Main Menu
Menu

Show posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Show posts Menu

Messages - NiallG

#1
General Discussions / Re: IceTV Resurrected
October 16, 2015, 07:39:23 PM
Ok well good to hear you guys are up and running again (EPG not Skippa).

however... 

I was really unimpressed that there was ZERO notification given to existing subscribers - all I received was the 3rd party Voluntary Administrator email which had news of our subscription $$ being lost quite literally buried 'in the fine print'. There was no information on when the service may be stopped/interrupted - although it stop getting updated on Tuesday. Short of staff/management here being banned from communicating with end users (which I doubt) - there's really no excuse for this behaviour - it just seemed like you guys decided 'stuff everyone, we're going under so why bother doing the right thing and letting people know what's going on'..  (PS: just posting stuff in the forum is not acceptable - you should have emailed at bare minimum).

Secondly, given it's basically all the same people/investors running IceTV v2 (whatever it's going to be called) - and essentially the same people who were holding the reigns - I think it's pretty unacceptable that you want to RECHARGE paid up subscribing customers a second time. I think all these users (including myself) should be given complimentary subscriptions for remainder of paid period + then you can start charging us again. If you go back and look at your records you'll see most of us have been subscribers for years (I think possibly 7 years or more for myself) - so it stands to reason that we'd resubscribe again as soon as paid period had expired (although monthly billing seems most sensible given risks to users).  While I understand the money has been swallowed in your Skippa fiasco (of which I have nothing to do with or a customer of) - it's about doing the right thing for goodwill and ongoing business - not doing a big short term money grab.

Once again sh*t happens, business goes stale, but it's about doing the 'right thing' no matter what. I try to support Aussie business where I can, but there's just a certain line that was crossed here. Anyhow - given the really poor behaviour/handling of what has happened (and the money regrab) - I'm now not sure if I've got the trust to resubscribe. There's plenty of working EIT + MHEG5 scrapers where I can just get the data myself - have all that working again now + was on verge of reconfiguring my setup to use it.

So I think it's in IceTV v2's court here, how about doing the right thing. You can start off by actually emailing everyone and telling them what's going on. Then have a good hard look at your recharge everyone business strategy - surely you can do better than that.

my 2 cents.

Niall








#2
Hi -

I've been noticing a lot of issues with the xmltv listings with invalid start/stop times etc over past week on various channels. I thought it might have just been a screw up with your DST calculations - but the problem has not gone away now that DST has kicked in.

One particular example is next Friday Night on Channel 9 + 9HD..

For example :

<programme start="20100409135000 +0000" stop="20100409155000 +0000" channel="7">
      <title lang="en">Rugby League: NRL Championship Season</title>
...
</programme>

and then

<programme start="20100409140000 +0000" stop="20100409160000 +0000" channel="7">
      <title lang="en">Movie: Striking Distance</title>
...
</programme>


Note that second start time is prior to first entry stop time. Most of the listings for friday night are then all over the place. (ie. shows which are not showing at all). Same thing happens for 9HD ..


Also - you guys keep publishing invalid xmltv data and then publishing different (or fixed) xmltv data a few hours later. This is a real pitb - can you please get it right the first time.


thanks
Niall






#3
Quote from: hamping on July 15, 2009, 09:24:36 PM
Well, with respect, that's not very helpful either. Logos are not a compelling reason to use BSG EPG. Its a one off process and there is freely available software available to to do it (as you know).

If you want to say that ICE Tv's service can't and won't be able to do something with WIN 7 as well as BSG EPG can or will do, you need to at least say what it is. I'm just asking why you see the service that this forum relates to is or will always be deficient? Is it limited to the AMG data and certain cover photos? This is quite different to saying how you achieve it from a software engineering persepctive.  And given that the answers about what WIN 7 is capable of is all in a Microsoft specification somewhere, its probably not such a secret anyway. It is, however, a good thing to discuss here for the benefit of subscribers....

The best solution is - if you want to get more of an understanding about how it gives you a better end result than a pre-prepared feed (and a more manageable/configurable solution over long term) -  download it and give it a shot - or come accross to the forums linked to above - and chat with others choosing to use it in combination with icetv feeds (even though they are aware there is just the option to just use the icetv mxf/win7 feed) - so that way you can make a more informed decision. (it's definitely not all about the channel logos - thats was just an 'example' of one feature you probably won't get from the premade icetv feed).

