Main Menu
Menu

Show posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Show posts Menu

Messages - mtb

#106
Anyone else seen this, I picked it up on Google alerts.

http://www.smarthouse.com.au/Content_And_Downloads/Industry/L8W5N7C2

Interesting reading...
#107
IceTV EPG Content / Re: rage: 20 Years Of rage
April 30, 2007, 12:23:01 AM
Thanks for the info. folks - I recorded both the late night shows for good measure.  The playlist URL is very useful too, some good stuff in there.

Thanks again.
#108
IceTV EPG Content / rage: 20 Years Of rage
April 27, 2007, 10:10:30 PM
The last four weeks on ABC, we have had "rage: 20 Years Of rage" as a five hour slot across midnight of Friday/Saturday - this week it starts at midnight and is just called rage.  There is, however a one hour "20 years..." slot now appearing on Saturday mornings at 08:00.

I know that this is the same details shown on other TV guides (so it isn't your fault) but could someone please clarify if the ABC have stopped the "20 years..." five hour show or just stopped calling it "20 years..." or whatever?

Thanks
#109
...to everyone at Ice.  Just wanted to get in early and pass on our best wishes for the season.

Here's to Santa bringing you a nice "case dismissed" regarding Nein and hoping that 2007 will be a far more prosperous one for you all.

We'll be thinking of you as our Toppy happily records all those wonderful new Christmas specials... oh, alright... old repeats over the Christmas break, courtesey of Ice data and TED/S.
#110
IceTV EPG Content / Re: Vanished - ch7 - Mondays
December 09, 2006, 11:46:02 PM
Quote from: impact on December 09, 2006, 11:24:14 PM
Im not interested in the icetv is nearly broke argument

Sounds to me like nothing Ice can do, nor anyone else suggests, will satisfy you, you might as well put yourself out of their misery - just ask for a refund on your subscription and use one of those other wonderfully reliable(!) data sources.
#111
IceTV EPG Content / Re: Vanished - ch7 - Mondays
December 09, 2006, 10:09:03 PM
Ok, so you're unable to use TED/S, it doesn't change the facts relating to the validity of the content.

Quote from: impact on December 09, 2006, 08:28:29 PM
In this case mentioned - Vanished - QA is non existant.

Given the fact that the networks love to change timeslot/day/week!/duration/title themselves from week to week, I should truly love to see how you would specify the validation algorithm of content for a particular timeslot.  Whether reported to the data entry operator or to a summary report at the end is irrelevant, the validation processing of such items would be identical - the only difference is if it is in-process or post-process.  Bearing in mind that you could not rely on previous weeks, times, durations or other attributes of the title or program details to accurately extrapolate a valid lookup-set to match against since the networks love to move days and times, change seasons (and therefore titles), drop mid-season, miss a week and double up slots.

To produce such an almost heuristic matching would require significant development time and money, things Ice has neither of in abundant supply, you also have to ensure that the speed of operation of the data entry system does not become so impeded by the validation routines that it impairs the data entry operation - a fine balance to attain and one few manage to properly achieve.  Post processing simply shifts the effort but doesn't reduce it

Consider the programme "Survivor" which contains varying elements in the title from season to season (locations, I think).  Are you suggesting that this valid component of the title be dropped?  To do so would make the data more inaccurate than accurate since you would be unable to distinguish between different series/seasons; your "Vanished" example is effectively the same thing - you again expect the data entry personal to be able to distinguish between the relevant and the irrelevant content of all titles.

I am well aware of the Ice/Nein information and the manner in which the data was originally created, I too have been following the case and reading the blogs and forums.  Nonetheless, given the now larger number of regions and so on, the 'push-a-button copy' process will still have a significant variation each week which must be catered for.  Your idea of having someone sign-off the data?  I'm sure someone already does... but not after reading through all of it, for all channels and regions, even the differences would be significant particularly now we are in the summer silly season when schedules change almost daily!  I'm sure Ice have procedures in place to try to minimise errors as best they can but only within the limitations of their manpower and funding.

By the same token that you consider that Ice could produce or commission such a validation system (given funds they don't have), I would say that it is not impossible to intercept and 'clean/validate' the Ice data en-route to the media centre.  It does, after all, arrive via a known protocol through a known port on the box.  There is no reason why a suitably knowledgable and motivated MCE equiped developer could not simply take that Ice data in on a different box (or perhaps the same), validate and clean it (according to the much smaller requirement set of the individual user) then send it back out in an identical format (to the original) to the media centre. 

Such an approach has been used for years for interfacing between apparently totally incompatible systems, screen scraping was one term for it - during the lead up to Y2K it was commonplace, as it was during the original PC 'revolution' in the 80/90's for interfacing between PC systems and mainframes;  I've done it many times for both scenarios. 

Ice would, I am sure, be very happy to spend their customers' money on developing solutions to validate and verify their data and improve the service they are currently providing.  Unfortunately, the Nein fiasco stopped them from raising the much needed capital for such improvements and instead they must waste it on lawyers.  Given the shoestring they're operating on as a result I think they provide a damned good service for $1.50 a week because, at the end of the day, 90% accurate data would be better than no data at all.
#112
IceTV EPG Content / Re: Vanished - ch7 - Mondays
December 09, 2006, 05:03:49 PM
Due to the way that Ice data is collated (i.e. manually enter by people, not computer), until the stations provide consistant data themselves in an electronic form, there will always be the opportunity for errors.  While I agree that inconsistancies are annoying, consider how someone entering the data who doesn't watch a particular programme could be certain of the correct title/details to use if the data source they get the data from is equally inconsistant.  These are the same poor titles that appear in the TV Guides and papers.

