Main Menu
Menu

Show posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Show posts Menu

Messages - superdadplus

#1
Humax / Re: Padding and missing the ends of shows
December 05, 2013, 01:30:43 AM
QuoteI solve this problem by paying careful attention to when my recordings are made and by having four tuners (in two PVRs) available to resolve core time and padding conflicts. I need to find the latter myself.

In all seriousness, what's the point of IceTV then? I may as well just read a printed schedule and program things manually.

sdp
#2
Humax / Re: Padding and missing the ends of shows
December 03, 2013, 10:33:10 PM
Thanks for your response PRL.

I don't recall us having this problem when we had an ozTivo, but if this is a feature of all 'modern' PVRs then... well, I'm back to pining for a Tivo (and not for the first time :^(

However, I don't understand a couple of points in your explanation.

QuoteIf you have a reasonably crowded recording schedule, then reporting conflicts of padding time on the PVR is likely to produce a good number of false alarms.

Under what circumstances would a false positive occur? As I understand it, start times always trump end times, so whenever I have one scheduled show finishing at 830 and the next scheduled show starting at 830 I will be facing a potential problem unless the other tuner is available.

Certainly there are some shows where the last couple of minutes aren't so important, but equally there are others where last (or first) couple of minutes are important. IceTV (and the humax) are aware of which tuners are in use and could flag potential problems, allowing me to make case by case decisions about how to handle the possible problem. (A classic use case for computer assisted scheduling.) Currently, I have to eyeball my entire schedule and try to spot where problems might be, which is precisely the kind of thing that PVRs were supposed to help me out with (weren't they?)

At any rate, it's nice to know I've correctly identified the problem. I've removed the start time padding which, I hope, will stop us from missing the final tag joke in every damn sitcom we record.

QuoteThe root problem, anyway, is of the networks' making, not IceTV's.

I don't see how that's the case. The root problem is that the service and equipment I purchased from IceTV has certain failure modes. IceTV have all the data required to recognise when these failures could be triggered and could warn me, but they don't. The networks have nothing to do with that.

thnaks!

sdp
#3
Humax / Padding and missing the ends of shows
December 03, 2013, 01:04:22 PM
Hello.

My family and I have laboured along with this for some time and I'm finally having another go of getting it sorted out.

I suffer from the  'missing the ends of shows' problem that gets mentioned here from time to time.

It appears that the problem occurs when both tuners are in use and the Humax has to 'switch' to recording the new show.

If I have three minutes of "start padding" set, the Humax will switch to recording the new show 3 min before the scheduled start, which in practice seems to be a minute or two prior to the end of the current show.

If the two shows are on the same channel, I will get the missing minutes at the start of the second show recording, but that requires that I know which recording was immediately following.

If the two shows are on different channels, then the end of the first show is never recorded.

Am I mistaken in my description of the issue? If I'm correct then I have this complaint:

Why can't the humax, or IceTV warn me that there is scheduling conflict and show me the problem recordings in the schedule so I least have the option of fixing them?

If I'm incorrect, are you able to correct me?

thank-you

d