Main Menu
Menu

Show posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Show posts Menu

Messages - mtb

#91
Ha ha ha ha, oh how my heart bleeds for them.... NOT!

Perhaps, if they stopped wasting all their money on frivelous lawsuits, they'd have some left to spent on decent programming content and wouldn't be so deep in the mire. 

I, for one, would/will not mourn their passing.
#92
As long as the ABC and SBS data is accurate we're happy, the rest is just a bonus.  As for Nein, we couldn't really be bothered if the whole station dropped off the map.

I'm glad I saw this post in time, managed to renew with just under an hour to go - thanks bodogbodog.
#93
Quote from: philzgr8 on June 30, 2008, 02:15:38 PM
I'm afraid I have to agree with Impact here. It's not about giving them time to fix what they took away, it's about the fact that they chose not to notify anyone before pulling the plug on the data.
If you took the time to read all the relevant posts and news items at the time this was happening, you would have seen that Ice's legal advice was to not to post ANY information regarding the real reason for the removal of the data.  The following is a quote from the e-mail that was issued...

"Acting under legal advice, we were prevented from fully informing our customers as to the reasons for this lack of guide data. We sincerely apologise for any inconvenience this may have caused our customers."

Given the true nature of the reason for the data not being produced, I think people should think twice before ranting about a lack of information - Ice are trying hard in trying circumstances, cut them a little slack!
#94
Quote from: prl on June 27, 2008, 09:40:44 AM
I'm not sure of the effectiveness of people who record programs, in part for the ability to skip ads, telling advertisers that they're going to stop watching their ads.
That is the very flaw in Nine's argument, the (tenuous at best) link between an EPG and skipping ad's.  We don't record in order to skip ad's, we record because we can't/don't want to watch the programmes at the time they are broadcast.  It is because we can record a programme by any mechanism (PVR, PC, VCR, etc.) which enables us to skip ad's, it has nothing to do with the source of the schedule data - that simply enables us to perform more accurate recordings of shows we watch rather than relying on out of date printed guides or having to scan the web daily "by hand".

As it happens we DO watch ad's (yes, really!), in order to keep up to date on pending shows and the occasional new product - but we only tend to watch them once or twice until the information is familiar and then we skip them.  Rather than jump the full 2.5 minutes or so of an ad. break, we tend to 30 second skip them - if we see something new, we'll tend to watch it until we deem it important or irrelevant and then skip or not accordingly.  After all, what is the point of watching the same old reality or game show ad's when you don't ever watch the show, it's almost negative marketing if you have to watch because it annoys you all the more.

So we consider there IS value in letting an advertiser know that the actions of a TV station are undermining their potential advertising audience.

One last thing...  If we contact advertisers, how did we identify that they are an advertiser...?  I guess we must have... watched the ad.!!
#95
Quote from: ackbar33 on June 25, 2008, 07:57:03 PM
There is a nice easy fix with all of this ...

No Nine Tv guide= We dont watch Channel nine.

I hope that makes them happy !
I phoned them in Perth today and told them just that... that their legal action had directly resulted in the loss of our entire family as viewers since we rely totally on the EPG from Ice.  I'm considering phoning the other Nein offices too, just to make sure to get the message across.

I also went through five old recordings we had (off sick) of The Dead Zone and noted forty five companies/entities in Perth who will be receiving letters explaining why their adverts will no longer be reaching us as we won't be watching Nein any more.

Anyone else who will also not be watching Nein, I would suggest do the same to keep the advertisers in the loop of why their advertising on Nein is not necessarily as cost-effective as before, purely as a service to them.

Quote from: mattk on June 26, 2008, 12:18:35 PMWe apologise for any inconvenience this process has caused some users. We completely understand some of your frustrations but unfortunately, although we were somewhat prepared for the Full Court's, we were advised at the time not to make any form of public comment or notification. I am sure most of you can appreciate this given the circumstances.
More power to your elbow fellas, when will Nein realise that they're hurting themselves as much as anyone else.

Oh, and if any "user" submissions are required/beneficial for any subsequent action, please feel free to contact me (and, I suspect, any other user on the forums!).

