Main Menu
Menu

Show posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Show posts Menu

Topics - coolguns

#1
Windows Media Center / IceTV and Topfield. A review.
October 13, 2008, 01:39:10 PM
I recently brought a topfield TF71000PVR after having it recommended to me. Up until now I have been using the Platinum Foxtel and figured the Topfield wouldn't be much different. Unfortunately, after almost a month of using the Topfield and IceTV EPG my views on this aren't all that spectacular. Compared to the Foxtel, my experience has been a nightmare. Basically I've had nothing but drama's, most of which are technical in nature. By profession, I am a Computer Network Engineer, so tackling issues such as wireless LAN's, Static IP addresses, LAN security, internet connections and PC issues was not about to deter me from spending the time and money to get it all working.

I'd like to state first and foremost, that if you are Mr and Mrs Joe Average then forget it. In order for me to get the Topfield to connect to my wireless LAN I had to resort to the online forums to get advice! In the end I had to update firmware, and strip all the security from my LAN to get the Topfield to connect to it, an exercise that was recommended in the forums. Thankfully, after reconfiguring the wireless security and fiddling around I finally had the Topfield on the network, with security enabled. In fact, had I taken the time to check the forums regarding IceTV and Topfield I may have decided against purchasing it. A good indication of how well a product or service works can be determined by the volume of posts and issues logged on the support forum(s). The IceTV and Topfield forums have thousands upon thousands of posts, mostly from users suffering technical issues. For a service that really hasn't been around that long it sounds a fairly loud warning to consumers.

After getting my connection sorted out I proceeded to take advantage of the free trial to IceTV.  I created an account, setup and tested the interactive connection to my PVR and began testing the TV Guide by scheduling a couple of favourite shows. Then the drama began. The first and probably most disappointing issue arose when I discovered that if my Topfield was in standby mode and I was wanting to schedule a show to record during the day from a remote internet browser, the electronic guide doesn't wake the Topfield to tell it what to do. Foxtel's IQ service doesn't suffer this problem, and it certainly wasn't an issue I'd even considered. In our day and age it was a natural assumption to think that I could use the IceTV interactive service to pick and schedule shows while my unit was in standby mode and expect them to be recorded when I got home.

After realising that I'd either have to leave the Topfield on during the day, or make sure I'd scheduled programs at least 24 hours in advance, I figured that after all the aggravation so far, I'd just have to live with it. I continued to test and evaluate the IceTC service. One morning from my office I scheduled a program to start that evening at 8:30pm. When I got home at around 6pm I turned the Topfield on so that it could pull down my newest schedule. By 6:30 pm, nothing had happened. My scheduled show had not appeared on the timer settings. At 7pm I forced a test connection to IceTV and it wasn't until almost 7:30pm that the show finally appeared. After researching this issue on the forums I discovered that IceTV's guide only updates every 30-60 minutes, longer if the server is busy. So what had I learnt so far? Forget trying to spontaneously schedule upcoming shows to record via the internet. You'll miss them.

The next issues proved to be even more frustating. Using the interactive guide to schedule shows turns out to be hit and miss at best. Show's I hadn't selected started appearing on my Upcoming Shows list. Shows I'd scheduled to record disappeared from the list the next day. I was becoming distressed trying to delete unwanted shows and re-schedule the ones I wanted. In one case, an unwanted show that was scheduled to begin recording the following day would not delete because it insisted it had already been recorded! While that may prove useful recording the horse racing in order to make a killing at the TAB with knowledge from the future, it was proving nothing but a frustration, here in the present.

My overall experience with all of this has obviously been disappointing, and I'm sure I will get flamed from forum users that have not the same experiences I've had. But the simple truth is, well... simple. In my business I'm constantly troubleshooting complex technical issues, and developing, testing and evaluating software. Had I released software to our users that was so frustrating even for an advanced user to navigate, and full of as many bugs, glitches and performance issues as IceTV contains, AND had the nerve to charge a fee for it - my boss would have sacked me.

I barely use the thing now. I'm back to using Foxtel and IQ until I can be sure that IceTV's software and service has progressed beyond the crawling stage and has learnt to stand on its own feet, on its own terms.