IceTV Forum

IceTV IceBox => General => Topic started by: srto2 on March 26, 2025, 01:50:36 PM

Title: Remote 2 feedback and query
Post by: srto2 on March 26, 2025, 01:50:36 PM
I purchased a Remote #2 mainly because I'm in the process of retiring my Harmony remotes and I am happy to say that it is exceptionally good.   Remote #1 was exceptionally awful.

But (Sorry!) - The sales blurb says: "Dedicated buttons to jump straight to your recorded shows, the EPG, the backlight and a subtitle button."

All OK except there is no button on my Remote #2 that selects recordings.  The button immediately below the mute button (that would be ideal) merely pops up one of the info screens.

This might only be an issue with my two BYOBs? Or, otherwise, can we remap the above mentioned button to select the recordings page?
Title: Re: Remote 2 feedback and query
Post by: Daniel Hall at IceTV on March 26, 2025, 02:02:27 PM
The IceTV logo button (the one just below the power button) takes you straight to the recorded shows. The same way the IceTV logo button performed on Remote #1.
Title: Re: Remote 2 feedback and query
Post by: srto2 on March 26, 2025, 02:24:26 PM
Quote from: Daniel Hall at IceTV on March 26, 2025, 02:02:27 PMThe IceTV logo button (the one just below the power button) takes you straight to the recorded shows. The same way the IceTV logo button performed on Remote #1.
Well, I did try all the buttons...

The Ice button just takes me to the main menu page - in two BYOB Iceboxes.  What setting/s do you think may I have fudged to make that happen?  And Remote #1 does, and has always done, the same thing. There is probably a quick fix for this but my aging brain hasn't found it yet.

Edit:  I just discovered that the button goes to recordings from the Home screen but when pressed from live TV it takes me back to the home screen.
Title: Re: Remote 2 feedback and query
Post by: IanL-S on March 26, 2025, 02:51:29 PM
I have never tried it from live TV, so I am as surprised as you are.

What buttons do can be context sensitive, depending on the "driver".

@Daniel Hall - Can this be fix by modifying the "driver" for the remote?
Title: Re: Remote 2 feedback and query
Post by: srto2 on March 26, 2025, 03:10:29 PM
Quote from: IanL-S on March 26, 2025, 02:51:29 PMI have never tried it from live TV, so I am as surprised as you are.

What buttons do can be context sensitive, depending on the "driver".

@Daniel Hall - Can this be fix by modifying the "driver" for the remote?
I would prefer the button below mute to bring up the recordings page.  I've been using a harmony remote + flirc that does that and more so there's no doubt that Kodi is able to handle it.

 @Daniel Hall  - I would love to see this key remapped please!  In live TV it just duplicates the OK button.
Title: Re: Remote 2 feedback and query
Post by: raymondjpg on March 26, 2025, 04:09:23 PM
Quote from: srto2 on March 26, 2025, 03:10:29 PMI would prefer the button below mute to bring up the recordings page.  I've been using a harmony remote + flirc that does that and more so there's no doubt that Kodi is able to handle it.
Backspace brings up the list of recordings in IceBox, so whichever button that issues that command.

If there is no button on Remote #2 that does that, you could try remapping your preferred button using the Kodi Keymap Editor Add-on. I know it works in Windows installations of Kodi, and see no reason why it shouldn't in IceBox. Do a Search on Add-ons.
Title: Re: Remote 2 feedback and query
Post by: srto2 on March 26, 2025, 04:20:52 PM
Quote from: raymondjpg on March 26, 2025, 04:09:23 PM
Quote from: srto2 on March 26, 2025, 03:10:29 PMI would prefer the button below mute to bring up the recordings page.  I've been using a harmony remote + flirc that does that and more so there's no doubt that Kodi is able to handle it.
Backspace brings up the list of recordings in IceBox, so whichever button that issues that command.

If there is no button on Remote #2 that does that, you could try remapping your preferred button using the Kodi Keymap Editor Add-on. I know it works in Windows installations of Kodi, and see no reason why it shouldn't in IceBox. Do a Search on Add-ons.

Backspace just goes back to the last screen for me.  What it says on the tin really...
Title: Re: Remote 2 feedback and query
Post by: raymondjpg on March 26, 2025, 04:36:07 PM
Quote from: srto2 on March 26, 2025, 04:20:52 PMBackspace just goes back to the last screen for me.  What it says on the tin really...
If you issue a backspace keystroke to IceBox from a keyboard, it brings up a list of recordings. If issued from some remote device, then it may have been remapped to something else.