If you want to just use the icetv mxf/win7 feed thats your choice too - not trying to push you to do anything you don't want to do ...  but in same respect I'm not here to provide a bullet point 'check-list' of it's features for others to mimick/replicate (who may have sat unhelpfully on the sidelines when their assistance was really required) - and some of it isn't (and never will be) in the spec - partially due to a large portion of my solution being written before any spec was published. I'm also not here to spruik/advertise my product. I mainly responded in here due to all the mentions/links to my product (and references to steps/procedures which were flushed out with a lot of hard work by myself, lobbying and of course feedback from my beta testers) - and of course to answer to some incorrect assumptions on not going to the high court 'yet'...    :)
#4
Quote from: hamping on July 15, 2009, 12:30:46 PM
Niall, what data do you think that ICE TV will not be able to include?
I doubt you will ever even get to see the channel logos from icetv (given the relationship between icetv and the "big boys") - and as for providing a list of the other '11 secret herbs and spices' - no thanks.....  ;D..


#5
Quote from: hamping on July 14, 2009, 06:51:59 PM
Quote from: NiallG on July 14, 2009, 12:23:39 PM

Anyhow - if you've got any q's about Big Screen EPG etc - please visit the abovementioned threads for more. If you want to use both products together - and you want to help make that experience as nice and workable as possible - then please contact icetv and tell them so (and hopefully encourage them to actually answer/follow up my emails to them over past few months).

cheers
Niall


Niall, I think that the program you have written is great but probably too hard for most non-tech/time poor users. However, my view is that if you have subscribed to the data from ICE Tv and ICE Tv support windows 7, then they should support a native feed that already has all relevant meta data in the right format for Win 7. If they ultimately don't do this, they will lose subscribers.

From my understanding - icetv won't be able to offer 100% of the metadata required at any point for windows 7 (even when they do fix up the metadata 'issues' in current implementation).   

The solution I offer is actually very simple and quick for a non-technical user to get going (and actually a lot simpler then the process required to get the icetv win7 solution going - which looks very technical atm once 'all' the required steps are taken). For Big Screen EPG installation/configuration - there's currently a couple of 'enhancement' steps in there (which aren't 100% necessary) which require some user interaction - and it's all these steps that could be completely eliminated if there was some co-operation from icetv (and make the installation of big screen epg for icetv a complete no brainer - with no configuration steps required at all except for user supplying their icetv username/password).  Anyhow you'd probably need to have a look at v0.4x of my product (and set it up for icetv) to understand what I'm getting at here. (and use your imagination on what a 'big screen epg for icetv' installer might look like - if I had some agreed integration points with their service).

#6
Quote from: hamping on July 14, 2009, 12:04:15 AM
Quote from: muzzakus on July 13, 2009, 06:32:54 PM
Tell us more about this Big Screen EPG.  Is this the ultimate EPG solution and a should be incorporated into the mix to get most out of the MCE configs ?

See the thread here: http://www.xpmediacentre.com.au/community/big-screen-software/37329-big-screen-epg-v0-4-discussion-support-thread-14.html

It's beta software.  Seems from the post above that ICE Tv can, subject to any legal issue, provide a lot of the full meta-data smarts in its native feed to WIN 7 - if they want to. Its just a question of implementation.

Big Screen would be essential if you were trying to process feeds from hundreds of disparate sources and needed to organise all that information. But ICE Tv only has to deal with a few Free To Air stations in Aus, so they should easily be able to apply all relevant data for WIN 7 directly into their feeds....most of it is already there as far as I can see...


Hi to try and answer those q's above :

Everything to do with Windows 7 / EPG is regarded as 'Beta' software because Windows 7 itself is still in beta (and may change at any point up until RTM release). Also - the importing of EPG's itself is not a 'supported' or 'guaranteed to work' scenario by Microsoft (and the disclaimers on the technical docs released by Microsoft emphasize this) - so this always invokes uncertainty - and "beta" and "use at own risk" type statements are made by all concerned.

In terms of bse vs icetv's win7 solution (not their standalone xmltv feed) - my take is that BSE is designed to work 'with', 'enhance' and 'fix' data from IceTV XMLTV feed (not the ictv win7/mxf feed) - as well as other sources. It should be used 'with' the epg provider: ie. I'm not trying to 'replace' icetv, oztivo or any elses core business of supplying the epg data (and this is why when you setup BSE there's a quick configuration option and presets for icetv xmltv feeds) - nor am I trying to replace or compete with any XMLTV Downloader products (such as the one provided by epgstream).

The architectural difference between the two solutions (again referring to icetv's win7 solution - not their raw xmltv feed) - is that BSE is a locally installed application (with it's own Windows User Interface) - that does the processing of downloaded data locally - and provides the end user a lot of configuration options - giving you power to do stuff like import channel logo's etc. For example - I don't provide any actual channel logo files - but instead give you the ability to assign channel logos to epg channels as part of the processing (if you've downloaded these logos from somewhere - or created them yourself). Also - when bse detects common metadata issues in the XMLTV (such as the ones preventing AMG Movie data etc appearing) - it will proactively fix these problems up when it runs. As the BSE product is updated very regularly - with new versions appearing quite often (and often within days/hours of a problem being raised) - then you again can benefit from that control over the processing and imported data.  Because it isn't being done all online (and locked in) - user controlled deployment of bse products updates can be pushed out a lot more easily at user discretion. (ie. icetv needs to be 100% sure of ramifications before they can change anything their feed as it will instantly impact every single user without end user being able to choose this).

