Main Menu
Menu

Show posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Show posts Menu

Messages - Mark

#16
Windows Media Center / Re: Crash due to multiple logins
November 30, 2009, 09:21:04 AM
I have multiple user accounts on my Vista MCE box, and my solution to avoiding the possibility of multiple, potentially conflicting, copies of Interactive running is as follows.

I have one user account dedicated to running Interactive (and any other programs that require a terminal session, rather than running as a service).  I also have the PC set up to autologin to this account at startup.  I then have a BAT file that includes a 10 second pause, followed by the "tsdiscon.exe" command (which disconnects the active terminal session and returns to the appropriate login screen - same result as "switch user"), which I have added to the "Startup" program group.  I added the pause after finding that otherwise I would sometimes end up with a blank screen on the terminal session, as if the desktop had failed to initialise, and the pause seems to prevent this.

With this setup, upon reboot the machine starts up into the dedicated account, starts Interactive, and then automatically returns to the login screen.  All other user accounts are set up not to run Interactive on login.  This way, whenever the machine is restarted I always end up with exactly one instance of Interactive running, without requiring any "normal" user to be permanently logged in.  Works perfectly.  (I also have the machine scheduled for an automatic weekly reboot, disk check, defrag, and a few other housekeeping tasks, starting 5.30am Mondays.)

Really, Interactive should be set up to run as a service, with the user program just being a configuration interface that communicates with the service process.  But that's not how it is, so you need to have a user permanently logged in.

I can provide more details, if needed, on exactly how I set all this up in Vista.  I am sure the same result can be achieved in Windows 7, but it is possible that some of the details may be different.
#17
IceTV EPG Content / Double episodes (eg Heroes on 7TWO)
November 05, 2009, 09:24:22 AM
I am wondering if I am the only one who would prefer that double episodes be included in the EPG as a single two-hour entry, rather than two separate one-hour entries?

The problem with double entries, on Vista MCE at least and possibly on other systems, is that you do not necessarily get the recordings that you want.  For example, I have two tuners, and if I have no other simultaneous recordings then I will get two separate recorndings that split at some random point in the program (since the TV channels do not run to time).  There is overlap between the two also, because of the padding that has to be set on the series recording to ensure that the end of the second episode is not cut off!  I would really much rather have one single continuous recording of the entire double episode.

Worse is if I have a simultaneous recording on another channel (eg last night City Homicide on 7 at the same time as the first episode of Heroes on 7TWO).  Using MCE soft padding is not an option, because its scheduler is a bit brain dead, and quite likely to decide to use the same tuner for City Homicide and the second episode of Heroes, cutting off the end of City Homicide (which is, of course, running late).

My current workaround is to set up the series recording for Heroes in MCE with 90 minutes of hard padding, and for City Homicide with 15 minutes of hard padding.  The first episode of Heroes schedules to record, and covers the second episode as well, while the second episode fails to schedule due to the clash with City Homicide.  Problem is that I can't set hard padding through Interactive (which is the main reason I don't use it -- soft padding in MCE is useless), and the whole method is based upon knowing when the programs are scheduled so that I can set the right paddings to ensure that everything I want gets recorded in full, which partly defeats the purpose of having an EPG since I might just as well be setting the timers manually.

Admittedly, this problem can arise any time two programs are scheduled to record consecutively on the same channel, but could be avoided in the case of double episodes by including them in a single EPG entry.  I imagine this is only viable if both episodes also have the same "repeat" status (ie both repeats, or both first-run).
#18
Sounds like your problem is not time setting, just that Aus TV channels do not run to schedule!  Trying to set your clock to the wrong time is not a solution to this problem.

I have been led to understand that Windows 7 Media Center lets you set higher padding values than previous versions, but initial beta versions of the IceTV Interactive app limit you to 2mins.  IceTV are trying to fix this -- see the main topic "Beta IceTV Interactive for Windows 7 available" in the "Interactive on Windows 7" discussion forum for more info.
#19
Quote from: tonymy01 on November 02, 2009, 12:15:11 PM
But Mark, where are you located?  Some dodgy broadcasters don't know their system very well (I was going to say something else related to human anatomy, but decided to leave that one out  :) ), and often do silly things like adjust the GMT clock instead of the localtime/GMT offset when DST kicks in, or simply don't setup the NTP properly on their broadcast systems.  A few years ago, even in Sydney, Nein was 15minutes out for about a week!
But now in Sydney I notice it is very good, they have finally got their act together here, regionals may not be so good in this area yet.
Regards

I'm in Melbourne.  But if the problem is that individual broadcasters can't set their clocks correctly, then there is no viable solution.  An NTP server synced to one dodgy station would still be wrong for all the others!  The best you could do is to ensure that your PC clock is correct, and then ignore anything coming in on the digital broadcasts.  I understand that Windows 7 Media Center can read the in-band EPG data, but have not seen it myself, and don't know whether it also tries to make some use of in-band time information, or if this is part of the problem here.

