Are the current restrictions on information for channel Nine TV guide over now, since IceTV won the court case?
Can be expect a more accurate TV guide for channel Nine again? instead of the current 'N/A' titles for many timeslots.
This is a good question and I'm surprised that the official announcement on the news page doesn't say anything about what the win means to subscribers.
There are over 20 'N/A' listings still in the Program Guide over the next week as at 10.30pm today.
Come on IceTV, we love the fact that you've given Channel 9 a bloody nose and we want to share the taste of victory, but it's a bit hard when we're not told what it actually means! Will it mean the end of:
* N/A listings
* incorrect timings of Channel 9 programmes that are listed correctly in other publications?
Ice are prolly just checking with their lawyers to ensure they know exactly where the boundaries are before saying or doing anything as the case has had significant implications for copyright in Australia.
As I understand it (and im not a lawyer), you can no longer expect to copyright a list of facts or information, you can only copyright the structure and presentation providing they are original and not obvious (eg the structure of day, date, time & duration, as per the Nein vs IceTV ruling, is obvious and not original)
Hi all
Please be assured that we will let you know as soon as possible what today's High Court decision means for Ice TV subscribers as it relates to the IceGuide. We will continue to abide by the orders of June 2008 when compiling the schedule for 9 and affiliates until the full legal implications of the ruling are made clear to us.
We understand how frustrating the "N/A" notifications are and genuinely appreciate everyone's patience over the last ten months, and indeed over the last few years as we fought this case.
Thanks
I think that is a wise decision - we have waited this long so a little longer won't hurt us!
Quote from: brianh on April 23, 2009, 05:54:25 PM
I think that is a wise decision - we have waited this long so a little longer won't hurt us!
Yes, the chances are we could go a few months and not miss anything that's any good on the Nine Network!
Hi Ice Guy's & Gal's, any word on when the laywers will let you guy's resume cross checking against the published guides?
Check the response (http://www.icetv.com.au/index.php?topic=1786.msg8412#msg8412) in another thread, looks like it could still be a long wait.
Quote from: Kirben on May 06, 2009, 11:38:50 AM
Check the response (http://www.icetv.com.au/index.php?topic=1786.msg8412#msg8412) in another thread, looks like it could still be a long wait.
Thanks but I was after an estimate and there isn't one in those posts from Madeline.
Quote from: djos on May 06, 2009, 01:47:50 PM
Quote from: Kirben on May 06, 2009, 11:38:50 AM
Check the response (http://www.icetv.com.au/index.php?topic=1786.msg8412#msg8412) in another thread, looks like it could still be a long wait.
Thanks but I was after an estimate and there isn't one in those posts from Madeline.
This is about as good an estimate as they can give. The way I read it it sounds like Two Weeks or longer depending on how fast (or should I say slow) the legal process takes.
Quote from: Madeleine at IceTV on May 04, 2009, 04:19:04 PM
The High Court victory did not address the matter of the order from last year, which came from a different court and is a separate, though connected, issue requiring more submissions, paperwork etc.
12 days may seem like a long time but these processes are slow. "Legal time" is different to real time - like dog years, in reverse, so to speak.
We will certainly let people know as soon as anything changes.
Quote from: Vortical on May 06, 2009, 01:58:06 PM
This is about as good an estimate as they can give. The way I read it it sounds like Two Weeks or longer depending on how fast (or should I say slow) the legal process takes.
Quote from: Madeleine at IceTV on May 04, 2009, 04:19:04 PM
The High Court victory did not address the matter of the order from last year, which came from a different court and is a separate, though connected, issue requiring more submissions, paperwork etc.
12 days may seem like a long time but these processes are slow. "Legal time" is different to real time - like dog years, in reverse, so to speak.
We will certainly let people know as soon as anything changes.
The 12 Days is very vague and the judgment was on the 22nd April (2 weeks ago).
Quote from: djos on May 06, 2009, 02:19:56 PM
Quote from: Vortical on May 06, 2009, 01:58:06 PM
This is about as good an estimate as they can give. The way I read it it sounds like Two Weeks or longer depending on how fast (or should I say slow) the legal process takes.
Quote from: Madeleine at IceTV on May 04, 2009, 04:19:04 PM
The High Court victory did not address the matter of the order from last year, which came from a different court and is a separate, though connected, issue requiring more submissions, paperwork etc.
12 days may seem like a long time but these processes are slow. "Legal time" is different to real time - like dog years, in reverse, so to speak.