In the case of the icetv win7 solution - they do all the processing at their end - and give you the final mxf file to import (so there's no configuration points for you - other than nominating your state/channels online). This works to a point (if they are getting the data 100% correct and providing all the metadata you want - neither I believe is the case right atm) - but if there's an issue (ie. unique episode problems for series recordings) - or a copyright/ip issue with supplying some metadata (as is providing actual channel logos) - you can't do anything about it until they sort the problem on their servers. While I'm sure some of these problems will get sorted over time - generally I've noticed an extremely long lead time to get things fixed up at icetv (due to many reasons such as the way they collect/enter/store and distribute their data).

Both solutions (bse and icetv) are also heading towards providing additional features in the realms of remote web and mobile phone based recording for Windows 7 (as is Microsoft themselves via Live Mesh and Web Guide ) - so the functionality offered there is also a differentiating factor. (I've made some announcements / blog posts already on what I'm intending with BSE - not sure where anyone else is with their solution)

Hope that helps answer those questions.   :)

Also - without meaning to hijack this thread or use it as a soapbox to spruik BSE - it would be good to actually get some co-operation from icetv with their xmltv (and other metadata). So far they have been pretty much unresponsive and difficult with issues relating to integrating their feeds into BSE / 7MC - and I've had to sort out 99% of icetv metadata related issues on my end (which is a bit frustrating seeing as I'm fully encouraging users to still use their epg service and trying to enhance that experience). In fact - quite ironically the only correspondance I have received from icetv in past few months is that latest 'refer a friend' bulk email which started with the line 'As a small Aussie company in a land of media giants, we often get pushed around and are overshadowed by the bigger boys as most people know. '....  ??? ???

Anyhow - if you've got any q's about Big Screen EPG etc - please visit the abovementioned threads for more. If you want to use both products together - and you want to help make that experience as nice and workable as possible - then please contact icetv and tell them so (and hopefully encourage them to actually answer/follow up my emails to them over past few months).

cheers
Niall



#7
Quote from: hamping on July 12, 2009, 10:52:13 PM
Yes, I am, as well as the ability to add logo's to the guide grid.  It is possible for IceTV to add images and guide logos, however that might throw up various copyright issues so it'd be something that their lawyers would need to consider.
IF Big Screen can do it, presumably ICE Tv can too.., but then Big Screen hasn't been to the high court on a copyright case yet!
b.t.w, the the Geo code hack hasn't resulted in any AMG data popping up for me. Is there anything else to do other than that. Do you need to install MC after changing the value, or can you simply rely on mcupdate.exe -uf ?
there's no 'yet' about it... "big screen epg" (or any other big screen product) doesn't sell, infringe on (or give away) anyone else's copyrighted material. Also there's lots of additional code and smarts in big screen epg to fix up and enhance bad/incomplete epg data (being able to view the proper movie metadata is just one of these benefits) - and gives you control over the full set of features in win7 media center epg (beware of cheap AND expensive imitations)..  ;)
#8
Quote from: Russell at IceTV on March 11, 2009, 09:23:33 AM
Quote from: NiallG on March 11, 2009, 09:00:47 AM
I think maybe your EPG team modified them at last moment - but I need to check

Quite possible.

Quotewhy do you have episode # of '-0' being assigned to what is obviously a new episode? This causes issues (on VMC and Win7) - and even if you don't have the new episode title/description - you at least know it's a new episode being shown (and you can preallocate an ID to it - with a 'TBA' etc as episode Title).  Then when you have an encore performance (ie. sunday night) - the same id should be allocated - so the PVR system know's it's the same episode screened as previous monday.

When the guide team starts working on a new day, they take data from the previous week, and then modify the episodes for those shows that are episodic.  At the moment I can see that the episode hasn't been set yet for that series on 16 March yet, but I assume it will be soon.  The only exception would be if for some reason they didn't know what episode it will be.  Remember that this is on channel Nine, which is handled differently by the guide team because of legal reasons, so it's possible that's why it hasn't been set yet.  But it's usually always done well before air time, so it should still get recorded.  Until it's set, the show is handled the same as if it was non-episodic, and the episode id is set to zero.

What issues are you seeing with it being zero?  Media Center should still schedule the show on the 16th for recording (even though it won't have any episode info for it at the moment) because it should still see the showing on the 16th as being part of the same series recording.  It seems to work fine in Win7 at least, which I just now checked.  Are you seeing something different?

Quote
Also - the 'previously-shown' tag (when used) - should have the date of when it's previously shown. This is a no-brainer for Underbelly (as it's an Encore performance) - so should always be the previous monday's date. I understand on some content - you may not know original air date (where it was first shown before icetv existed).

