IceTV Forum

IceTV IceBox => General => Topic started by: nathgreco on June 01, 2023, 11:36:34 AM

Title: email Current IceBox issues qusestion
Post by: nathgreco on June 01, 2023, 11:36:34 AM
Hi, I have just received this email regarding issues with the icebox, is it possible someone can elaborate on the issues?  as usually if I find an issue I will do some research myself, and I don't want to waist my time researching issues if its a currently known by Icetv

Thanks
Nathan   
Title: Re: email Current IceBox issues qusestion
Post by: MD on June 01, 2023, 11:48:10 AM
The main problem has been the SSD going into read only and the fix has been to leave the box unplugged for 12+ hours. The reasons for the failure and fix working are not properly understood and we are working with the manufacturer to get to the bottom of it with a solution.
Title: Re: email Current IceBox issues qusestion
Post by: nathgreco on June 01, 2023, 12:06:43 PM
thank you, luckily I haven't experienced that. Fingers crossed a solution is found soon
Title: Re: email Current IceBox issues qusestion
Post by: IanL-S on June 01, 2023, 12:08:49 PM
You only need to unplug the IceBox for 10+ hours if it fails to boot (startup), or (repeatedly) jams while starting up. If the IceBox starts up in the normal way, as a matter of prudence, I do a soft reset.

Title: Re: email Current IceBox issues qusestion
Post by: MD on June 01, 2023, 02:11:23 PM
Although we don't believe that is anything like acceptable hence the free sub until we get to the bottom of the darn thing.

It's random so accurate fault finding has been difficult but we believe we are near to understanding the reason (which is not overheating so the long time period unplugged, measured in hours, to successfully restart is a puzzle best left to a physicist specialising in silicon!).
Title: Re: email Current IceBox issues qusestion
Post by: IanL-S on June 01, 2023, 02:41:59 PM
I have seen no evidence of my IceTV IceBox overheating; the demands on CPU of running the IceBox hardware are relatively modest, even when simultaneously recordings multiple recordings and playing back a recording or watching live TV.

I had a BYOB IceBox that overheated, but that was (I suspect) due to its significantly more modest hardware specifications. Cannot be said to be at all representative of what BYOB users can expect - the BYOB power supply died with sparking - also killed it. My current BYOB setup, an ancient Intel i5 NUC also runs cool - cooler than the IceTV IceBox.
Title: Re: email Current IceBox issues qusestion
Post by: raymondjpg on June 02, 2023, 10:15:12 AM
Quote from: IanL-S on June 01, 2023, 02:41:59 PMMy current BYOB setup, an ancient Intel i5 NUC also runs cool - cooler than the IceTV IceBox.
+1 with an 8th generation Intel i5 NUC, In my case running cooler than with Win10 or Win11.
Title: Re: email Current IceBox issues qusestion
Post by: DeltaMikeCharlie on June 04, 2023, 04:42:56 PM
Quote from: MD on June 01, 2023, 11:48:10 AMwe are working with the manufacturer to get to the bottom of it with a solution.

Are you also able to ask the manufacturer if they have a BIOS version that supports wake-on-USB?
Title: Re: email Current IceBox issues qusestion
Post by: Hati on June 05, 2023, 07:16:45 AM
I am one of those people with the issue above mentioned. Lost a bunch of recordings twice now. But also found a workaround that has now "performed" adequately twice.

The SSD issue sends you into the BIOS. If you just use "save and exit" option, it puts you right back into BIOS again, however selecting the "save and" or "exit and reset/reboot" option (can't remember exactly) actually makes the drive usable again.

First time this happened was at the latest firmware change. I was doing something else at the time so only paid half the attention to it, but after one try I got the box back to normal. The second time this worked I was away and had my wife do the same and worked again I think the third try did the job.

At the moment we have too many recordings to save them all and play with this, but if someone else having this issue could try the "fix" would be great.

Edit: I just came across a screenshot of the BIOS page posted by DeltaMikeCharlie (thanks). It's the "save changes and reset" option I used.
Title: Re: email Current IceBox issues qusestion
Post by: nathgreco on June 05, 2023, 01:20:35 PM
the issue just hit me save and reset didn't do anything, just waiting i guess
Title: Re: email Current IceBox issues qusestion
Post by: Hati on June 06, 2023, 07:36:01 AM
Quote from: nathgreco on June 05, 2023, 01:20:35 PMthe issue just hit me save and reset didn't do anything, just waiting i guess


How many times did you try the "save and reset"? I had to do it multiple times and there is a bit of wait involved.
Title: Re: email Current IceBox issues qusestion
Post by: nathgreco on June 06, 2023, 08:06:07 AM
was a few times, gave it a rest then tried again eventually it came good,
Title: Re: email Current IceBox issues qusestion
Post by: PeteRyde on June 10, 2023, 12:57:40 PM
My icebox has the issue (again). Unfortunately the "Save Changes and Reset" multiple times didnt help. Nor did waiting an hour and trying the "Save Changes and Reset" multiple times again. Hopefully the unplug for 10+ hours will resolve it.
Not sure if it it was a coincidence but mine was running fine for a number of weeks including late last night. Had a short power outage (10 min) this morning and found it in the stuck boot state.
I'm hoping I dont need to re-install and lose another week of recordings (again).
Title: Re: email Current IceBox issues qusestion
Post by: IanL-S on June 10, 2023, 01:56:05 PM
Not good news. I do not recall having this particular issue. That could be because my beta testing IceBox has slightly different hardware (has third video out - VGA) and different bios date (but same bios number - how is that for potential confusion).

