Main Menu
Menu

Show posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Show posts Menu

Messages - IcedCoffee

#1
Quote from: prl on January 11, 2008, 12:56:38 PM
I'd guess that owners of the copyright on the Web page would be OK with the automatic highlighting function (and I've no idea whether it would be an infringement). The "and send to a media player" function might well be an infringement,
It seems to me to be a contradiction in the case where the "and send to a media player"  is considered an infringement, but the process where I manually do that step is not considered an infringement.  After all aren't I essentially just a very sophisticated fully programmable machine?  ;D

Quote from: prl on January 11, 2008, 12:56:38 PM
I'd expect, though, that if someone screenscraped the stations' online TV guides and repackaged it for sale as an EPG for PVRs then the stations would be very likely to pursue it. That's a practice that IceTV appears to be being very careful to avoid.
Agreed but what if someone sold a "smart browser"?  The company are not doing the scraping just selling a tool that can be configured to do it.  Of course this gets into all sorts of other debates eg bittorrent, napster, telcos and ISPs being held responsible for content passing through their network etc  The law is still struggling to deal with these examples.
#2
Quote from: prl on January 11, 2008, 10:07:59 AM
What you were proposing in the post I originally replied to was to use a program to transform EPG data into the right format for a PVR. I can't see how this is other than a derivative work. It's certainly not "restat[ing] public information in your own words".

I take your point.  I am just exploring where the line is drawn in the new media.  eg The network's online guide is intended for the public to be viewed in a browser.  In my browser, I may change the fonts, switch off images etc - this is not seen as infringing copyright.  My browser may have other features, eg be smart enough (via a plugin browser helper object) to eg highlight in red, things that interest me - say the name of a show.  (This is not unlike say the Google toolbar that can highlight search words in the page in different colours.)  My browser could be smart enough such that if I click on the names of shows in red, it can send that info to my Media Centre application so it can be recorded.  All the while I was simply using my "smart browser".  

What I am getting at, is at what point am I no longer using a browser and now infringing copyright?  The networks don't specify which browsers I must use or what the browsers functionality should be.  If I were to manually do the steps it is OK but if my browser is smart enough to automate it, I am no longer allowed to use this "smart browser".  I am simply saying that it is interesting that there is a distinction between the two.

Quote from: prl on January 11, 2008, 10:07:59 AM
I don't believe that it is the layout of the guide (alone) that the copyright lies in; it's primarily in the words of the author(s).

Yes OK so if I list a set of formulae such as e=mc2, F= ma, etc even though these are known formulae I can still claim copyright in the list.  If someone now takes that list, and add other formulae and adds descriptions and explanations, I think I would have a very hard time claiming you infringed since my originalwork was a list of facts that I don't own.  

Quote from: prl on January 11, 2008, 10:07:59 AM
The Nine law suit against IceTV shows that the stations definitely regard their program guides as copyright, and as I understand it, IceTV's defense wasn't that Nine had no copyright on its guide, but that the IceTV guide was constructed in such a way that Nine's copyright wasn't infringed.

I agree that this was the position taken by the stations.  I also believe this position relied on the precedent set by the telephone listing case.  In my view I think this position should be challenged as I believe it was in the US where straight telephone listings are apparently not copyright.  It seems to me that Ice TV chose not to challenge whether Channel 9 can have copyright in the listing.  I am guessing they decided it would be harder to win that case then to prove that the guide was constructed independantly and chose the path that gave them the greatest chance of victory.  

Thanks for all the responses to my "layman" arguments.  In truth I generally agree with you and PVogel in relation to the way the law currently stands but enjoyed the opportunity to explore some arguments as some laws, in my view, could be improved to serve the community better.
#3
Quote from: dgaust on January 10, 2008, 08:48:06 PM
Actually I think Telstra won a court decision that said that the White Pages was copyrightable material. So a compilation of facts is copyrightable. In most countries it ain't, but in little old backward Oz it is.
Yeah unfortunately I think that was the precedent I referred to later in my post regarding a list of numbers.  I am still not convinced that it fully translates to the general case that a "list of facts" is copyright though. Consider the example I gave of a newpaper article.  Clearly though for us, we find ourselves in Aus in this strange - I say ridiculous- situation.  As far as I know we are the only country in the world to have copyright in TV listings. 

Oh well, we have a lot of other good things going for us in Aus so the occasional anomaly is to be expected and I guess tolerated.  It still would be nice if we fell into line with the rest of the world though.