The guide team fills in this data when they can.  It's possible they didn't know that new episodes are on Monday and repeats on Sunday, or maybe they just didn't get to it yet.  When there's no date available, the XMLTV guide includes an empty previously-shown element to indicate that it's a repeat.  Most systems interpret an empty element correctly, even without an actual date.  In the MCE guide, we use a date of 1900-01-01 to indicate the same thing -- that it's a repeat, but we don't know the original air date.

Russell

Hi -

I checked back on the data - and looks like the EPG team over there edited this data at last moment (so looks ok right at this instant) - however during the time it wasn't fixed (which I think was right up until the day of airing) it wasn't working.

With regards to use of episode '0' - this is a bit of a problem - as it makes it quite a bit more difficult to determine what is a new episode and what isn't (and makes processing of the xmltv feed a lot harder)...  For example - if you get the EPG on Monday - and it has data for that night through to following Monday - then all 4 screenings (9/9HD = x2 screenings - not including the encore) will be marked as episode 0 (and hence difficult to determine that there are 2 x unique sequential episodes there).

In your Win7 feed - i think you're actually referencing the same parent Program from each of the four schedule entries (ie.   '!Program!XXX-0'  ) - so once this program has been successfully recorded once - 7MC may not recognize other screenings to be new episodes. (as 7MC makes a decision on whether to record something partially based on whether a successful recording occurred previously).

So anyhow - it would make things a whole lot easier if your EPG team could preallocate a unique EpisodeID - even if you don't yet know the episode title/overview.  That way you'd have a unique Program UID for each actual episode (that would be shared accross the HD simulcast - and through to the encore showings on Sunday night).

thanks

Niall






#9
Hi Russell,

I think maybe your EPG team modified them at last moment - but I need to check (I have incramental snapshots taken of your xmltv going back 2 weeks). To confirm - I also downloaded your Win7 feed as well yesterday - and I'm 99% confident it also picked up same error and had isRepeat="true" marked.

However - why do you have episode # of '-0' being assigned to what is obviously a new episode? This causes issues (on VMC and Win7) - and even if you don't have the new episode title/description - you at least know it's a new episode being shown (and you can preallocate an ID to it - with a 'TBA' etc as episode Title).  Then when you have an encore performance (ie. sunday night) - the same id should be allocated - so the PVR system know's it's the same episode screened as previous monday.

Also - the 'previously-shown' tag (when used) - should have the date of when it's previously shown. This is a no-brainer for Underbelly (as it's an Encore performance) - so should always be the previous monday's date. I understand on some content - you may not know original air date (where it was first shown before icetv existed).

Niall
#10
Hi -

Your XMLTV Feed has been incorrectly marking 'Underbelly 2' (Nine) as a repeat for it's 8:30pm Monday Night Showing (which is supposed to always be a new episode) - and incorrectly includes the <previously-shown /> element.  (but doesn't include a 'previously shown' date)

My Location : Melbourne
Guide Source : XMLTV feed

I think the other Underbelly listings seem to be incorrect as well - ie.

For next week - there is a repeat screening on Sunday Night (10:30pm) - where no proper episode id has been provided (and one of the entries is not marked as repeat) - and then on Monday night it's marked as a repeat (on both 9 and 9HD).

This same problem existed with feed for last night (where Underbelly was listed as a repeat by inclusion of the <previously-shown/> element).

Can you please fix this.

Thanks
Niall




#11
Windows Media Center / Re: Vista MCE Fiji Update
December 09, 2008, 12:32:39 PM
Hi -

My IceTV subscription is about to expire - and since the new TVPack fixes are working now - I'm switching off my old (pre TVPack) system and will only be using TVPack + Win7. I'd really like to use your service still (appreciate the data quality when its there) - but basically it's not an option.

However - from my understanding of the EPG situation - Mike Hayton has only indicated he will release some notes at some point on how the MXF format works (and how to use loadmxf in Win7) - but this is only half the solution - and you will still need to figure out how to get around the db protection in TVPack. Because the db protection side is a sensitive area (involving copyright / breech of terms of use etc) - it's unlikely that anyone who does figure it out will post this information (as they could get in a lot of grief). 

That being said - it does look like it's definitely possible (from a coding pov) to get it working on TVPack (but no where near as 'easy' as the upcoming Win7 beta1+ release - which will provde a working loadmxf). Also - AFIK - you can already get samples of the MXF file's used (in a Web Service scenario) by setting your system up for a supported country like UK and capturing the temp files.

So the question is - are you guys actively investigating (from a code pov) how to get the EPG working on TVPack - or are you simply waiting for Mike Hayton (or someone else) to provide the MXF/loadmxf information to you? (and hence have given up on TVPack).

Niall