We will certainly let people know as soon as anything changes.
The 12 Days is very vague and the judgment was on the 22nd April (2 weeks ago).
I think that the 12 days is actually quite precise and refers to the time from when the judgment was handed down (22 Apr) to when Madeleine posted (4 May).
Quote from: djos on May 06, 2009, 02:19:56 PM
The 12 Days is very vague and the judgment was on the 22nd April (2 weeks ago).
Yes it is but as was also discussed by the IceTV Rep the final High Court judgement didn't have anything covering the judgement in the previous court case that forced IceTV into the postion of modifying the Nine EPG into the state it's currently in.
Edit: As prl stated above it appears the 12 days may be the time already past up to the time Madeline@IceTV posted. Sp all we can do is sit tight and wait.
Hi all
Sorry for any confusion, the "12 days" did refer to how long it had been since the High Court verdict...
I have been informed that a date has been set for an audience with the court to have the order from June 2008 lifted.
This matter will be heard on Monday 18th May. (Strangely enough, in 12 days time).
We will make an announcement after the matter has been heard to inform subscribers about how this affects Nine scheduling, as well as anything they'll need to do etc.
Thanks
Thanks Madeleine, thats exactly the info I was after. :)
Bloody Justice system, you'd think it would be an instant smack down to the lower court order when you've had the lower court judgments quashed by the high court? ???
+1 to the comment by djos, let's hope logic prevails on the 18th
Hi
Just to keep everyone in the loop... the court date has been moved to Friday May 22nd. This was beyond our control and had to do with legal paperwork from the High Court.
Thanks
Arrgh, Justice eh!
Thanks for the update Madeleine
and the result was?????
I can still see "N/A Channel Nine". :(
There are still restrictions and IceTV do not have any rights or intention of 'copying' any other guide. We still utilise out predictive process, as we did before the court case. However, it is true, the Channel Nine Guide will improve. Over the next week you will notice the N/A's disappear as we re-employ our original methods. Thanks for your patience on this.
I Thought "time & title" where deemed by the high court* to be not copyrightable as they weren't considered "original literary works" as apposed to the show descriptions which are considered literary works?
*I'm not a lawyer but I read the all transcripts in their entirety.
Quote from: Mitch IceGuide on May 23, 2009, 12:27:21 PM
There are still restrictions and IceTV do not have any rights or intention of 'copying' any other guide. We still utilise out predictive process, as we did before the court case. However, it is true, the Channel Nine Guide will improve. Over the next week you will notice the N/A's disappear as we re-employ our original methods. Thanks for your patience on this.
That's great news Mitch
Thanks for the update.
It might be worth putting some info in a news article and email update :)
Quote from: djos on May 23, 2009, 12:32:22 PM
I Thought "time & title" where deemed by the high court* to be not copyrightable as they weren't considered "original literary works" as apposed to the show descriptions which are considered literary works?
*I'm not a lawyer but I read the all transcripts in their entirety.
What you say is, as far as I know, correct, but the orders issued in the first appeal by Nine are still in place. IceTV is bound by them until the orders are lifted by the court that imposed them (which wasn't the High Court). That is expected to happen at the hearing due on Monday 24 May. "The Wheels Of Justice grind slow, but they grind exceeding fine ..."
Also very much not a lawyer, but Madeleine at IceTV has said much the same.
1. There is no Monday the 24th of May this year.
2. Per Madeline post above hearing had been postponed and rescheduled for Fri the 22
May.
3. Hopefully details of the result will be posted eventually but they havebeen alluded to in a post above by Mitch.
It is currently 9:52 AM in Sydney and a complete 7 days worth of Ch 9 seems to be available!
Adelaide data is up to scratch now too! :)
Win HD in the ACT is almost all "N/A Channel Nine". For example, on Sat 30th, there's a single block of "N/A Channel Nine" on ACT WIN HD starting at 00:00 and running 1440 minutes - that's 24 hours, folks! Other days have more blocks but it's mostly N/A.
I wasn't actually using the 9HD data in Sydney but have just turned it on. 4hrs N/A Sun am in Sydney otherwise fine. ( HD seperate programming is very new.