Interestingly Tivo will be launched later this year and according to the SMH it will support all the channels.  I wonder if that could lead to an argument that the networks, in only allowing the guide for Tivo and not other providers, are engaging in anti-competitive behaviour.
#4
Quote from: prl on January 10, 2008, 05:53:36 PM
That's (from my limited understanding) exactly one of the sorts of things that copyright law is intended to give the copyright owner control over - the making of derivative works, i.e. making a new version based on the original. The information isn't "freely available". It's copyrighted.

OK I kind of walked into that :D - I'll elaborate a bit more...
Yes from my limited understanding that is the situation however I believe it is relevant where there is copyright material in the first place.     A list of data eg telephone book, list of people who got married, died, born etc is arguably not copyright as it is factual information in the public domain.  A factual news story that appears in a newspaper is a copyright article in the sense that the writer has composed the words around the facts, however the facts themselves are not copyrighted.  If a murder happened, it happened and anyone can write an article about it listing all the facts.  Since the tv list of what is on is a factual list, I don't IMHO think that should be copyrightable.  That is what I meant by comparing my use of the list in an EPG form to that of manually using the list to program the device.  If one is legal then so should the other be.

Certainly the layout of the program is copyright, but then the EPG layout is distinctly different to the listings produced by the networks.  I can see an argument where the descriptions of the program are copyright however, it doesn't seem to me that the local networks write their own descriptions of most of the programs as most are the same as that listed on US sites so if anyone holds copyright in those descriptions it should be the US writers.  Unfortunately it seems that in Aus a legal precedent was set whereby a telephone book's list of phone numbers was considered to be copyright - an opposite precedant was set in the US.

It also seems to me that the info is "freely available" in that it is available from numerous sources not just the network list themselves but the numerous online and offline publications, as well as a listing on the digital guide channels that list the shows of the day and of course by turning on a TV and watching it you will see the program being screened. There is no copyright notice on most if not all of these lists.

From US copyright law "Copyright protects the particular way an author has expressed himself; it does not extend to any ideas, systems, or factual information conveyed in the work.  http://www.copyright.gov/fls/fl102.html

In Australia we have "Fair Dealing" provisions.  A quote from this is If you simply restate public information in your own words, you will not infringe copyright.  http://www.copyright.org.au/pdf/acc/infosheets_pdf/G079.pdf

THis of course is all academic as Ice have taken a position,  Channel 9 have sued and lost but are appealing and Ice's method of compilation it seems is such that they are attempting to compile the info independantly.
#5
Quote
No, the current SD to HD option, applies to several other channels (ABC, Nine, SBS) too. Which would force inaccurate TV guide data for SevenHD and TenHD channels onto those users.

Unless a separate SD to HD option was added, specifically for the SevenHD and TenHD, as suggested elsewhere.

Point taken - as well as the point made later that it is probably not worth the effort for Ice to do a temporary Kludge to add a separate option since the solution is supposedly a few weeks away.  Had they considered the kludge in November however.. it would have given them and us three months of a better option than is currently available. 

I am still intrigued as to how by watching weeks of programming, they can then suddenly be able to predict the future.  I can kind of see that they can predict the next episode in a tv series as they can look at overseas guides that describe episodes (although there have been many times that 7, 9 and 10 have messed up the order of the episodes.)   When it comes to predicting movies, how is it possible to know what the networks are going to screen by guessing?  They have to read it off some guide unless the networks put out some sort of press release of what movies are to be shown in a form which is not copyrighted.

What a ridiculous situation we in Australia find ourselves in ;-)  I as a user can manually look at any tv guide online and manually program my DVR,DVD Rec or VHS machine with that info, but it is not permissible for me or anyone else (Ice) to write a program that extracts that freely available info to automatically program my DVR.  However a judge has ruled that if the same info is compiled by people watching and predicting the info it is then OK.  Sigh.
#6
Quote from: Kirben on January 10, 2008, 10:01:49 AM
Quote from: dgaust on January 10, 2008, 09:47:14 AM
After all, there is only 50 hours of individual programming, and I know when it is (and I daresay Ice do as well by know). Even if they didn't know what shows were going to be broadcast when, just allow us to choose the SD listings to be displayed in the HD channels.

No please don't go back to showing the inaccurate TV guide data, as it will just cause people to have various recording issues again. Especially for movies/series which are mistakenly marked as been shown in HD. Since it still requires checking another TV guide, to be sure the content is actually been shown on the SevenHD or TenHD channels.


I agree with dgaust.  People that do not wish to do this due to the recording issues you mention can simply uncheck the copy SD to HD option and they will continue to get what they get now.  This at least allows those of us that wish to take the risk, the option to do so.