Main Menu
Menu

Show posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Show posts Menu

Messages - tonymy01

#631
When we complained about the timers being one hour out, ICE said it was because the Beyonwiz wasn't DST aware.   Thus I have to assume they send the timers as GMT, as there is no other way this problem could happen (as once the timers are created, the Wiz stores them in local time too, thus why my own daily timer didn't alter by one hour when I fixed the GMT offset for the clock).
I am guessing your statement was somewhat rhetorical, possibly questioning the way ICE does things.
The good thing about being GMT for timers is there is no question about what to do at 2am Sunday morning of the DST transition (as there is two 2ams when DST ends).   But I reckon for sure they should also provide the GMT offset to the timers in the protocol also, so that PVRs don't have to have a tonne of logic to apply different rules when creating timers before and after a transition.
Regards
#632
Ok, this has mucked me up yet again, something MUST be done about this.
I have a series record setup for "Californication" on TenHD.   I don't have a red dot for Sunday night, ahh, I see it is only on TenSD this week.    No problems, with the widget, I choose to series record the only episode of Californication this week.   Nope.  Nothing.    I go to the web page instead of the widget, search for Californication, choose to series record "this channel".  Nope.  Nothing.
Then a small synapse clicked "ahh, because I have a series record for the TenHD version, it might be rejecting my attempts to create one for the TenSD version".... and sure enough, in a grey bar at the top of the guide webpage, a "error: already a series recording in place" message is there.    You really need to put these errors in a pop-up, or next to the guide entry that you are attempting to create a series record for, since this was down the bottom of the web page that I was trying to create the recording, but the error was way up the top of the web page.
You also really need to have another preference, that if the show appears on both SD and HD, to choose one or the other, not both.   Then I can either choose "all channels" in confidence that I am not taking up two recording slots for the same show, or choose some kind of new option "record on this channel unless not on this channel this week but on the other channel" (I have a sneaking suspicion this option won't be considered  ;))
I am a fairly clued up person, and even I struggle with the interface quirks of ICE. 

example1:
Try to setup a series record for a show.   No red dot appears.  What is going on?   Ahh, I set it up for first runs, and this show is marked as a repeat.   I don't know how many times that has stung me!   You should provide a pop-up when initiating a series record that shows what timers are going to be created for the week, and if none, indicate that the current show you have attempted to initiate a series recording from is a repeat when you are asking for 1st runs.

example2:
All my timers for this week (created prior to DST changover) were all an hour too early.   Ok, so you send the timers to the PVR (in my case, Beyonwiz) in GMT.   Ouch, not many (none?) PVRs have logic to know exactly "ok, I will add 10hours to the timers this week, but I can see the transition is this Sunday, so any timers I create for after that transition time I will add 11hours to".   Can you please also add a GMT offset to your protocol, and work with the PVR teams to read this extra protocol info.   Of course you may already do this, but with no explanation of your protocol to date, I have no idea how it is meant to behave.    Your FAQ says to this problem "you need to resend your timers from this page"... so I deleted all the incorrect timers from the Beyonwiz timer interface, go to the ICE page to resend all timers, initiate the option and zip, nothing.   No timers got resent (well, maybe 3 timers out of about 30 and in about 6 days time!).   So I tried the "resend on Beyonwiz device" and "resend on all devices" about 4 or 5 times in 2 days.   Still not all timers re-appeared.   I had to see my shows were coming up in the Widget or Web (with no red dots!!), and ICE interactive knows there is series recordings setup for these shows (as I can't create a new series recording for them) so I have the option of "record" and this worked about 90% of the time.

example3:
May be related partially to example2.   It seems that if you want to make a change to a series recording, everything gets itself in a twist for that week.  It normally takes a week for it to iron out whatever the heck the quirk is.   Typically you delete a series record, then change your mind or want to make it a specific channel instead of all channels, and attempting to get ICE interactive to get that cute little red dot again on the show in nearly impossible.   If only the red dots could be as reliable as the Yellow Love hearts.  These little things are 100% reliable on my "favourites".


Something is not right, and needs more work.   Please don't try and pin all the blame on the STB manufacturer.   Sure, if you send timers in GMT, then the STB manufacturer should really think ahead about what happens during transition time, but given I haven't come across a STB that handles the DST transition seamlessly as yet (ok, I have managed to make the 5K do this by creating a TAP that uses timezone code and the TZ tables... but that is an exception), and you can read dozens of posts on dtvforums about broadcasters mucking up TOT and/or TDT tables, the chances of a STB getting the correct information for DST transition is slim at best.

I hope these points get considered, I think all of them have come up in the past in one way or another, sometimes I get a tad frustrated by the fragileness of the ICE interface and the lack of feedback about why something isn't behaving the way I expect it to, and also the lack of knowing how the whole protocol is really meant to behave for initiating and updating timers from Interactive to the PVR.