This is what I'm currently seeing as "N/A Channel Nine" in the WIN NSW HD IceTV guide for the ACT:
Date
Time Duration
Wed 27 May
0900 2h
1630 3h
2130 1h
Thu 28 May
0300 2h
0500 30m
0900 2h
1630 5h
Fri 29 May
0215 3h15m
0900 2h
1630 1h30
1800 6h
Sat 30 May
0000 24h
Sun 31 May
0000 3h
0300 2h
0500 2h
0700 4h
1800 2h30m
Mon 1 Jul
0200 3h30m
0900 2h
1630 4h
2130 1h
Tues 2 Jun
Only ABC and SBS data available
The prime time shows that actually do show up in the prime time/Evening (6pm-12am) ACT IceGuide for WIN NSW HD are:
Wed 27 May
2030 The Mentalist
2230 Young Lions
2330 Stingers
Thu 28 May
2130 The Footy Show (AFL)
2330 Rugby League: Super League (UK)
Fri 29 May
No WIN NSW HD programming in the IceTV guide
Sat 30 May
No WIN NSW HD programming in the IceTV guide
Sun 31 May
2030 CSI: Crime Scene Investigation
2130 CSI: NY
2230 Days that Shook the World
2330 MOVIE: Tigerland
Mon 1 Jun
2030 Sea Patrol
2230 AFL: Footy Classified
2330 Comedy, Inc.
Tues 2 Jun
Only ABC and SBS data available
All the shows I've listed except The Mentalist, CSI, CSI: NY and Sea Patrol, are in slots where the programming in WIN NSW HD is different content from WIN NSW. For what's in the guide, when WIN NSW HD is showing different content from WIN NSW, the WIN NSW HD content isn't HD (this last point should be taken as a criticism of WIN, not of IceTV).
Complete? I don't really think so.
Hi Peter
We're aware of the continuing issues with WIN HD and we know it's frustrating, which is why Mitch cautiously said "over the next week". It's really a problem specific to WIN, unfortunately, though it's similar to the ABC HD issue.
We're doing a WIN HD schedule off our own bat. The alternative is to have no WIN HD schedule at all (we don't really want to do this) or to dump all the SD shows in between the gaps, which we did at one stage until we were informed by subscribers that it was wrong. As you know, even if a show is available in HD or flagged as HD this can't be relied upon when it comes to WIN, who go off and do their own thing.
What we will do soon is get rid of the old "n/a" and put in a no data message or something similar that only appears on WIN HD.
Thanks
Thanks Madeleine.
I agree that IceTV made the right choice in including SD multicasts on WIN NSW HD in the IceTV guide. I was only grumbling about WIN/Nine's decision to put SD material on the HD service.
I'm looking forward to the gaps getting filled in over the next few weeks.
We'll do our best with WIN HD.
It comes back to that issue of assuming they do what everyone else does only to find out that they don't. WIN is clearly struggling with some HD issues and this flows on to the way we schedule the channel.
Quote from: Madeleine at IceTV on May 27, 2009, 11:55:56 AM
...
What we will do soon is get rid of the old "n/a" and put in a no data message or something similar that only appears on WIN HD.
The "no data" entries on Tues 2 Jun for WIN NSW HD in the ACT now have the title "WIN HD". That seems a bit odd as a choice.
Quote from: prl on May 27, 2009, 09:44:40 AM
This is what I'm currently seeing as "N/A Channel Nine" in the WIN NSW HD IceTV guide for the ACT:
SNIP
Complete? I don't really think so.
I think I found the problem. 8)
Quote from: djos on May 27, 2009, 08:12:30 PM
Quote from: prl on May 27, 2009, 09:44:40 AM
This is what I'm currently seeing as "N/A Channel Nine" in the WIN NSW HD IceTV guide for the ACT:
SNIP
Complete? I don't really think so.
I think I found the problem. 8)
I know that WIN's scheduling is a bit all over the place, but I still have a whole bunch of gaps in the IceTV data I get. I'm happy for now that Madeleine has said that they're working on the problem.
The point I was trying to make was that just because the restrictions on using Nine's Time & Title data has apparently been lifted (still no statement from IceTV about it though), and that Sydney and other Nine regions now have much better data, doesn't mean that all the "Nine and affiliates" data is of the same quality.
Quote from: prl on May 27, 2009, 05:03:33 PM
Quote from: Madeleine at IceTV on May 27, 2009, 11:55:56 AM
...
What we will do soon is get rid of the old "n/a" and put in a no data message or something similar that only appears on WIN HD.
The "no data" entries on Tues 2 Jun for WIN NSW HD in the ACT now have the title "WIN HD". That seems a bit odd as a choice.
Now changed to be more like what Madeleine suggested. The missing information on WIN NSW HD for the ACT is now showing as "No data - WIN HD" for Tuesday and Wednesday.