Maybe if the original poster could elaborate a little on the problem -- how do the PC time and the broadcast times compare with the actual time (i.e. as obtained by calling 1194)?
#20
IceTV EPG Content / Re: Seven's new channel: 72
November 02, 2009, 03:11:55 PM
Quote from: Neon Kitten on November 02, 2009, 12:31:27 AM
What, if anything, is being done in the wake of the recent court decision in favour of IceTV to ensure that situations like this don't happen in the future?

And not to anyone from Seven who might be reading: if there was something on I might have wanted to see but I miss the first episodes because your program listing is "copyright", then that's just another show added to the torrent list.

There is no reason why anything should or would be done about this.  The commercial channels are only trying to protect their business model as best they can.  You might want to bear in mind that this is the same business model that provides you and I with free-to-air commercial television in the first place, and you can't expect to have you cake and eat it too.

The High Court has ruled (quite rightly IMHO) that copyright subsists in program schedules.  This is perfectly reasonable: the schedules do not just "exist" for anyone to discover, and do with as they wish, they are created by those people at the various networks whose job it is to select programs, and to decide when and where they will be broadcast.  They are original works, in the sense required by the Copyright Act.  So copying the whole of someone's schedule, or a substantial part of it, is an infringement of copyright.

However, the High Court has also ruled (again quite rightly IMHO, and in favour of IceTV who took the fight all the way to the top) that the "time and title" information of individual programs within a schedule are not a sufficiently substantial part of the whole work to sustain a case for infringement.  Thus if, like IceTV, you have independently constructed a complete program guide without copying the schedule, it is OK to correct a few individual entries by reference to the schedule.

The commercial channels are free to license their schedules to any other party they wish (including IceTV) on whatever terms (including for a fee) that they see fit.  Or they can refuse to do so, and take legal action against any infringers.  As I understand it, the reason they are reluctant to work with third party EPG suppliers such as IceTV is because, in general, PVRs make it too easy for viewers to avoid exposure to commercials, either via "30 second skip" buttons and/or more sophisticated measures.  This obviously kills the major source of revenue to commercial free-to-air networks.

As you may know, the Australian TiVo PVR has access to a licensed EPG, but the trade-off is that it had to hop into bed with Seven, and does not include the most convenient commercial-skipping functionality.

You might think that in the age of broadband internet, the commercial free-to-air networks are dinosaurs in danger of extinction if they cannot come up with new revenue models, and you might be right (time will tell).  But the problem is that the most vocal objectors seem unwilling to pay in other ways for the content.  If you think that your alternative to 7TWO is an (illegal) free download, then I would ask you who is going to pay to create and distribute the content you love so much once there are no networks left that are willing or able to buy it?  The best information available on the internet suggests that many one-hour action series cost well in excess of US$1M per episode to make.  A whole season is thus on a par with a modest Hollywood movie, and someone has to have a good business case before they will bankroll that.

The situation is not even as bad as you make out.  There has been a full schedule on the 7TWO web site for over a week already.  The schedule is also in all of this week's papers.  And the in-band EPG on 7TWO is complete.  So what is stopping you from manually setting your recordings for a couple of weeks while IceTV gets its EPG data up and running?
#21
There should not be a problem with synchonisation between station broadcasts and Windows time, if Internet time sync is working properly.  The Internet time function in Windows is based upon the Network Time Protocol (NTP), which is ultimately referenced to one of a relatively small number of "stratum-1" time servers around the world which maintain extremely accurate clocks.  Worst-case performance for NTP these days should set your clock to within about 100 milliseconds of the correct time.  