Regards
Tony
#633
Topfield / Re: Reloading
October 08, 2008, 10:14:47 PM
http://www.icetv.com.au/index.php?topic=1309.0
ICE have stated about 3 times in the last day or so, that the 7100 is NOT working properly as yet.  There is a f/w in testing that fixes most of the issues that you need to speak to Topfield about.
Regards
#634
IceTV EPG Content / Re: Good Game, ABC2 Sydney
October 06, 2008, 11:20:53 PM
I wasn't going to post into this thread, but you Mitch has posted something quite similar to what I was going to suggest, so I may as well add my 2.02cents.   I have seen plenty of complaints about TiVo over on dtvforums.info forums with similar issues about show names, recordings missed, padding not enough for some shows etc etc, so all the same issues really as using any form of "guide" that comes from the broadcasters that tend to not follow their own guide.
Regards
#635
See Daniel, if you detailed your protocol in full we can lay the blame to the appropriate people.   So what you are saying is that the timers that ICE send the PVR are in GMT only.   This is a recipe for problems as it means the PVR has to not only auto adjust for DST, but to understand that "this timer is in 4 days time, which is 2 days after the DST transition, and thus I have to adjust the time for the entry with an extra hour".
If the protocol for how timers were determined, updated, deleted, uploaded, we might have some idea about how to get the best out of interactive.    I deleted all my timers on the Wiz and ICE interactive simply refuses to update the timers now (and I followed the FAQ on how to go into your account details and trigger the timers to get resent.    It has only sent about 4 timers and I had about 24timers, including sending 2 timers for last night).
So this whole mess needs some more thought I think.   Probably your timers, if they are sent in GMT time, should also have a GMT offset info to be sent with the timer info, and the PVR can use this offset info to determine what time to set the timer for.
Regards
#636
Just be warned everyone!   My beyonwiz timers for this week, all the ones created by ICE prior to last night, are all one hour too early.   Only timers created today are correct.    So it looks like ICETV uses a fixed GMT offset and doesn't adjust the offset "in advance" for DST.    So you need to delete all your timers and get them resent, and then everything is back to normal.
It certainly wasn't adjusting the Wiz clock by one hour that has anything to do with this, as I have a daily "wakeup" timer for 4am that is still at 4am.    So it is clearly timers set by ICE interactive that obviously used a 10hour offset despite the timers being for a time when the 11hour offset should be in place.   Once the DST transition happened, it appears that ICE interactive correctly uses an 11hour offset.
Regards
#637
It is nothing to do with the iphone.   This has everything to do with ICE's "this channel" vs "all channels" option, which is the same for the Webpage and the Widget.   If you select "all channels" (which you have to do for Dexter to catch all HD eps as it chops and changes from SD&NoHD to SD+HD).    This has been discussed ad-infinitum in other threads, and ICE is suprisingly stone cold on it.    We have all been screaming out for a "HD vs SD" type preference for when shows are dual-cast, with not much reaction from the ICE people.
#638
I think somewhere in a FAQ it will mention something along the lines of "it is up to how your PVR deals with it", as ICE don't know if you have one, two or 4 tuners for example.
Regards
#639
Yep, I like that feature.   I tried to use this as an argument against Neins ludicrous court case that they can *gain* valuable info out of ICE about what people *really* watch, rather than trying to kill ICE and then learn nothing, but was laughed off when I suggested this.   Also without ICEtv guide info for the litigous broadcasters, we are less likely to watch shows from said broadcaster, which they would learn when seeing their shows dissapearing from the "popular shows" lists in ICEtv.   And the reason for Terminator2 TSCC being #1:  Because the clowns kept moving it, it was the only way to ensure it would be recorded by setting it up in interactive (not to mention interactive with the Beyonwiz came live about that time).
#640
Topfield / Re: Should Toppie be on 24x7
September 24, 2008, 07:45:01 PM
As per my post, a wakeup or VCR timer.
#641
Topfield / Re: iPhone and Toppy 500
September 24, 2008, 12:07:54 AM
500?  Do you mean 5000?   There are other options that can still use ICE data to set timers on the 5K, have you looked at the Topfield forums?    Toppyweb, PerlTGD, TED/S.   Someone has even written a pretty nice iphone app to do the Toppyweb like stuff.
Regards
#642
Topfield / Re: Should Toppie be on 24x7
September 24, 2008, 12:04:22 AM
For my Beyonwiz and 5K, I have a daily wakeup timer for 15mins at 4am which will at least get any changes for the day or later in the week through (without recording to the HDD.  Also called a VCR timer).   Obviously if you are out later in the day and want to do a timer for something that night, this won't update to the unit unless it turns on for a timer, but I never need to do this (touch wood).
Regards
#643
General Discussions / Re: Why the repeated EPG entries
September 23, 2008, 04:52:26 PM
Do you mean this: http://www.icetv.com.au/index.php?topic=1285.0 ??  Your post is a bit confusing, I am not sure what you are seeing and where.
#644
Beyonwiz / Re: Duplicate Recordings
September 22, 2008, 09:11:43 PM
We have all been screaming out about getting a preference system in, but ICE are slow to advance their product at the moment for obvious reasons.    I have an issue with "Dexter" on "any channel" too.   I have to leave it like this because I want to record it in HD if it is available in HD, but when the MotoGP is on or F1, TenHD ditches Dexter for the motor racing, and thus for these weeks I need to record the SD channel instead of the HD.   So I keep it at "all" rather than fixed to a particular channel, but when Ten dual-casts the SD and HD version of the show, I have to manually delete the 10SD timer.   Bloody annoying that ICE behaves like this.   Also my friend who just got a wiz was asking why he often had 2 recordings of the same show, ICE shouldn't be setting dual simultaneous timers like this, as it confuses noobs.   If the preference is to have HD shows listed, I reckon it should be to record the HD version of the show by default, and if ICE would (please) like to add an option in the setup, then for sure have a priority preference for SD over HD or vice-versa.
Regards
#645
Beyonwiz / Re: Duplicate Recordings
September 19, 2008, 03:13:15 PM
The explanation is quite obvious.  You have setup ICE to record the show on "Any channel" which means that if the show is dual cast on both SD and HD, you will end up recording both.   You have to reset your series setups to only record on one channel rather than any channel.
For the existing timers in the Wiz, just go thru the timer list and cull the SD or HD shows you don't want recorded.
Regards