Hi Raymond
I was thinking maybe of getting a USFF Dell, HP or Lenovo, as these units are physically bigger, and while they do take up extra space, they should run cooler - the GEN 10 NUC I have here, would be more than adequate, if I were considering that size, but if I go for a HP Elitedesk G5 or G6 which have either Gen 8 or Gen 9 i5 or i7. most come with at least 8GB and some come with 16GB - but it's the room inside, there is plenty of room for a 12mm 2.5" SSD or a 2TB SSD - iirc the 4TB SSD is thicker, but it's still smaller than your typical 2.5" Spinning Disk. I haven't seen any of the higher performance drives, like the WD Purple Surveillance drives in anything smaller than a 3.5" configuration and I suspect a 1TB WD Blue 2.5" HDD might be a SMR drive - as all the drives I've seen in 2.5" over the past 5+ years, anything smaller than a 5TB 2.5" portable HDD have been SMR drives.
Correct me if I am wrong, the Blue WD as 2.5" HDD is WD absolute entry level drive - which would likely make it a SMR drive, unless you have had it for more than 5 years - I first encountered 2.5" external SMR portable spinning HDD as far back as 2018.
So If you have a 1TB WD Blue SSD in a 2.5" SATA config, I am certain that has enough speed to read and write video, but its limited by its SATA interface. Even mSATA drives are still limited by their 600MB/sec interface afaik.
I have a Samsung mSATA in a HP Probook G4 from 2017.
I have purchased three different Elitebook G7 and G8 and these come with M.2 SATA, but it depends on which model - some have room for a 2nd full sized 2280 M.2 SSD and some have one which is only half size, and you can buy 1TB and maybe 2TB in that shorter smaller, forgot the length.
I wouldn't use a laptop for a DVR, but it would be handy to look at the screen rather than running a remote ssh shell to it from somewhere else on the network, and a laptop definitely doesn't have the room, not any more, back in 2017-2019, many of the Probooks were thick enough you could buy a 2.5" bracket, but buying the bracket was about $50-80 and then you needed screws, and the only way to get screws is to buy a screw kit which has enough replacement screws for the laptop or whatever you are working on.
I found a few suppliers on AliExpress who sell screw kits but they are not well labeled and if you want a particular M size screw, it can be a bit of trial and error to find the right one.
The larger size of the USFF HP, Lenovo or Dell computers are about the size of four NUCs stuck together, but about 75% of the hight. Some of the refurbs have brackets and 256GB SSD and some have M.2 SSD slots, but looking at the motherboards of the Elitedesk G4 and G5 which have in front of me right now, one is a 8500 i7 not sure of the CPU speed but it would WAY fast enough, the G4 Elitedesk 800 Mini came with a 256GB 2.5" SATA Drive on a bracket, but the motherboard has room for a 2280 M.2 SSD slot and another smaller slot for Bluetooth and Wifi, which lucky enough this one does.
So I took the old 2.5" 256GB SSD out I had to remove the bracket to get to a few other things, and put in a Samsung 880 Pro M.2 1TB Drive, and had to mark a BIOS setting so that it recognised it had different storage, it away we were going, and installed Windows 11 24H2 and Windows update picked up every single driver available for that G4
With the G5 Elitedesk 800 Mini - that has a Gen 9th i5, but the speed between the units is hard to tell on everyday work - but the Gen 8 i7, its got cooling mesh and a massive fan, and if I push that to download Usenet, then the fan comes on and the SSD will hit high 60s, sometimes low 70s depending on the size of the files I am grabbing.
The cooling fan is very effective, but its a noisy bast*rad when you push it.
The G5 Elitedesk 800 Mini, I put in a 512GB Evo 870 as the M.2 SSD slot is only PCIe 3.0 so it, the three Elitebooks all have 880 Pro or 890 Pro Samsung SSD - yes, I am a bit of a hardcore Samsung fan only because I have about 2 dozen of them going back to 850s and not one has failed, the oldest drive would be the 850 and that is in a GBRIX or Gigabyte NUC Clone but it only has a Celeron CPU, and is so slow it makes you want to tear your hair out, but once it has booted, as long as Windows 10 and 11 have 16GB they perform pretty well, regardless of what you throw at them.
The except is Gen 2, Gen 3, Gen 4 and Gen 5 CPUs - in fact since I started using Gen 8 i5 and i7, trying to use an old Gen 5 with Windows 10 even with SATA SSDs in all of these machines, they are SLOOOOOOOOOOW.
You find lots of ex-lease gear on eBay if you know the quality refurbish vendors, they usually will thoroughly check everything, one company sent me a 256GB SSD, which I wasn't planning on using, but it's WEAR LEVEL was doing 40% and there is no way I would use an SSD with a WEAR LEVEL that low - TBW is a good measure of how much data a SSD has moved in its life, but with video files, they tend to be larger, say 1GB for an hour of HD.
So I check other SMART variables to keep an eye on them, but I've argued with a few refurbishes that I doubt that many corporates would allow their SSD drives to be resold, as I've been involved with upgrades with spinning drives, and we either send them to a shredder who gives us a certificate on every drive they shred, there is a reburbisher that takes old drives for parts for people trying to recover the controller and get their data back. They too give a certificate of DOD wipe on the SSD or HDD.
