Main Menu
Menu

Show posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Show posts Menu

Messages - richardp

#1
It would also be cool if the IceTV staff could specify recommended paddings for shows. For example, if we all know that a particular show consistently runs 20 mins overtime, Ice could set 20 mins as a recommended padding for that show.

Users could then set show-specific paddings and they would also have their global padding settings that apply to all shows by default. (One of the padding options for show and global settings would be 'Ice Recommended', which uses the recommended paddings, as above, by default.)

The padding durations should be sent to the device as a padding duration and not simply by extending the schedule's times since that would probably create conflicts with other shows. The devices can use their padding priorities to decide whether to favour the first show's padding or the start of the second show if applicable.
#2
If a show gets an error icon (which I find is usually because there are already 2 shows recording at the same time), I'd like to see Ice automatically attempt to record a repeat instead (this could be a user-configurable option of course). I would suggest that Ice should only look for repeats of the same episode within a 7 day period. I know ABC often does this by repeating shows on ABC2 the following day, and now it seems that GO! is repeating some shows at a later slot even on the same day.

This could be further extended by switching the failed scheduled recording for one of the successfully queued ones if the former has no alternates but the latter does. I appreciate that this would be a lot more complex though.

Another related idea is a priority system. Shows/series could be assigned a priority (1-5 or 1-10 scale perhaps) by the user. If schedules are always sent to the device in order of priority, then any shows that can't be recorded due to no available timers would already be those with the lowest priority. I often find that the 'wrong' show (in my opinion) is the one that misses out when these conflicts occur.
#3
Drop Dead Diva (Monday 9.30pm Nine) is incorrectly listing the actors from Dexter (Michael C. Hall, Julie Benz, Jennifer Carpenter).
#4
The PVR should be responsible for combining consecutive timers. Beyonwiz and Topfield (and whoever else implement IceTV Interactive) should add an user option for automatically combining consecutive timers into a single file, and maybe even adding a bookmark at the point where the second timer starts.

This is not a feature that IceTV should implement since it makes more sense for IceTV to tell the PVR when each timer is and the PVR can do what it likes with them, such as combining them.
#5
To recap what I posted earlier in this topic and to summarise what has been suggested more recently:

The scheduling interface on IceTV needs to allow the user to

  • select the channels to record on - default to any but allow it to be filtered (multi select, eg: Ten, Ten HD and Seven HD)
  • give preference to recordings based on

    • broadcast start time (ie: record the earlier channel)
    • broadcast format (ie: SD or HD)
  • prioiritise the above criteria - should preference be given to start time (if applicable) or format (if preference is given to start time, the earlier screening will record regardless of the format; if preference is given to format (or both formats screen at the same time) then the preferred broadcast format will be recorded regardless of start time)
  • select the days to record the channel on - default to any day but allow it to be filtered (this also allows daily shows to only be recorded on a couple days of the week)

The fact that AFL (and other shows) can have the same name on two different channels is a good thing. This allows the user to set a single series recording for all AFL matches and they can get them all. If they only want channel Ten recorded, they filter it as such.

In the case of Dexter, set it to prefer HD. It will record HD when available and fallback to SD when not available on the HD channel.

In the case of shows in two different timeslots (eg: IPL Cricket back in May), if preference is given to HD, it will record in HD regardless of whether it airs first or second (and only fallback on SD if not available on HD). If preference was instead given to start time, it will record the channel that starts earlier. If both channels start at the same time, then preference will be given based on the HD/SD option instead.

Providing each episode is correctly identified by IceTV's system, all should go well. If the same episode is broadcast on multiple channels, whether it be the same network or not, it has the same ID. The same ID would be used whenever it is rebroadcast, even a year later. If different episodes of the same show are on two different channels, even at the same time, they should have different IDs and therefore both be recorded.

Does everyone agree so far? And does anyone have anything to add or change?
#6
Quote from: j s on June 11, 2008, 07:02:01 PM
This isn't really what Bruiser333 was saying. In his instance the IceTV EPG was updated in a timely manner but the timer created by Interactive earlier wasn't adjusted to reflect the new timeslot.

Until the networks are forced to make public announcements of scheduling changes it will remain difficult for Ice to be 100% accurate with last-minute schedule changes but your issue with that would be better lodged in the EPG Content forum.

I know what Bruiser333 was saying. However, both issues are related. Although in this case the EPG was updated, there are many times that it is not. It no longer just means that the EPG is slightly inaccurate, now it means that timers could be missed. So obviously the timer update problem needs to be fixed but without an accurate EPG, there will be little point.

Also, my other point was that if other free online guides can be updated in a timely manner, why is the Ice EPG (a paid service) often not updated?
#7
I often find that the Ice Guide is wrong because of schedule changes. I can look at various online guides and see that there are changes, but the Ice Guide on my PVR as well as the widget don't seem to update with the changes. I haven't really used series recordings yet but I have recorded shows based on the Ice Guide on my PVR only to find that the show was moved to a different timeslot or something. I would expect a paid service to remain up to date and reflect any changes in scheduling up to a couple hours before the fact.
#8
Log in and click on 'My Account' at the very top. Then select 'Interactive (Devices & Tokens)' on the left. Then beside your device, there is a link to 'resend all recordings'. If this works correctly, I assume it should send all the timers to the BW again, including those it has already sent.

As for the actual error message, I guess IceTV will have to find this error and display a nice message saying that 'you already have this show set to record' instead.
#10
Quote from: bruiser333 on May 17, 2008, 09:56:27 AM
I have had other strange behaviour from Interactive, such as a timer that keeps getting created in the past! I delete it, but it keeps coming back even though the scheduled time has long gone.
I've had that happen too. I created quite a few series recordings but after I had problems with the first couple not recording properly, I cancelled the series recordings and set up timers on my PVR instead. I thought I'd give it a bit of time before I use series recordings again (just so any problems are ironed out). Anyway, for the next week, it kept recreating the timers in the past. Deleting them (on the PVR) just meant they'd come back next time it synchronised. And they weren't showing up on Ice.

The only way I could solve it was to create a new device on Ice (ID 1 instead of 0), delete the old device from Ice, and tell the PVR to use the new device instead. I assume it's a Beyonwiz problem that it keeps trying to revert to device 0 each time I turn it on. So the next day, I deleted device 1, created a new device 0 and then all was working fine.

No idea what went wrong but I've finally sorted it out for now. I'll return to using series recordings after most of the reported problems seem to be fixed.
#11
I was thinking a similar thing yesterday. While most shows are shown on the SD and HD channels, there are times that something else is shown on HD (eg: IPL cricket on Ten) in the place of the usual show (eg: Rove this Sunday is only on SD, since cricket will be on HD at the same time).

If I had set the series recording to 'Ten HD' only then I would miss Rove this week. If I set it to 'any channel', then I wouldn't miss it this week, but on a normal week where it appears on both channels, I could either end up with it only recording one channel (which seems to prefer Ten (SD) over Ten HD) or two recordings (one for each channel).

I haven't worked out how Ice works this out since sometimes I find only 1 channel set to record, while other times both channels are set to record. I would imagine that Ice should have some way to identify if the same program is showing on both the SD and HD channel and only tell one of them to record. If this is happening, it isn't always working.

The next step requires some sort of priority system where users can specify which channel they want recorded if it is available on both SD and HD channels. In addition to the obvious options for giving priority to SD or HD would be the option to give priority to the first channel to broadcast (some shows, eg: IPL cricket, is shown earlier on HD), although this option would still need to give priority to either SD or HD when both channels are broadcast at the same time.