avail myself of an IceTV tuner post haste!

I should add that I see my problem with the single dual tuner 1590 in plain vanilla installations of LibreELEC, up to and including the current version 11.0.1, not just in the IceTV modified version.
Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: IanL-S on April 08, 2023, 09:45:23 AM
Quote from: raymondjpg on April 07, 2023, 09:37:57 PM
Quote from: MD on April 07, 2023, 07:39:17 PMI can only assume the "1590" has a driver issue whereas our IceTV branded ones are tested to work correctly as dual tuners. You may get some info from the Kodi forum...
That is precisely why I would be interested to see established exactly what model the IceTV tuners are. If 1590 then it would point to my installation of LibreELEC being problematic. If not I would avail myself of an IceTV tuner post haste!

I should add that I see my problem with the single dual tuner 1590 in plain vanilla installations of LibreELEC, up to and including the current version 11.0.1, not just in the IceTV modified version.


I assume that both tuners are properly configured - that is DVB-T rather than DVB-C and you have selected DVB-T Network for each.

I will check the Kodi logs to see if it gives more information.
Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: raymondjpg on April 08, 2023, 10:34:34 AM
Quote from: IanL-S on April 08, 2023, 09:45:23 AMI assume that both tuners are properly configured - that is DVB-T rather than DVB-C and you have selected DVB-T Network for each.

I will check the Kodi logs to see if it gives more information.

Both tuners configured for DVB-T rather than DVB-C and DVB-T Network selected. These are default IceBox settings.

I have tried changing Linked input settings, no difference.

Thanks for looking into it.

IceBox.jpg




Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: raymondjpg on April 08, 2023, 04:54:31 PM
Quote from: IanL-S on April 08, 2023, 04:36:26 PMThe information on the rear of the USB tuner provided by IceTV may be of some (limited) help:

Could be, but I don't have one, nor a BW provided one. Only those I purchased a while ago on the open market.

If you have an IceTV provided one, I'd appreciate it if you could post output from UsbTreeView (https://www.majorgeeks.com/files/details/usb_device_tree_viewer.html). That would probably need connecting the tuner to a Windows PC, if you have one.

Relevant entries in output from UsbTreeView for model 1590, with Vendor ID and Product ID of particular interest.

      ========================== Summary =========================
Vendor ID                : 0x2040 (Hauppauge Computer Works, Inc.)
Product ID               : 0x0265
USB Version              : 2.00
Port maximum Speed       : High-Speed (Companion Port 1-16 supports SuperSpeed)
Device maximum Speed     : High-Speed
Device Connection Speed  : High-Speed
Self powered             : no
Demanded Current         : 500 mA
Used Endpoints           : 3

Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: IanL-S on April 08, 2023, 05:16:20 PM
My IceBox has been crashing regularly, next time it does I will attach the tuner to my Windows PC.

Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: raymondjpg on April 08, 2023, 06:20:44 PM
Quote from: IanL-S on April 08, 2023, 05:16:20 PMMy IceBox has been crashing regularly, next time it does I will attach the tuner to my Windows PC.

Thank you.
Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: IanL-S on April 09, 2023, 09:34:00 AM
OK, got the information on the IceTV provided tuner.
    ========================== Summary =========================
Vendor ID                : 0x2040 (Hauppauge Computer Works, Inc.)
Product ID               : 0x0265
USB Version              : 2.0
Port maximum Speed       : High-Speed
Device maximum Speed     : High-Speed
Device Connection Speed  : High-Speed
Self powered             : no
Demanded Current         : 500 mA
Device Manager Problem   : 28 (CM_PROB_FAILED_INSTALL)
Used Endpoints           : 1
Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: raymondjpg on April 09, 2023, 11:21:13 AM
Thanks for that. Looks like a model 1590 to me, same as the one I am using with the BYOB IceBox installation.

Any chance you have a BW supplied one for the V2 that you could do the same test on with UsbTreeView? It would likely clear up the question of whether they (BW provided Hauppauge tuners) are also model 1590.
Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: IanL-S on April 09, 2023, 04:43:03 PM
I do not have any BW provided Hauppauge tuners. Only have no-band name single USB tuners from Beyonwiz (provided with U4 and T2).