It is very annoying if you end up loosing your recordings. For the computer savvy, if it is possible to use a USB stick with Linux installed on it and copy the content of the \media\recordings directory to a USB drive, then copy them back when the IceBox is up and running. Then do a soft reset and the recordings should be back.

Earlier this week I had a Beyonwiz T2 which stopped recognizing its HDD. For some reason PVRs running Linux have a propensity for file system corruption. I have also had it happen with my Topfield PVRs. Fortunately, in most cases the recordings are recoverable if you have the appropriate software (which I have).
Title: Re: email Current IceBox issues qusestion
Post by: PeteRyde on June 11, 2023, 12:08:52 PM
Unfortunately the waiting 12+ hours didnt work for me. I left it unplugged for 14 hours and no change to the symptom. Tried again doing numerous "Save Changes and Reset" with no luck. Need to rebuild it (again!). I really hope a fix is available very soon. It kind of defeats the whole point of having IceTV.
Title: Re: email Current IceBox issues qusestion
Post by: raymondjpg on June 11, 2023, 02:13:12 PM
Quote from: PeteRyde on June 11, 2023, 12:08:52 PMI really hope a fix is available very soon. It kind of defeats the whole point of having IceTV.
I hope so too, because my experience with the IceBox BYO in an 8th generation i5 NUc has been that the software works pretty much flawlessly. I would have little hesitation in saying that as a TV recorder it functions as well as two Beyonwiz PVRs that I currently have operational still.

If I recall correctly all the Topfield and Beyonwiz PVRs I have had over the years have had teething problems. That is not to excuse the issue with the IceBox SSD, but without having a unit to look into or test it looks to me like potentially a more robust and long term solution as a PVR than the aforementioned Topfield and Beyonwiz boxes, that when I opened them up for one reason or another all looked as if they had been knocked up in some back yard operation. If the IceBox is largely solid state soldered down like a NUC I see a better prospect for longevity.

As far as I am concerned there is really no service other than IceTV that enables me to set and record programs I am interested in remotely. I might take issue with what I see as persistent problems with accuracy of EPG and repeat flags, but there really is no alternative.
Title: Re: email Current IceBox issues qusestion
Post by: IanL-S on June 11, 2023, 05:11:08 PM
I can assure IceBox owners that the IceBox development team is very concerned about this issue. For the best part of two week the development team and the beta testing panel have been flat out testing the IceBox so that the cause of the problem can be isolated. This has been a seven-days-a-week effort, starting early in the morning and well into the night. I am looking forward to its end - I want to get my life back!

I came late to Beyonwiz, but I was Topfield beta-tester for from 2010 until the demise. Early in the model cycle there were always difficulties. And yes, the build quality was not always what one would like.
Title: Re: email Current IceBox issues qusestion
Post by: PeteRyde on August 22, 2023, 10:04:18 PM
Is there an update on this issue?
Is the only fix still to reinstall from a USB?
My icebox is bricked again. Yet another week of all recordings lost and some older ones. I've tried the save & reset multiple times and leaving it powered down. They didn't work the previous two times either.
I love icetv programming my recordings but the box being unreliable is killing me.
Title: Re: email Current IceBox issues qusestion
Post by: MD on August 23, 2023, 07:45:17 AM
Hin Peter,

I posted this on a different thread on Sunday:

We will certainly replace the SSDs.

If the customer is happy to do it themselves, as it only involves removing the IceBox base with four screws, unplugging the old SSD and plugging in the new one, we will send the new SSD to them. The new SSD will have been preconfigured by us with the correct BIOS preferences and IceTV software preloaded. The customer will just need to login as they do now after a soft reset.

If they prefer they can send the IceBox back to us, we will copy all the recordings on the old SSD to the new one then return it so, apart from about a week's turnaround time, it will now work reliably with old recordings and new ones coming up as their IceTV account sets them up when they log in again.  We have just purchased the cloning device for the copying.

This week, after much tooing and froing, we will be told by the Chinese manufacturer as to our cost for the new SSDs and the delivery schedule. I'd expect to have them, subject to freight and customs, in about three weeks.

This has been a horrid time for all involved and I'd hope we'll soon be over it with customers enjoying the IceBox as we always hoped. Then we can get down to smoothing out some clonky setup UI wrinkles and add more exciting features such as auto ad skipping.
Title: Re: email Current IceBox issues qusestion
Post by: IanL-S on August 23, 2023, 11:27:19 AM
PeterRyde,

Not good news. I have fortunately not had this happen for some time now.

I think it is possible to recover the recordings by booting with a Linux "live CD", and copying the /storage/recordings directory (including subdirectories to a USB HDD). Then do the USB reinstallation. Once the setup has finished, copy the /storage/recordings directory (including subdirectories) back to the IceBox via SFTP. Do a soft reset and the recordings should be recovered. A bit messy and takes a bit of time.

You can copy just the recordings you want (but copy everything in the .backups directory. Can be difficult working out which ones you want.

Ian
Title: Re: email Current IceBox issues qusestion
Post by: PeteRyde on August 23, 2023, 09:31:55 PM
Awesome news that there's an end in sight. Bring on those new SSDs.
My screw driver is ready to go!
Title: Re: email Current IceBox issues qusestion
Post by: richardv on August 24, 2023, 03:04:58 PM
I have just had this issue as well, will try the powerdown for 12hrs
Title: Re: email Current IceBox issues qusestion
Post by: Hati on August 25, 2023, 06:09:08 AM
I haven't had the issue for some time now, but then I plugged the box into a UPS.

@MD: I'll be happy to swap the SSD myself, once you guys are ready to go with them.