Quote from: mattk on June 25, 2008, 11:27:27 AM
We have also made further requests to certain TV Networks to permit or grant licensed access to IceTV to reproduce their weekly television listings within our IceTV Guide. It is our understanding that similar agreements must have been made for services such as TiVo to provide thier EPG information.
I think I shall also be writing to two other commercial networks and pointing out to them the likely result of them stopping Ice from providing EPG data for their network's programming, namely the loss of us as viewers.  Might also write to some more advertisers too...
#96
Quote from: mattk on June 22, 2008, 05:30:33 PM
We are currently experiencing technical difficulties in producing the IceTV schedule for Channel Nine. It is hoped that we can overcome these issues internally over the coming days and our coverage of Channel Nine's broadcast will be back to normal shortly after.
Good to hear that all is not lost yet, not that we'd actually miss anything just now - nothing worth watching on Nein at the moment anyway, just the occasional movie.
#97
Quote from: neilius on May 09, 2008, 11:45:07 AM
My suggestion to Ice TV is to license their software to us, not the EPG data, and modify the model so that we all can contrbute to and independently rebroadcast the EPG info.  If the data is coming from several thousand different places, and all Ice TV is doing is licensing their own software, then there's nothing Nein can do about it.
I've been playing and researching the idea of a P2P data collection mechanism around in my mind from the moment I read this news, sadly it is not an area I have any knowledge of or experience in programming in... but that can change!
#98
For what it's worth, my letter going to channel nein, plus copied to a number of advertisers and the minister (with appropriate covering letter)...
Quote
The Directors and Chief Executives of Channel Nine
<snip>

Dear Sirs,

I find it difficult to determine if your company is just completely out of touch with the modern age or if you are simply hell bent on self destruction.  I refer, of course, to the current on-going saga of your "supposed" copyright law suit against IceTV and again have to ask... are you totally blind or just plain stupid?

My family owns a PVR – a digital set-top box with embedded hard disk and twin receivers.  We do not buy newspapers, prefering to obtain our news and associated content on-line and are therefore subscribers to the IceTV Electronic Programme Guide data.  We enjoy the flexibility of time-shifting our viewing to fit in with our busy personal lives, with the additional benefits of increased capacity for on-line storage, on-screen guide/information and more advanced recording features.

The use of certain software on our personal computer combined with the IceTV data permits us to record numerous programs and series without fear of missing episodes due to scheduling mistakes, alterations or late changes, by checking the data daily against our list of favourite programme titles, actors, genres and/or other attributes and then automatically setting the timers on the device without human intervention, for viewing when convenient.

As a direct result of this almost flawless recording system we have found that we are probably watching, as a family, about 30% more television than we did when we used the limited VCR and tape approach – we still rarely watch live TV, other than the news, but then again, we didn't before either.

So we are at a complete loss to understand why you should be wishing to destroy a company which is essentially helping to ensure that we, as viewers, are increasing our viewing time rather than reducing it;  unless, of course, this law suit has little to do with copyright are is more about the mistakenly related subject of advert skipping.

It has been suggested for some time and in many quarters that this is the real reason for the attempt to silence IceTV – because of the misguided belief that EPG = Advert skipping... what utter rubbish!  If you have been given this impression that the EPG is the sole reason for ad. skipping then you should get some new, competant, technical advisers – the humble VCR provided people with the ability to ad. skip years before the invention of the internet, never mind the EPG – it was called the fast forward button.

The humble EPG is nothing more than that... a programme guide, in electronic form, which enables users with the right equipment to make more accurate and relevant recordings, rather than relying on the less accurate and more out of date printed versions of the information.  While the various website versions of the TV guide are more accurate they are still inadequate for the task currently fulfilled by the IceTV data as they require human scanning - time consuming, innefficient,  ineffective and error prone.  Even those which provide some degree of searching and favourites are limited in functionality and there is still the need for the human to transfer those results to the recording device.

The actions of the viewer, irrespective of the technology, will not change overnight.  For ourselves, we still do sometimes ad. skip and sometimes we don't, just as we did with the old VCR.  Occasionally we use the breaks to make a drink or go to the toilet or make a quick phone call and sometimes we watch the ad's so we know about forthcoming events in our locale or actually see a product we are interested in (it does happen!). 

Your company should be adapting to this technology rather than trying to smother it;  you could be in discussion with IceTV, learning from them rather than trying to kill them off.  For example, has it even occurred to you to sell the final ten seconds of any ad. break at a higher premium since even the ad.skippers are likely to see that part as they try to find the segment start, whether on disk or tape?  What about the entire concept of the ad. break, how 1970's is that?  You need to start thinking outside of the box, rather than hiding within it.

You could already be providing the EPG data in ready-made form, perhaps with sponsorship messages appended to the extended information, to a company that seems to have the interest of your viewers closer to its heart than your company seem to have them.  You should be embracing a company which has helped increase the number of viewers, rather than alienating them.

Had the commercial stations come up with something... anything... better than the utterly pathetic Now and Next program guide (for want of a better phrase) in the first place, IceTV would likely as not have even have got off the ground.  You should be looking to them as saviours of free-to-air, commercial television rather than deperately trying to sue them and every other upstart who dares to think up something new which goes against your "tried and tested" (and boring) approach.