I saw something yesterday when trying to work this issue out that suggests the Linux kernel requires separate drivers for each version of the Hauppauge tuner.

Have you tried going into Settings > Add-ons > Services and installing DVB drivers from the latest kernel? It may be you need one of the other listed driver packs, but this is really above my pay grade.

Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: prl on April 09, 2023, 06:27:54 PM
The Beyonwiz firmware only has the Busybox version of lsusb, which doesn't take any options and only lists bus and device numbers, and the USB ID. It confirms that my Beyonwiz-supplied Hauppauge has USB id 2040:0265, which matches the id for the model 01590 listed in the LinuxTV link that raymondjpg posted.

I had a dig around in its /sys/usb files, but didn't find anything much useful. Its "product" file just contains "dualHD".
Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: raymondjpg on April 09, 2023, 10:20:58 PM
Quote from: IanL-S on April 09, 2023, 04:43:03 PMHave you tried going into Settings > Add-ons > Services and installing DVB drivers from the latest kernel? It may be you need one of the other listed driver packs, but this is really above my pay grade.

Thanks. That's one of many things I have tried to resolve the issue. What flummoxes me is that recordings will start on the second tuner, but then both are killed in their tracks. I've also looked at the different recording caching options without success.

Bottom line is that TVheadend is really fragile if only one tuner of the twins is effectively available in my installation. Once borked it seems to mess up reliability for any other recordings down the track.

Two twin tuners may resolve the issue, but I'd prefer it if one twin tuner could be made to work such that both tuners can work concurrently.

It would be helpful to know if IceBox users are experiencing any similar issues running just one twin tuner.


Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: raymondjpg on April 09, 2023, 10:32:59 PM
Quote from: prl on April 09, 2023, 06:27:54 PMIt confirms that my Beyonwiz-supplied Hauppauge has USB id 2040:0265, which matches the id for the model 01590 listed in the LinuxTV link that raymondjpg posted.

It looks as if Model 01590 has been the one generally supplied for broadly speaking the "European" PAL standard. I can't find a local supplier for it, but it is still apparently available on the Hauppauge UK site.

I don't know how Model 1595 (the "USA" version) would go here.
Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: prl on April 10, 2023, 10:19:58 AM
Quote from: raymondjpg on April 09, 2023, 10:32:59 PMI don't know how Model 1595 (the "USA" version) would go here.

Probably not at all, since the Hauppuge and LinuxTV links for it that you gave both say (probably because the latter copies from the former) "Model 01595: Dual tuner for ATSC and clear QAM". ATSC is the US digital TV standard. We use the European DVB standard.
Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: IanL-S on April 10, 2023, 11:10:51 AM
This is really very odd. As the tuner is being recognized, it is difficult to understand why it is not working properly.

You could try an XBOX ONE USB turner, you can get them from Kogan (under $10 for Kogan First price, $20.00 + shipping for others; limit of one per customer and see if that stabilizes things. The way TVHeadend allocates turners will result in it being Tuner 0.

I have a clutch of XBOX ONE tuners, 4 of which I got from Kogan for only $5.00 (including delivery).
Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: raymondjpg on April 10, 2023, 05:12:53 PM
Quote from: IanL-S on April 10, 2023, 11:10:51 AMThis is really very odd. As the tuner is being recognized, it is difficult to understand why it is not working properly.
You'd have thought so, but recognition of the tuner(s) is apparently no guarantee that they will work properly. For example if I select DVB Drivers for TBS I see both tuners, but a forced scan fails on all muxes.
Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: raymondjpg on May 23, 2023, 03:55:46 PM
Quote from: IanL-S on April 10, 2023, 11:10:51 AMYou could try an XBOX ONE USB turner, you can get them from Kogan (under $10 for Kogan First price, $20.00 + shipping for others; limit of one per customer and see if that stabilizes things. The way TVHeadend allocates turners will result in it being Tuner 0.
I eventually acquired an Xbox One Digital TV Tuner (6CV-00002), more out of curiosity than anything else.

I cannot get it recognised by the IceTV publicly available BYOB software. I see that you have it working, but perhaps in more recent beta BYOB software unavailable to the likes of me?