I have directed a few people with HDD Spindle motors or Controller boards which have failed. and they need the data back, but I've never heard anything back whether they were able to recover the drive.
There are no HDD Clean 10 rooms in AU afaik, or at least there wasn't in the 2000s as I had to recover a 120MB SATA Drive which ended up going to five recovery places in Melbourne before I found someone who said, your actuator arm is probably broken, and if the drive is opened outside a clean 10 room I think he called it, a partial of dust is usually bigger than the space between the read/write heads and the surface as it floats nanometers above the surface.
SSD failure, I've personally had almost 2% success with one Crucial SSD, I managed to read the contents of the drive, but the controller chip as soon as it hit about 40C, it failed.
I passed on to a colleague who does SMD/SMR board level repair with a heat gun and microscope and his assessment was after removing and resoldering he lost all ability to communicate with with the SSD, but I'm not sure of what hardware he was using to read it.
Sorry, got off track again, but I think those USFF Ex-Lease PCs would do the job, just need to do a fair amount of reading and make sure I've got suitable hardware - but I suspect those ICE TV Dual Tuners are rebadged somethings and they are probably good quality.
So that may be my plan from here - I managed to disable Tuner A via software in the Beyonwiz T4, and am now using Tuner B as the Priority and Main Tuner, the biggest issue I am seeing is that the signal strength feeling those T4 is way higher than what the T4 says its getting in terms of dBm.
However, I believe this is a known issue and was always a problem for people.
So I get a few dropouts, but rescanning all the five transponders and getting actual names took me half a day and a change of RG6 Quad quite a few times to get enough single into the Beyonwiz Tuner B - but its recording, with the occasional macroblock dropout - despite me trying to boost the signal, originally, I had to put attenuation on that when I lived in Melbourne - the problem I have here is the hill in the way of the Mt Alexander Transmission tower and the moving trees, that even a Phase Array and a Masthead Antenna can't help me - I'd need 40-50 metres in high to "see" over the hill and everyone around me has an array of different antennas, from basic log periodic right through to Phase Array to get a signal.
I have enough signal, but the Beyonwiz seems like it needs double and most devices don't want that much signal - so I think it was a design flaw and probably has been spoken about for years.
Thanks again Raymond - I appreciate your help and comments, and looks like I might be doing BYO but I've gotta find some components that are suitable to put into a unit before I try build my own Ice Box.
Thanks everyone for your advice.
Cheers, Darren
I was thinking maybe of getting a USFF Dell, HP or Lenovo, as these units are physically bigger, and while they do take up extra space, they should run cooler - the GEN 10 NUC I have here, would be more than adequate, if I were considering that size, but if I go for a HP Elitedesk G5 or G6 which have either Gen 8 or Gen 9 i5 or i7. most come with at least 8GB and some come with 16GB - but it's the room inside, there is plenty of room for a 12mm 2.5" SSD or a 2TB SSD - iirc the 4TB SSD is thicker, but it's still smaller than your typical 2.5" Spinning Disk. I haven't seen any of the higher performance drives, like the WD Purple Surveillance drives in anything smaller than a 3.5" configuration and I suspect a 1TB WD Blue 2.5" HDD might be a SMR drive - as all the drives I've seen in 2.5" over the past 5+ years, anything smaller than a 5TB 2.5" portable HDD have been SMR drives.
Correct me if I am wrong, the Blue WD as 2.5" HDD is WD absolute entry level drive - which would likely make it a SMR drive, unless you have had it for more than 5 years - I first encountered 2.5" external SMR portable spinning HDD as far back as 2018.
So If you have a 1TB WD Blue SSD in a 2.5" SATA config, I am certain that has enough speed to read and write video, but its limited by its SATA interface. Even mSATA drives are still limited by their 600MB/sec interface afaik.
I have a Samsung mSATA in a HP Probook G4 from 2017.
I have purchased three different Elitebook G7 and G8 and these come with M.2 SATA, but it depends on which model - some have room for a 2nd full sized 2280 M.2 SSD and some have one which is only half size, and you can buy 1TB and maybe 2TB in that shorter smaller, forgot the length.
I wouldn't use a laptop for a DVR, but it would be handy to look at the screen rather than running a remote ssh shell to it from somewhere else on the network, and a laptop definitely doesn't have the room, not any more, back in 2017-2019, many of the Probooks were thick enough you could buy a 2.5" bracket, but buying the bracket was about $50-80 and then you needed screws, and the only way to get screws is to buy a screw kit which has enough replacement screws for the laptop or whatever you are working on.
I found a few suppliers on AliExpress who sell screw kits but they are not well labeled and if you want a particular M size screw, it can be a bit of trial and error to find the right one.