My observation of the times transmitted with the networks digital broadcasts is that they are accurate.  I am running two recorders: Windows Vista MCE with IceTV and Internet time synchronisation, and a Topfield PVR (without IceTV EPG) which syncs to the incoming broadcast time.  Despite having read some reports of temporary anomalies in broadcast times throwing off the Topfield clock, I have never seen this phenomenon myself.  Both recorders keep perfect and consistent time (to the level of accuracy that I can manually observe).  A few minutes' discrepancy is a lot, and suggests something wrong at your end.

I have no experience with Windows 7, but you might want to check that your internet time sync is working properly.  When your system time seems to be out, open the date and time properties panel, and go to the "Internet time" tab, then go to "Change settings".  If the time server is set to "time.microsoft.com" you might want to change it to use a more local source.  Your ISP probably runs a time server (Optus provides time.optusnet.com.au, for example).  This shouldn't make much difference, because NTP is designed to compensate for network delay and jitter, but you never know.  Then click "Update now" to see if this corrects the time.  If so, then the problem may be that you local system clock suffers from excessive drift.  By default, the Windows time sync runs only once per week, so if your clock gains (for example) one minute per day, it will be out by seven minutes by the time it is again synchronised.

If clock drift is a problem, then the proper solution is to get it fixed/replaced -- your PC clock should not be so inaccurate!  

However, as a temporary fix you can alter the time sync frequency via the Registry (at least in Win 2000/XP/Vista -- hopefully this is the same in Win7).  Navigate to the following key in the Registry:

HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SYSTEM\CurrentControlSet\Services\W32Time\TimeProviders\NtpClient

Right click on 'SpecialPollInterval' in the right hand column and select Modify>Decimal.  The decimal number is in seconds.  For example, "3600" will cause your system to synchronise every hour.  Then go back and "Update now" again, to shift onto the new schedule.

As always, before messing with the Registry it is wise to backup or create a restore point before proceeding.
#22
IceTV EPG Content / Re: Seven's new channel: 72
October 31, 2009, 05:19:57 PM
Quote from: Daniel Hall at IceTV on October 30, 2009, 05:44:55 PM

Excellent news, the way its been added this time should mean we won't have all the problems in MCE that happened in previous new channels.


Daniel -- kudos and thank you to all responsible for looking into this issue.  Addition of the new channel could not have been smoother on Vista MCE this time out.  I enabled channel 72 about a week ago (when it was still called "7 digital 2" according to MCE), and of course it has just been saying no data available all week.  But as soon as the guide data became available I see it has renamed to "7TWO", and the EPG data automatically associated with it!  I have done literally nothing and it is all working perfectly.

Nice job!  ;D
#23
General Discussions / Re: I am confused!
August 07, 2009, 08:55:49 AM
I have the same issue, and missed The Simpsons on Wednesday because of it.  I have posted in the forum for Vista Media Center, but it seems that nobody else cares  :)

The issue seems to arise because of the way that Microsoft has implemented guide listings in MCE.  There is nothing Ice can do about this, but given that it is predictable and unavoidable a bit of advance warning would be nice (is anyone at Ice listening?!)

In addition to channel numbers and names, MCE maintains an internal "ServiceID" number.  This is just an index number for each listing in the guide, as far as I can tell.  This index number seems to be used as the "key" for scheduled recordings.  So if somebody inserts a new channel listing into the guide, the index numbers of all listings after the insertion increase by one.  For all existing scheduled recordings affected by this change, the index numbers will no longer match the other information (eg the channel name/number), and this causes MCE not to schedule the recordings at all.  However, if you look at your scheduled series recordings, everything appears OK and there is no obvious reason why the recordings are not happening.

In this case, ABC1/2, Seven and Nine all precede the new GO data in the guide, so scheduled recordings for these channels are OK.  But Ten and SBS ONE/TWO (at least) are "above" the inserted channel, and thus all scheduled recordings on these channels fail.  You can see all this stuff in the Recordings.xml file (in my case, for example, Ten went from ServiceID=13 to ServiceID=14).

The only sure-fire fix is to go back and set up your guide listings from scratch again.  Once you have done this, all your series recordings will still be there, but the "corrupted" ones will now be set to record on the wrong channels.  You need to cancel and reschedule each one of these to reassociate them with the correct channel.

I am not sure if it is possible, but if new channel listings could be added to the end of the guide, rather than in the middle, then the transition would probably be a lot less disruptive for us poor MCE users...
#24
I noticed tonight that all of my series recordings on Ten Digital and SBS TWO (set within MCE) have disappeared from the schedule.