I haven't tried it yet in plain vanilla LibreELEC 11.
Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: IanL-S on May 23, 2023, 04:12:47 PM
I have been using that model USB turner since before IceBox went on sale. I do not recall having any difficulties with it as such.

Is the tuner connected directly to the IceBox or does it do so via a USB hub. In early testing I had considerable difficulty getting USB tuners recognized on my BYOB IceBox. I managed to get a stable connection using a 4-port unpowered USB2 hub. Not success at all with powered USB hubs (either USB 2 or USB 3).

With the current beta firmware (which has the latest LibreELEC kernel) all USB tuners I have tried have been rock-solid.

Ian
Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: raymondjpg on May 23, 2023, 04:43:21 PM
Quote from: IanL-S on May 23, 2023, 04:12:47 PMIs the tuner connected directly to the IceBox or does it do so via a USB hub. In early testing I had considerable difficulty getting USB tuners recognized on my BYOB IceBox. I managed to get a stable connection using a 4-port unpowered USB2 hub. Not success at all with powered USB hubs (either USB 2 or USB 3).
Thanks for the response.

All my BYOB installations of LibreELEC and IceBox so far have been in virtual machines, principally Virtualbox in Win11 hosts.

I do this because I prefer to run IceBox headless, and I can do that with Windows RDP.

So far the best I have been able to do is run single Hauppauge WinTV Dual HD USB tuners, where both are recognised by IceBox but only one tuner is effectively available for live TV or recordings.


Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: IanL-S on May 23, 2023, 04:52:11 PM
If I recall correctly, Delta Mike Charlie has some experience running LibreELEC on virtual machine and he may be able to help out.

Ian
Title: Re: stand alone
Post by: raymondjpg on May 26, 2023, 03:06:27 PM
Quote from: IanL-S on May 23, 2023, 04:52:11 PMIf I recall correctly, Delta Mike Charlie has some experience running LibreELEC on virtual machine and he may be able to help out.
Clearing up some issues wih tuners and VMs:

1. The Xbox One Digital TV Tuner (Microsoft original not the Hauppauge version) does not work in an IceBox installation (original LibreELEC v10) in a Virtualbox VM, but is recognised in a standalone IceBox BYOB installation. It is however recognised as a single (C/T) tuner, so even if it was working in a VM it would not be a solution for the Hauppauge dualHD tuner not working properly in a VM.

2. The Hauppauge dualHD tuner in an IceBox installation in a VM , as I have reported previously, is unable to simultaneously record two programs from different services, or play live TV while simultaneously recording a program on a different service. It's as if only one tuner is effectively available, although both tuners can be seen to work for a brief period (about a minute) before recordinga terminate abruptly. The Hauppauge dualHD tuner does however work perfectly well in a standalone IceBox BYOB installation.

Most of my attempts with VMs have been with Virtualbox 7 in Windows 11 and 10, although I have also tried Virtualbox 6. I did see some success briefly with VMware Workstation Player, both versions 6 and 7, in Windows 10 and 11, but after initial success performance deteriorated to match that with Virtualbox. There was no improvement using VMware Workstation Pro.

My conclusion is that the LibreELEC DVB drivers in VM installations are not up to coping with USB TV tuners plugged into Windows hosts. Even single service recordings using the Hauppauge dualHD tuner in a VM sometimes did not run to completion, and most times the recordings carried errors in the transport stream according to TS-Doctor 2.2.

Recordings made with a Hauppauge dualHD tuner in a standalone IceBox BYOB installation, on the other hand, have, so far, been completely free of errors according to TS-Doctor 2.2.

I could find no references to LibreELEC implementations in VMs in the LibreELEC, TVHeadend or Kodi forums, probably because it's not an option that is frequently used, although I did find one or two references to USB dual tuner behaviours that suggested thay might have originated from VM implementations. Given the paucity of references, I doubt that there would be any movement to improve the LibreELEC DVB drivers to accommodate VM implementation, or come to that any movement from Virtualbox or VMware to accommodate shortcomings in USB tuner performace in LibreELEC implementations in VMs.