The larger size of the USFF HP, Lenovo or Dell computers are about the size of four NUCs stuck together, but about 75% of the hight. Some of the refurbs have brackets and 256GB SSD and some have M.2 SSD slots, but looking at the motherboards of the Elitedesk G4 and G5 which have in front of me right now, one is a 8500 i7 not sure of the CPU speed but it would WAY fast enough, the G4 Elitedesk 800 Mini came with a 256GB 2.5" SATA Drive on a bracket, but the motherboard has room for a 2280 M.2 SSD slot and another smaller slot for Bluetooth and Wifi, which lucky enough this one does.
So I took the old 2.5" 256GB SSD out I had to remove the bracket to get to a few other things, and put in a Samsung 880 Pro M.2 1TB Drive, and had to mark a BIOS setting so that it recognised it had different storage, it away we were going, and installed Windows 11 24H2 and Windows update picked up every single driver available for that G4
With the G5 Elitedesk 800 Mini - that has a Gen 9th i5, but the speed between the units is hard to tell on everyday work - but the Gen 8 i7, its got cooling mesh and a massive fan, and if I push that to download Usenet, then the fan comes on and the SSD will hit high 60s, sometimes low 70s depending on the size of the files I am grabbing.
The cooling fan is very effective, but its a noisy bast*rad when you push it.
The G5 Elitedesk 800 Mini, I put in a 512GB Evo 870 as the M.2 SSD slot is only PCIe 3.0 so it, the three Elitebooks all have 880 Pro or 890 Pro Samsung SSD - yes, I am a bit of a hardcore Samsung fan only because I have about 2 dozen of them going back to 850s and not one has failed, the oldest drive would be the 850 and that is in a GBRIX or Gigabyte NUC Clone but it only has a Celeron CPU, and is so slow it makes you want to tear your hair out, but once it has booted, as long as Windows 10 and 11 have 16GB they perform pretty well, regardless of what you throw at them.
The except is Gen 2, Gen 3, Gen 4 and Gen 5 CPUs - in fact since I started using Gen 8 i5 and i7, trying to use an old Gen 5 with Windows 10 even with SATA SSDs in all of these machines, they are SLOOOOOOOOOOW.
You find lots of ex-lease gear on eBay if you know the quality refurbish vendors, they usually will thoroughly check everything, one company sent me a 256GB SSD, which I wasn't planning on using, but it's WEAR LEVEL was doing 40% and there is no way I would use an SSD with a WEAR LEVEL that low - TBW is a good measure of how much data a SSD has moved in its life, but with video files, they tend to be larger, say 1GB for an hour of HD.
So I check other SMART variables to keep an eye on them, but I've argued with a few refurbishes that I doubt that many corporates would allow their SSD drives to be resold, as I've been involved with upgrades with spinning drives, and we either send them to a shredder who gives us a certificate on every drive they shred, there is a reburbisher that takes old drives for parts for people trying to recover the controller and get their data back. They too give a certificate of DOD wipe on the SSD or HDD.
I have directed a few people with HDD Spindle motors or Controller boards which have failed. and they need the data back, but I've never heard anything back whether they were able to recover the drive.
There are no HDD Clean 10 rooms in AU afaik, or at least there wasn't in the 2000s as I had to recover a 120MB SATA Drive which ended up going to five recovery places in Melbourne before I found someone who said, your actuator arm is probably broken, and if the drive is opened outside a clean 10 room I think he called it, a partial of dust is usually bigger than the space between the read/write heads and the surface as it floats nanometers above the surface.
SSD failure, I've personally had almost 2% success with one Crucial SSD, I managed to read the contents of the drive, but the controller chip as soon as it hit about 40C, it failed.
I passed on to a colleague who does SMD/SMR board level repair with a heat gun and microscope and his assessment was after removing and resoldering he lost all ability to communicate with with the SSD, but I'm not sure of what hardware he was using to read it.
Sorry, got off track again, but I think those USFF Ex-Lease PCs would do the job, just need to do a fair amount of reading and make sure I've got suitable hardware - but I suspect those ICE TV Dual Tuners are rebadged somethings and they are probably good quality.
So that may be my plan from here - I managed to disable Tuner A via software in the Beyonwiz T4, and am now using Tuner B as the Priority and Main Tuner, the biggest issue I am seeing is that the signal strength feeling those T4 is way higher than what the T4 says its getting in terms of dBm.
However, I believe this is a known issue and was always a problem for people.
So I get a few dropouts, but rescanning all the five transponders and getting actual names took me half a day and a change of RG6 Quad quite a few times to get enough single into the Beyonwiz Tuner B - but its recording, with the occasional macroblock dropout - despite me trying to boost the signal, originally, I had to put attenuation on that when I lived in Melbourne - the problem I have here is the hill in the way of the Mt Alexander Transmission tower and the moving trees, that even a Phase Array and a Masthead Antenna can't help me - I'd need 40-50 metres in high to "see" over the hill and everyone around me has an array of different antennas, from basic log periodic right through to Phase Array to get a signal.
I have enough signal, but the Beyonwiz seems like it needs double and most devices don't want that much signal - so I think it was a design flaw and probably has been spoken about for years.
Thanks again Raymond - I appreciate your help and comments, and looks like I might be doing BYO but I've gotta find some components that are suitable to put into a unit before I try build my own Ice Box.
Thanks everyone for your advice.
Cheers, Darren