No matter. the Kodi Keymap Editor Add-on should enable issue of a backspace keystroke from whichever device, Harmony remote or IceBox Remote #2, that you are using.
Title: Re: Remote 2 feedback and query
Post by: srto2 on March 26, 2025, 04:57:13 PM
Quote from: raymondjpg on March 26, 2025, 04:36:07 PMNo matter. the Kodi Keymap Editor Add-on should enable issue of a backspace keystroke from whichever device, Harmony remote or IceBox Remote #2, that you are using.

Wth the Harmony + Flirc I can issue any command I like via IR.  And Backspace = Backspace.  It does not bring up recordings.

I don't think that it will be as simple to remap the Remote #1 or #2 commands - especially as more than one button sends the same command:  The button that I would like to use, ie under the mute button, sends the same command as OK when in live TV.

I would like to go direct to recordings from live TV.  To do that, the remote itself will probably need reprogramming.  Remote #3 perhaps?
Title: Re: Remote 2 feedback and query
Post by: raymondjpg on March 26, 2025, 05:10:42 PM
Quote from: srto2 on March 26, 2025, 04:57:13 PMAnd Backspace = Backspace.  It does not bring up recordings.
Something screwy there. Backspace definitely goes back a screen in Windows installations of Kodi, but has always given a list of recordings in IceBox. It's still doing that in my BYO installation, up to date, and as far as I know should do so also in IceBoxes.

Maybe someone else can throw light on why backspace is not working as expected for you.
Title: Re: Remote 2 feedback and query
Post by: srto2 on March 26, 2025, 05:24:59 PM
Quote from: raymondjpg on March 26, 2025, 05:10:42 PM
Quote from: srto2 on March 26, 2025, 04:57:13 PMAnd Backspace = Backspace.  It does not bring up recordings.
Something screwy there. Backspace definitely goes back a screen in Windows installations of Kodi, but has always given a list of recordings in IceBox. It's still doing that in my BYO installation, up to date, and as far as I know should do so also in IceBoxes.

Maybe someone else can throw light on why backspace is not working as expected for you.

Backspace brings up the list of recordings from the Home/Main Menu page.  No argument there.  Otherwise Backspace goes back to the previous page - as expected.  I would like the Icebox remote to allow selection of Recordings page from Live TV.  Which is what the Harmony + Flirc can do via IR.  I'll post the keyboard key when I've looked it up again! 

Edit:  K = Recordings so the Flirc sends a "K"

Edit #2:  Backspace does NOT bring up Recordings with the Ice Remote.  But only from the Harmony + Flirc combo. 
Title: Re: Remote 2 feedback and query
Post by: raymondjpg on March 26, 2025, 06:37:13 PM
Quote from: srto2 on March 26, 2025, 05:24:59 PMEdit:  K = Recordings so the Flirc sends a "K"
Fine! You have identified the keystroke that should bring up the list of recordings when live TV is playing. I just confirmed that on my IceBox.

So use the Kodi Keymap Editor Add-on to map whichever key on the IceBox Remote #2 you wish to "K" and Bob's your uncle.

Edit: I may have been over-ambitious about the ability of the Kodi Keymap Editor to map keyboard letter strokes, but there is another way to use it to bring up the list of recordings.

1. Install the Add-on and Run
2. Select Edit, then you have the option to set a mapped key globally or while in full screen live TV.
3. Choose which you want, then scroll sown to Windows and select Open TV Recordings.
4. Follow the prompts to assign a key on the remote, then back out and Save.

I've tested it on a Windows installation of Kodi and it works fine on a Live TV screen. You'll still need some way to execute an ESC  key to back out of the recordings list.
Title: Re: Remote 2 feedback and query
Post by: srto2 on March 27, 2025, 09:32:47 AM
Quote from: raymondjpg on March 26, 2025, 06:37:13 PM
Quote from: srto2 on March 26, 2025, 05:24:59 PMEdit:  K = Recordings so the Flirc sends a "K"
Fine! You have identified the keystroke that should bring up the list of recordings when live TV is playing. I just confirmed that on my IceBox.