It was your own failure to have the foresight and desire to improve the package delivered to the digital viewer that created a void which IceTV filled, your own intransigence which threatens to make you an anachronism – a twentieth century TV station floundering in the twenty-first century content provider world, trying to survive by litigation and bullying the competition rather than coming up with new and creative ways to genuinely improve the package and their market share, in a world where the fickle viewer has so many more options and sources of content and only the best can survive.

Let me be honest, we don't watch many Nine series, just two or three perhaps (when you finally get round to (re)scheduling them), over half our weekly viewing comes from the ABC and SBS.  Where you do win though is with the occasional content, such as movies and features, which get picked up by the data scanning for actors, genres and etc. - this is where you can sometimes more than double the amount of Nine viewing in our household and generally content we would not generally see, were it not for the PVR software picking it up automatically.

So what of the future?  If IceTV continues but without your blessing and content, then you, and subsequently your advertisers, will lose viewers such as ourselves because your data will not be available to scan and set timers against.  If IceTV is driven completely out of business, you will still lose us as viewers and suffer our antagonism as well;  we shall find new sources for the SBS and ABC data and alternative sources for the lost content too, be it DVD, borrowed media or, dare I say, perhaps even downloading via torrents if all else fails, we have gone too far down the automatic recording path to be expected to go back to reading the TV guides, on-line or otherwise.

So, please, drop the bully boy image that you seem to relish so much, stop this ridiculous lawsuit which can only harm the industry in the long term and sit down with the right technical people, the IceTV people, and work our a better solution for all.  Look for new ways to deliver your advertiser's messages – PVRs are here to stay, irrespective of EPG content, and as with the VCR ad. skippers will remain ad. skippers however they record their content.  Adapt to the new technology and the benefits it can give you, the advertisers and the viewers, before you become so out of touch that you cannot recover.

As for encrypted EPG's?  Don't waste your time, all systems can be cracked eventually these days.  Anti-skipping PVRs?  Yeah, right!  Assuming you can actually get enough manufacturers on board, have you never heard of firmware updates?  Mod. chips?  The gaming industry has been fighting this losing battle since day one, just like all the copy protection schemes that have gone by the wayside.  As long as there are alternatives available, you won't stop people getting their data (and content) elsewhere.  In the current age, you have to live with the technology of the internet, not fight against it, or you will become irrelevant... and lose... and will your advertisers.

One final point.  I am copying this letter to the Minister for Communication and all the advertisers whose products and services are featured within those channel Nine programmes that we do watch, perhaps if you won't listen to us, the humble viewer, then perhaps they can make you listen to reason – because they will suffer from the dwindling numbers too – as you stumble blindly forwards towards oblivion.

Welcome... to the real world.

Yours faithfully,
#99
General Discussions / Re: Muting ads
April 06, 2008, 12:57:13 AM
I believe that in Europe there are some Taps for the Topfield which can trigger an ad. skip/mute function based on the audio type - 2.0 or mono for adverts and 5.1 for the programmes.  As has been said though, the networks would soon twig to this and tweak accordingly.

We find the simplest thing is never to watch live TV any more, let the Toppy and Ice combo. record all our favourites and watch at our leisure, skipping the ad's as the appear.
#100
General Discussions / Re: Perth DST Ends March 30th
March 30, 2008, 11:53:59 AM
Quote from: vincent on March 30, 2008, 09:52:35 AM
I am using a toppy and all appears to be correct apart from the TV information for ABC1 is on hour early in Perth
Glad I'm not the only one who seems to be having this issue, though stuff later in the week seems correct.

SBS doesn't seem to be right today either.
#101
IceTV EPG Content / Life on Mars, new season - 14th, ABC
February 09, 2008, 11:36:54 PM
Hi folks,

Life on Mars on the 14th of February, ABC, Perth, is being flagged as a repeat.  I believe this is the first episode of the second season and therefore should not be flagged as a repeat.
#102
True, but channel seven will at least since they are "sponsoring" the TiVo.  Once the others realise that there is potential in this they'll be forced to follow suit I believe.

Fortunately I had padded my Toppy with an hour at the end for all Torchwood so I didn't miss it - as the numbers grow of annoyed viewers grow, they'll have to take notice... eventually.
#103
One little gem that I picked up in one article I read (about the TiVo I think, sorry can't find again) was the wonderful benefit that all this might bring to free TV, namely the free commercial channels might finally have to start sticking to their published schedules at long last.

If a larger number of people do embrace this new technology and then find the shabby scheduling lets it all down, the offenders might finally get the necessary pressure put on them to improve... and that's good for us all.
#104
Excellent news guys, sanity reigns at last.
#105
IceTV EPG Content / Re: Torchwood
June 17, 2007, 09:24:11 PM
Quote from: paulgraham on June 17, 2007, 08:08:29 AM
Since it's on after Big Brother, you should extend the timer by about 30 - 40 mins any way!
Wow, you're optimistic... I padded it by an hour!