I then noticed that GO! has been added to the Ice guide.

Coincidence?  I am guessing not -- we saw this last time there was a change with the renaming of SBS ONE and TWO.

It's great that the new channel has been added, but how about some warning guys?!  Changes to the guide mess with MCE.  Whether this is Microsoft's fault, or Ice's, we need to know it's happening so we can fix it before we start missing our favorite shows!  Like tonight's episode of The Simpsons :(

I see another evening of cancelling and rescheduling all my series recordings ahead of me...  After I've finished rescanning and resetting all my guide linkages.

Mark
#25
Mitch, there are lots of things that cost less than the price of a cup of coffee.  This is not a universal standard of value!  By the time I have paid all my insurance premiums, ambulance subscription, utlility bills, and everything else which is advertised as costing "less than the pice of a cup of coffee per day/week/whatever", I could be swimming in virtual coffee!  However, whatever the price of the service, it would be preferable that there not be errors in the Melbourne guide data due to mucking around up in Sydney and against all evidence and information available to those of us actually located in Melbourne!
#26
Thanks for your comments, Mitch.  I can appreciate your "damned if you do, damned if you don't" problem with posting responses on these forums.

But even so, your reasoning does not seem very sound, at least for those of us iin Melbourne (and probably elsewhere).  You say Channel 7 did a swap on you earlier in the week.  I don't know what you consider to be a "primary" source of information, but for we Melbourne viewers there was never any indication of a swap -- not in the Age's Green Guide, not in the Sunday Age's M Magazine, not in the daily papers, and not in Channel 7's own transmitted EPG.

But you guys are based in Sydney, right?  Hmmm...

"Impact" is right.  IceTV has done the hard yards, and spent the big bucks, to pave the way for other providers.  Now that the High Court has had its say, it is only a matter of time before you face real competition.  I am sure that many of us would love to keep supporting the innovator, but $100 per year is too much just for program guide data (especially if it is unreliable).  IceTV justifies the higher charges by adding value through the "Interactive" features, which is a good business model if people want those features, and they work reliably. 

But there has not been any update to the IceTV Interactive application for well over a year, despite niggling bugs and limitations, such as the ongoing "corrupted cache" problem in Windows, intermittent failures of the Media Center extended padding feature, the fact that Interactive does not perform a "true" synchronisation with the server (ie it makes a difference whether a series recording was originally scheduled via the web on in MCE, and if you do both your scheduled recordings can end up in a bit of a mess), and the fact that you cannot view or set hard padding values via the web (use of hard padding is pretty much essential, given the Australian channels' inability to run programs to schedule).

I have been through the free trial period, and I am currently still taking it one month at a time and continuing to evaluate the service.  I have experienced all of the above issues during the past 2-3 months, and I know it is not just me because I have searched these forums and found the same problems discussed time and again.  On top of this, the recent change in the SBS channel names caused a complete mess.  I realise that this was not really IceTV's fault (SBS did not announce the change, and the corruption of all of my series settings was due to poor design in Media Center), the the management and communication around this change was sub-standard for a commercial service provider charging premium rates.

I am currently running with the Interactive features disabled, and my setup is now stable and predictable (unreliable EPG data notwishstanding).  But I am really questioning the value for money of this setup.  If I could get this same basic service for a lower price, I would take it.  I know I can put together a "home brew" solution for free, but this creates separate issues of reliability and ongoing maintenance (avoiding this is what you pay for, surely).

#27
I think that SBS changed its digital channel names (to "SBS ONE" and "SBS TWO") over the weekend, which apparently caused me to lose all guide information for SBS, in turn resulting in my SBS series recordings all reporting no upcoming programs.

To fix this, I had to go back to "Add Guide Listings to Channel" and relink the "new" SBS ONE and SBS TWO to "SBS" and "SBS 2".  Even then, my existing SBS series recordings did not pick up their programs from the guide even after two days of guide updates, so I re-entered all of my SBS series recordings and deleted the originals.  (All of these recordings were set up in MCE, I do not currently use Interactive to set or maintain recordings.)

All now seems to be OK again, but I was surprised that this happened given that there has been no change in the digital channel numbers.  If I had not noticed, or had been away, then all of my SBS series recordings would have been missed.

Has anybody else had this problem?  Could there something wrong with my setup that has caused this, or are we really all at the mercy of the broadcasters -- if they change their channel names, we lose our guide data?!