So use the Kodi Keymap Editor Add-on to map whichever key on the IceBox Remote #2 you wish to "K" and Bob's your uncle.

Edit: I may have been over-ambitious about the ability of the Kodi Keymap Editor to map keyboard letter strokes, but there is another way to use it to bring up the list of recordings.

1. Install the Add-on and Run
2. Select Edit, then you have the option to set a mapped key globally or while in full screen live TV.
3. Choose which you want, then scroll sown to Windows and select Open TV Recordings.
4. Follow the prompts to assign a key on the remote, then back out and Save.

I've tested it on a Windows installation of Kodi and it works fine on a Live TV screen. You'll still need some way to execute an ESC  key to back out of the recordings list.

Thanks for that.  I will experiment with this idea.  The difficulty I see is that the button I would like to use is shared with the OK button at least in Live TV.  Which is kind of why I suspect the remote itself needs reprogramming and I don't expect @Daniel Hall has an app for that...  No USB connector on the remote!
Title: Re: Remote 2 feedback and query
Post by: raymondjpg on March 27, 2025, 10:39:33 AM
Quote from: srto2 on March 27, 2025, 09:32:47 AMThe difficulty I see is that the button I would like to use is shared with the OK button at least in Live TV.
I don't have a Remote #2 so just looking at an image of it is the mute button at top right? The button below that is it some sort of list button? Is that the one you want to remap?

I don't understand how any of the buttons other than the OK button, clearly labeled towards the centre of the remote, would be used to share "...with the OK button at least in Live TV".
Title: Re: Remote 2 feedback and query
Post by: IanL-S on March 27, 2025, 11:09:38 AM
I would expect that the RCU is programed at the factory, so probably now easy was to reprogram them.

One thing is not clear to me is if the two keys are sending the same signal, or if they send different signals that the firmware recognizes as the same function under some conditions. I am inclined to believing the latter is the case.

I an app that identifies the RCU codes sent to Toppys. I may work with the IceTV RCU - if I have time I will check it out.

Ian
Title: Re: Remote 2 feedback and query
Post by: Daniel Hall at IceTV on March 27, 2025, 11:17:24 AM
With the first IceBox remote we were not able to get the keycodes changed to be exactly as we wanted, so while we could get the IceTV logo put on the button it was still the backspace key. This was re-mapped in Kodi (but it seems not within the LiveTV context).

As we could not break compatibility with Remote #1 (and as we could change the keycodes in the second remote) we have tried to get each of them to work out of the box, so in this context it meant that recordings was once again set to backspace. We can however look at fixing keymap in the LiveTV context.
Title: Re: Remote 2 feedback and query
Post by: srto2 on March 27, 2025, 11:50:42 AM
Quote from: Daniel Hall at IceTV on March 27, 2025, 11:17:24 AMWith the first IceBox remote we were not able to get the keycodes changed to be exactly as we wanted, so while we could get the IceTV logo put on the button it was still the backspace key. This was re-mapped in Kodi (but it seems not within the LiveTV context).

As we could not break compatibility with Remote #1 (and as we could change the keycodes in the second remote) we have tried to get each of them to work out of the box, so in this context it meant that recordings was once again set to backspace. We can however look at fixing keymap in the LiveTV context.
Thanks Daniel!
Title: Re: Remote 2 feedback and query
Post by: NBOSTI on March 29, 2025, 08:42:32 PM
I purchased the remote 2. I had no end of hassles with the original, found a great replacement and was happily using until "2" came along.
With my curiosity and FOMO I ordered it.
Quick delivery and works as described. Much improved over "1".
My only niggle would be the dedicated "Home" button.
For example; If I go into "timers" and press "Home" , I am taken to the Home Screen , as would be expected.
But if I go into any timer there to edit it  and then press "home" I get an audible beep suggesting that action is not allowed, so need to use the "back" button to return to that parent folder.
Same with entering "Recordings".
I can"t really see the need for a home Botton unless it takes you "Home" from any menu that you may be in.
My preference would be that  both the "Return" and "Home" buttons on the bottom rocker were one and the same,
continuous and performed the same action, "Return".
And before I get any advice on re-mapping keys via kodi whatever,.. that is well out of my ability nor desire to do so.
I would end up with a remote opening the neighbours doors, starting their cars and turning devices on and off unwittingly.
 Just an input as to how I have found it to work.