This manual collation of data is a highly intensive, repetative and boring manual task and to increase the number of people checking the data to reduce such problems would undoubtedly increase the cost of the service and undermine its financial viability.  I work in I.T. and, believe me, ALL data entry IS prone to errors. 

Personally I think that Ice do a remarkable job, given that there are seven or so channels of data, 24/7, with all the regional variations from a varienty of sources - as a percentage of that, the number of errors are very small.  They also have to operate within tighter financial constraints that they ought, due to the Channel Nein farce.  I say Nice One IceTV!

Jason W, I cannot agree that the guide is only for machine consumption - we used our Toppy for quite a while with Ice and the EPG only and simply browsed for the programmes we wanted, the main guide data is for human consumption as well.

As it happens, since I now use TED/S to process the data I would not have been impacted by either of the problems you have given, since I would have searched for "vanished" and/or "dancing with the stars" - both would have been found and timers set accordingly (if we watched either of them).  Despite the functionality of TED/S, however, I do still check the future timers and EPG on a fairly daily basis as I acknowledge that the data might not be perfect - but then, I've seen errors in the Now and Next data the stations provide themselves so that's nothing new.

Perhaps you should both have a look at TED/S as a cheap way of complementing the Ice data and providing a far higher level of confidence that your desired programmes will get recorded.
#113
IceTV EPG Content / Re: Daylight Savings in WA
December 06, 2006, 11:43:56 PM
I can't comment on the Mac widget but the Ice data IS correct on XP if you correctly set daylight savings on, so you'll have to find another solution Chris.  I still have to disable D.S.T. before sync'ing my Xda then re-enable it before TED/S runs to load the Topfield.  Crazy, but it works.  Surely someone has a D.S.T. patch for the W.A. based Mac by now?

Satch, the data is right so Ice can't fix something which isn't broken.  I'm afraid if you haven't patched your XP or are using something else, you'll have to live with it or modify the data yourself.
#114
IceTV EPG Content / Re: Daylight Savings in WA
December 04, 2006, 11:12:44 PM
Quote from: whitford on December 04, 2006, 10:31:10 PM
Daylight saving basically stuff up all my recordings. The guide is "correct", but the "recording is not". For example: The guide: Seven news: start at 6.00. But under scheduled recording, Seven news start at 7.00 (not at 6.00 as it is written on the guide).
I had that problem on a number of occasions during the 'trying' times yesterday but seem to have got over it at last with a heap of fiddling.  I'm running the taps listed in my sig. (with some version changes), what taps are you running?  Maybe we can nut it out between us.  I don't think it's Ice's fault, it's those damned pollies...

Edit: Ah, wrong forum... no sig.!!  Ok, taps are latest of... EPG_Uploader, Improbox, JustEPG, ProgressBarKeys, Subtitle Switch, TimerExtend, TSRCommander
#115
IceTV EPG Content / Re: Daylight Savings in WA
December 03, 2006, 09:57:41 PM
Quote from: poedgirl on December 03, 2006, 05:19:59 PM
Is it just me or are all the shows an hour out on TV right now? All day today the shows have been an hour out (according to the IceTV guide).
I'm having a similar problem.  I can't apply the D.S.T. because  is screws up my 250+ appointments but this appears to be screwing up the data by an hour - I'm using TED/S by the way.  This whole D.S.T. thing is soooo ove-rated, we and neighbours have already had no end of problems with the kids wanting to stay up because it's still light.
#116
IceTV EPG Content / Re: Daylight Savings in WA
December 03, 2006, 11:33:04 AM
Well, whoopie-****ing-doo! Here we are seven (or eight) hours in good old W.A. daylight saving territory and already it has totally ****ed up all my Outlook appointments!

If I apply the MS patch, they all shift by an hour but if I don't all my timezones are out - great, just bloody great!  Probably they'd say, if I were running all the latest and greatest software from them, it wouldn't be a problem but I'm damned if I'm going to feed MS until I die!

Three times in the last thirty years the W.A. people have rejected D.S.T. and still business and the government ram it down our throats. I just hope that the people have the sense to stick it back where it belongs in three years time!

For those who argue that it helps business trade with the Eastern states... one hour, so what, we're still out by two, we're a big country... live with it!
#117
IceTV EPG Content / Re: Daylight Savings in WA
November 26, 2006, 12:18:27 AM
Quote from: Daniel Hall on November 23, 2006, 11:39:53 AM
...it appears that Microsoft should have an official update out in time for the change...
I hope they make a better job of it than they did for the Commonwealth Games!
#118
IceTV EPG Content / Re: Daylight Savings in WA
November 22, 2006, 11:44:57 PM
For those running XP, there is a patch available from pcguru.com.au which should enable the DST for Perth timezone computers.  For the rest (non-XP) you could try selecting a GMT+8 timezone which has DST enabled, although the only one in XP appears to be a northern hemisphere!
#119
Just ran TED/S again, down to just three items (one SBS and two ABC2) - nicely done folks.
#120
...and just to add further pain, WA will be introducing daylight saving in December - whole concept is stupid if you ask me but this is just plain crazy!